Annual Report 2008-09 - Constitution Committee Contents


APPENDIX 2: PROGRESS OF SCRUTINY


Title Bill Number First discussed[29] Comments Action Cleared
Queen's Speech 17/12/08
Marine and Coastal Access Bill HL 1, 38, 49, 7610/12/08 Concern about lack of appeal procedures in the bill. Report published; agreed that Chairman would table amendments on behalf of the Committee; amendments tabled at Committee stage; Government agreed to table their own amendments which partially met the Committee's concerns; amendments agreed to. X
Local Democracy, Economic Development and Construction Bill HL 2, 27, 40, 7114/1/09 NFA X
Banking (No. 2) Bill (withdrawn on 18 December and replaced with Banking Bill) HL 3

HL 13, 20, 21, 23

14/1/09Concern about breadth of retrospective provision contained in Clause 75(3) First report published 22 January; Government amendment accepted at Third Reading which partially met the Committee's concern; Committee engaged in further correspondence with the Minister; supplementary report published.
House of Lords Bill HL 4N/A Lord Steel of Aikwood PMB
House of Lords (Members' Taxation Status) Bill HL 5N/A Lord Oakeshott of Seagrove Bay PMB
Equal Pay and Flexible Working Bill HL 6N/A Baroness Morris of Bolton PMB
Disabled Persons (Independent Living) Bill HL 7N/A Lord Ashley of Stoke PMB
Cohabitation BillHL 8 N/ALord Lester of Herne Hill PMB
Dog Control BillHL 9 N/ALord Redesdale PMB
Companies' Remuneration Reports Bill HL 10N/A Lord Gavron PMB
Bank of England (Amendment) Bill HL 11N/A Lord Saatchi PMB
Geneva Conventions and United Nations Personnel (Protocols) Bill HL 1214/1/09 NFA X
Community Amateur Sports Clubs (Support) Bill HL 14N/A Lord Addington PMB
Borders, Citizenship and Immigration Bill HL 15, 29, 36, 654/2/09 Concern about

·  scheme under which the Director of Border Revenue would share 'customs revenue functions' with the current holder of those functions, namely the Commissioners for Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs; and

·  The bill's constitutional implications for the relationship between the United Kingdom and the Crown Dependencies of Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man.

Letter sent to Minister about Part 1 of the Bill; reply received; report on Part 1 published; letters sent to Minister and to Chief Ministers of Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man; report on Part 3 of the bill published; Committee amendment agreed to at report stage.
Online Purchasing of Goods and Services (Age Verification) Bill HL 16N/A Baroness Massey of Darwen PMB
Torture (Damages) Bill HL 17N/A Lord Archer of Sandwell PMB
Health Bill HL 18, 31, 43, 7028/1/09 NFA X
Law Commission Bill HL 1920/5/09 Lord Lloyd of Berwick PMB

Committee welcomed the reforms contained in the Bill as enhancing the accountability and transparency of the relationship between the Government and the Law Commission

Report published. X
Sports Grounds Safety Authority Bill HL 22N/A Lord Faulkner of Worcester PMB
Postal Services Bill HL 24, 41, 4425/2/09 NFA X
Saving Gateway Accounts Bill HL 25, 37, 5218/3/09 NFA X
Political Parties and Elections Bill HL 26, 45, 54, 6425/2/09 NFA X
Northern Ireland Bill HL 284/3/09 Concern over lack of pre-legislative scrutiny and the fast-tracking of the bill through Parliament. Also concern about involvement of Prime Minister in the appointment of and any steps to remove a member of the senior judiciary in Northern Ireland. Report published; Chairman spoke at Second Reading; letter received from Minister and copies distributed.
Business Rate Supplements Bill HL 30, 47, 51, 5522/4/09 NFA X
Welfare Reform Bill HL 32, 62, 65, 75, 81 1/4/09Welfare Reform Bill raised points of constitutional significance—Clause 42 proposed to amend the Child Support Act 1991 to give new sanction powers to the Child Maintenance and Enforcement Commission (CMEC) to disqualify a person from holding a passport, a driving licence, or both, if he or she has wilfully and culpably failed to pay maintenance for a child. Report published; response from Government received 2 June and copies distributed; Committee amendments tabled for Grand Committee stage.
Coroners and Justice Bill HL 33, 69, 77, 8022/4/09 Concern about:

·  omnibus nature of bill;

·  provision for inquests without juries; and proposed amendments to the Data Protection Act 1998.

Letter sent to Minister and reply received; report published; Chairman spoke at Second Reading; Government withdrew provisions on inquests without juries at Committee stage.
Constitutional Renewal Bill HL 34N/A Lord Tyler PMB
Perpetuities and Accumulations Bill HL 35, 5913/5/09 NFA X
Industry and Exports (Financial Support) Bill HL 3920/5/09 NFA X
Apprenticeships, Skills, Children and Learning Bill HL 42, 73, 7820/5/09 NFA X
Marine Navigation Aids Bill HL 46N/A Lord Berkeley PMB
Policing and Crime Bill HL 48, 74, 793/6/09 Report brought to the attention of the House provisions on preventative injunctions, gang-related violence injunctions, retention and destruction of DNA samples and border controls. Letter sent to Minister; reply received; Report published; Government response received informing Committee that Government would seek to remove clauses on DNA samples from bill—this took place at HL Committee stage; Government response published as Committee report.
Constitutional Reform Bill HL 50N/A Lord Willoughby de Broke PMB
Parliamentary Standards HL 60, 6724/6/09 First report concentrated on the fast-tracking of the bill through Parliament; second report dealt with a number of provisions contained in the bill. Letter to Leader of the House about fast-tracking of bill; reply received; first report published; memorandum sought and received from the Clerk of the Parliaments about the bill; second report published; Chairman spoke at Second Reading; Government response to reports received and published.
Holocaust (Return of Cultural Objects) Bill HL 57N/A Mr Andrew Dismore PMB
Co-operative and Community Benefit Societies and Credit Unions Bill HL 5314/10/09 Malcolm Wicks PMB
AutismHL 56 N/AMrs Cheryl Gillan PMB
Driving Instruction (Suspension and Exemption Powers) Bill HL 58N/A Willie Rennie PMB
Green Energy (Definition and Promotion) Bill HL 61N/A Peter Ainsworth PMB X
Finance Bill HL 63N/A No scrutiny.
Live Music BillHL 66 N/ALord Clement Jones PMB
Damages (Asbestos-Related Conditions) Bill HL 72N/A Andrew Dismore PMB


29   Date of discussion in Committee Back


 
previous page contents

House of Lords home page Parliament home page House of Commons home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2010