Memorandum 21
Submission from Centre of the Cell
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1. Centre of the Cell is a science education
centre, an online resource and an outreach project aimed at schools,
young people and families. The project started in September 2003,
the online resource (www.centreofthecell.org) was launched in
March 2007 and the Centre is scheduled to open in spring 2008.
It was conceived by staff at Queen Mary, University of London,
from the need to help young people understand cell biology and
biomedical science. Professor Frances Balkwill is Director of
Centre of the Cell and also Centre Lead for Translational Oncology
at Queen Mary's Medical School. Centre of the Cell is a registered
charity (no: 1102034). It is the first science education centre
in the world to be sited in biomedical research laboratories;
the Institute of Cell and Molecular Science. The Institute is
part of Barts and the London, Queen Mary's School of Medicine
and Dentistry, in Whitechapel, east London.
MISSION
2. Centre of the Cell is dedicated to inspiring
curiosity and learning by connecting science to everyday life.
AIMS
3. Our aims are:
To raise the educational and career
aspirations of young people.
To increase the number of students
studying science and taking up a career in science.
To create a centre of excellence
for local, national and international science communication.
To improve scientific literacy and
raise awareness of the key ethical issues surrounding biomedical
research.
TOP LEVEL
MESSAGE
4. Centre of the Cell seeks to engage the
audience through an innovative mix of interactive, theatrical
and multimedia experiences. By creating a centre of excellence
for public engagement with scientific research, we aim to encourage
young people to enquire, debate and interact. It will excite,
surprise and absorb visitors and deliver the following "top
level" message:
The cells in your body work together to keep
you healthy. When you are ill your cells have gone wrong: scientists
at Queen Mary and around the world are trying to find new ways
of putting cells right.
FUNDING
5. The total cost of the project is £3.8
million. £2.7 million has been raised and £1.1 million
needs to be raised to enable the Centre to open in Spring 2008.
We are currently seeking funding for the remaining internal fit-out
capital costs and for post-opening revenue costs from charitable
trusts and foundations, the corporate sector and individual donors.
To date, our main funders are the London Development Agency, the
Wellcome Trust, the Mercer's Company, the Jack Petchey Foundation,
the Garfield Weston Foundation and the Clore Duffield Foundation.
6. The availability of designated central
government funding streams for science centres for capital and
operating costs would be a significant asset. There are very few
structured funding routes specifically focused on science and
discovery centres, which results in a lack of stability in the
sector and makes it difficult to make long-term plans. Securing
a grant from central government also significantly enhances an
organisation's ability to lever funding from other sources. It
adds a valuable endorsement and encourages other funders to support
our work.
7. A key issue during our discussions with
funders about the capital costs has been the need to demonstrate
long-term sustainability. The commitment of revenue costs from
central government would strengthen our business plan and ability
to attract both capital and operating costs from other sources.
It would enable Centre of the Cell to achieve long-term sustainability,
plan for the future and regularly update our content and resources.
8. Centre of the Cell's annual running costs
will be £400,000. As matters stand, our business plan is
based on four sources of revenue; grants from trusts and foundations,
a corporate sponsored places scheme, ticket sales and support
from Queen Mary, University of London. One of our key objectives
is to ensure that visits for school children remain free of charge
and that charges during school holidays remain at a modest level
to ensure that cost does not present a barrier to access. Ticket
sales during school holidays will represent 15% of annual revenue,
which places a heavy reliance on fundraising. The majority of
trusts and foundations tend not to continue support after two
or three years and corporate support fluctuates and cannot be
relied upon on a long-term basis. Centralised government funding
would add stability and greatly enhance our capacity to succeed.
CONTENT
9. Four main topics are covered; All About
Cells (includes Single Cell Made You and Body Balance), Medical
Research (includes Cancer, Accidents and Unhealthy Lifestyles),
Ethics (includes Stem Cell Research and Cloning) and Patients'
Journeys (includes Spinal Cord Injury, IVF treatment and Cystic
Fibrosis). More than 60 leading scientists have contributed to
the content, which is curriculum-linked to Key Stages 2, 3 and
4 of the National Curriculum for Science. Visitors to Centre of
the Cell will pre-book structured sessions in the "pod".
Each session will last for 60 minutes and unfolds through a series
of linked scenes, containing 40 interactive learning activities.
Content will be updated and changed on a rolling basis to reflect
scientific breakthroughs, changes in the curriculum and feedback
from our evaluation programme.
EVALUATION
10. During the last three years, the concept,
content, interactives and website have been extensively researched
and evaluated with more than 6,000 young people and their teachers
to test learning outcomes and levels of interest and engagement.
For example, we carried out a major front-end evaluation to inform
both content and design. Participating schools (12 primary and
secondary schools in Tower Hamlets, Newham and Hackney involving
900 pupils aged 9 to 16) were selected on the basis of ethnic
profile, league table standard and geographical location. The
evaluation aimed to provide information about their knowledge
of cells and the inner workings of their own bodies; to find out
if the young people understood scientific terminology; and to
gauge their emotional responses and beliefs regarding science
and scientists. Pupils took part in creative workshops, answered
questionnaires and were interviewed in groups and in pairs. A
science teacher focus group was set up in each of the schools
visited.
11. We seek to create an enjoyable and exciting
experience but feel that it is important to highlight that we
deliver considerable educational depth and are not simply a visitor
attraction. All of our content is rigourously evaluated and is
designed to achieve clearly defined learning aims which enhance
and enrich the National Curriculum for Science. We provide unique
interactive, investigative learning resources for children, young
people and their teachers, which are not currently available in
the classroom.
12. Evaluation has been an integral part
of the project from the start. Our future growth, success and
impact is determined by measuring our activities against agreed
outcomes and targets. A measure of our success is our ability
to reach school pupils with low levels of achievement, to improve
educational attainment, and to raise career aspirations. Our evaluation
strategy includes quantitative and qualitative elements. A quantitative
gauge is the number of children and young people we work with
through our outreach programme, and by visits to the Centre once
it opens. Our qualitative evaluation methods are designed to assess
whether or not our organisation is making a difference to the
lives of the young people we engage with.
13. Centre of the Cell has collaborated
with 30 schools over the last three years and has built excellent
partnerships. When Centre of the Cell opens, we will continue
this successful collaboration with our partner schools to evaluate
the effectiveness of the project. This evaluation strategy will
include pre- and post-visit questionnaires and interviews with
school pupils and teachers as part of our long-term research.
TARGET AUDIENCE
Day time audience during the school year
14. The target audience is school children
aged 9-16. There is open access to all schools. Already science
teachers are asking to block book visits for the next three years.
On the basis of the current levels of interest, we anticipate
that demand for school visits will outstrip available places.
School visits will be free of charge. Our target is to work with
14,400 school children and their teachers during the first year
of operation.
Evenings, school holidays and weekend audience
15. Evening visits will be allocated to
after-school clubs, family groups and youth and community groups
(6,400 targeted in the first year). At the weekend and during
school holidays the Centre will be open to the general public,
with the focus on children, young people and families (12,000
targeted in the first year). Weekend and school holiday visitors
will be charged £7 for adults and £5 for children. There
will be a range of other ticket options to encourage family groups,
together with concessionary rates. Special events and activities
will be organised for residents of Tower Hamlets.
NEED AND
BENEFITS
Educational
16. Our research team found that young people
have difficulty understanding cells, find science boring and think
that scientists are white, male, middle-aged and mad. They found
that young people lacked the incentive to study science; they
were not inspired by it and knew very little about the benefits
of a career in science and healthcare. In spite of the fact that
cell biology and an understanding of sickness and health is a
substantial part of the Science National Curriculum at Key Stages
2, 3 and 4, there is currently no dedicated resource aimed at
young people and their teachers to help them learn and teach about
cells and medical research. Centre of the Cell will fill this
need.
17. Centre of the Cell relates science to
everyday life and illustrates its relevance to society and its
capacity to tackle diverse and complex issues. Our evaluations
revealed that pupils do not relate school science practical classes
to drug discovery and medical treatments. Centre of the Cell will
address this need by enabling visitors to understand what medical
research is, what it has achieved and its future potential.
Economic
18. Encouraging school students to take
science beyond GCSE is a major national issue. Inspiring and developing
the next generation of scientists and improving Science, Technology,
Engineering and Maths (STEM) skills are vitally important national
challenges. UK industry and future economic growth relies upon
skilled science graduates. The Confederation of British Industry
(CBI) estimates that the UK will need 2.4 million more people
with STEM skills by 2014. This forecast is based on data published
in Working Futures 2004-2014, Institute for Employment
Research, University of Warwick, January 2006. Centre of the Cell
and other science and discovery centres are addressing these challenges
by creating resources which encourage young people to study STEM
subjects and take up careers in science and healthcare.
Regeneration
19. Centre of the Cell is based in Whitechapel,
Tower Hamlets, east London. Based on the Indices of Multiple Deprivation
2004, which combines seven indicators of deprivationincome,
health, employment, education, barriers to housing and services,
crime and living environment, Tower Hamlets is one of the most
deprived boroughs in England. Centre of the Cell will play an
important role in the regeneration of the area by creating world-class
educational resources, widening participation in higher education
and introducing career pathways within the NHS and the education
sector. For example, our six Patients' Journeys highlight the
many different roles and careers involved in each patient's care.
20. We also provide a resource for the wider
community and are developing a family learning programme aimed
at local community and family groups. Special events are planned
for local residents and for our early evening visits priority
booking is given to community and youth groups and after-school
clubs.
Public engagementscientific literacy
21. Science, and the ethical issues that
biomedical research increasingly raises, underpins the future
development of our society. It is vital that young people engage
with key scientific and ethical issues to enable them to make
informed choices about their futures. We seek to dispel stereotypes
about science and scientists. The RIBA award winning Institute
of Cell and Molecular Science where Centre of the Cell is sited,
is now fully operational. The staff at the Institute represent
a diverse mix of cultures, genders and ages; this will help to
dispel some of the stereotypes surrounding scientists. The design
of the building is deliberately open plan to encourage staff to
share ideas and is transparent to the public, a stunning glass
box. The majority of scientists who have contributed to Centre
of the Cell's content work at the Institute and are actively involved
in public engagement.
COLLABORATIONS
22. Centre of the Cell is developing partnerships
with key organisations, agencies and networks involved in public
engagement and attracting young people to science subjects and
scientific careers. For example, we are have joined the Science
Ambassadors programme run by the Science, Engineering, Technology
and Mathematics Network (SETNET), which will involve volunteers
with STEM skills working with our audience. We are exhibiting
at the Royal Society Summer Science Exhibition in July 2007. Centre
of the Cell is hosting the British Association for the Advancement
of Science Crest Awards in March 2008, which celebrates the accomplishments
of school children across the UK.
CONCLUSION
23. Learning about and understanding science
is a major national challenge and Centre of the Cell and similar
enterprises play a vital role in tackling this challenge. We add
considerable educational value and provide a range of unique curriculum-linked
resources to help children and young people engage with science.
Our long-term success and sustainability would be greatly enhanced
by the availability of central government funding programmes for
capital and revenue costs.
June 2007
|