APPENDIX 10
Untitled
Memorandum submitted by North Down Development
Services
Council policy on Inward Investment is part
of the Corporate View prepared for the purpose of achieving best
value. In this the Council aims to work closely with the private
sector and government agencies such as the IDB and the Department
of Economic Development to promote North Down as a viable location
for inward investment. As far back as October 1995 Council called
for support from IDB in attracting Inward Investment in the High
Tech, Plastics, Medical and Leisure Goods sectors.
In May 1996 Council examined its implementation
measures for inward investment policy by considering mechanisms
for supporting inward investment using vehicles such as the Private
Finance Initiative, the Local Development Company concept and
a Borough Property Fund.
This brief summary of North Down inward investment
policy exposes a paradox which is evident when one examines the
current industrial development location policy for new inward
investment. The policy seeks to target inward investment into
the most deprived areas of Northern Ireland. The quantitative
measure of deprivation used by Government is the Robson Index.
This rates North Down as the least deprived Council area in Northern
Ireland. This may be true at District Council level but clear
pockets of social need exist based on an analysis at Enumeration
District level within the Borough.
Northern Ireland is competing with other successful
and affluent areas of Ireland and Europe for Foreign Direct Investment
in the Advanced Technology, ICT and Knowledge Based sectors. Most
commentators suggest these sectors are the future growth sectors.
North Down is perhaps unique in offering the
greatest concentration of graduate population anywhere in Northern
Ireland. If, as in the knowledge based and high added value sectors,
the skill base, quality of life and second level education infrastructure
are more significant factors in the FDI decision, then North Down
is well placed to compete.
Council has called for the deprivation criteria
that influence IDB support policy to allow for the possibility
that absence of deprivation is a significant attraction
in the advanced technology and knowledge based sectors. In many
cases this can lead to better value for money for the public purse
and lower cost per job figures.
North Downs does currently engage in promotion
of Northern Ireland but not through direct advertising. We feel
that this is more properly the remit of IDB and others in the
DED family. North Down uses a project based approach rather than
a destination emphasis and promotes itself as a project opportunity
area through direct networking. We use the Sister Cities Network
around the world and in North America. In Europe our vehicle is
the Edge Cities Network which gives access to local business communities
on the edge of Europe's national and regional capital cities.
Council policy is to encourage Business Networking
between local entrepreneurs and like-minded businesses in the
target areas. This has led to successes through joint ventures,
cross-licensing agreements and distribution through to manufacturing
agreements.
Although this approach has proved successful
in North Down, it only operates successfully where a significant
network of local entrepreneurial talent exists. In North Down,
the SIGNAL Business Growth network, which was developed in partnership
with local business over the last two years, fulfils this requirement.
In the future the CORE network in County Antrim will also fulfil
a similar role.
Although the network-based approach is cost
effective in terms of CPJ and success levels, it is very sensitive
to sub-regional investment support policy differences. When local
councils use their civic links as gateways to overseas business
networks they get very concerned at losing a potential investment
from their geographic areas. Part of the justification for expenditure
in maintaining and supporting overseas civic links is to secure
inward investment. There is a need for IDB operational policy
to reflect the sensitivity of this issue and to seek to address
it.
Local authorities in Northern Ireland have limited
powers to acquire and manage land for industrial development.
There is also no remit to actively promote and attract inward
investment. Rather we are required to host prospective target
companies when they decide to choose North Down as a possible
location. IDB funding guidelines for inward investment are statutorily
the same for the whole of Northern Ireland. In practice, operating
guidelines on support serve to tilt the playing field at a sub-regional
level. The effect may be to skew projects away from the North
Down area and even possibly from Northern Ireland.
As earlier stated, a real estate based approach
to inward investment is supported by Council. As a way forward
it has the advantage of being geographically specific and could
be "funded" through the transfer of land from IDB to
councils for the purpose of economic development.
In general we would note that an even greater
level of co-ordination and co-operation with IDB is required.
Discussions are currently underway between North Down and IDB
regarding the development of the Balloo South Industrial Estate
into a Business Park for the industry sectors being targeted by
Council for Foreign Direct Investment. The new Business Support
Centre being provided by Council to encourage further SME internationalisation
will also be a means to advance this objective.
30 November 1999
|