Conclusions and Recommendations
1. At
our request, the Government extended the period of time available
to Parliament to scrutinise the UK/US Defence Trade Co-operation
Treaty. This allowed us to conduct an inquiry into the Treaty.
In November 2007 we took evidence from defence companies as well
as the MoD and the Cabinet Office and published our report in
December 2007 which recommended early ratification of the Treaty.
(Paragraph 10)
2. The MoD was extremely
slow in responding to our request for written evidence on our
inquiry into UK Defence: commitments and resources and this significantly
delayed our inquiry. (Paragraph 17)
3. Unusually, because
of the classified nature of the material presented to us, we had
to conduct our evidence sessions for our inquiry into The Iran
hostages incident in private. We had some reservations about conducting
scrutiny on terms of the Government's choosing. (Paragraph 26)
4. We concluded that
the Fulton Report, and the evidence provided to us in support
of it, contained a depth of operational detail which it would
have been damaging to have made public. This made it difficult
for us to demonstrate openly the grounds on which we reached our
conclusions. In our report, we assured the House of Commons that
we had scrutinised the report thoroughly and we wrote to the Secretary
of State for Defence with a number of classified conclusions and
recommendations. (Paragraph 28)
5. We have expressed
concern that the reduction in the number of Defence Agencies may
lead to a loss of transparency and Parliamentary accountability.
(Paragraph 38)
6. In 2007, as in
2006, we visited UK Forces on deployment in both Afghanistan and
Iraq. Visiting our troops wherever they are deployed is crucial
to our understanding of the conditions in which our Armed Forces
operate. (Paragraph 61)
7. For the future,
we would hope that the Government's responses will deal more fully
with the whole argument contained in the report, and not restrict
themselves to the bold recommendations and conclusions; and it
would be pleasing if they could be more generous in acknowledging
where our inquiries have contributed to changes in Government
policy. (Paragraph 71)
|