House of Commons portcullis
House of Commons
Session 2008 - 09
Publications on the internet

House of Commons
Wednesday 1 July 2009
Notices of Motions for which no days have been fixed
(‘Early Day Motions’)

* The figure following this symbol is the total number of Members' names submitted in support of the Motion, including names printed for the first time in this paper.

After the initial printing, Motions are reprinted only when names are added or amendments are submitted; only the first six names and any names added since the last printing are listed. After the week in which a Motion is submitted and the following week, added names and amendments appear only in the paper distributed on the next Thursday. In the meantime they are available for inspection by Members in the Table Office and the Library.



46EX-SERVICEMEN AND WOMEN3:12:08
Colin Challen
Andrew George
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Mr Ian Cawsey
Sandra Gidley
* 97
 David CairnsMr Douglas Carswell
   That this House believes that all ex-servicemen and women should be treated equally in the payment of pensions, regardless of when they served in Her Majesty's armed forces.


57DIABETES UK'S YOUR VISION CAMPAIGN AND ACCESS TO RETINAL SCREENING3:12:08
Mr Adrian Sanders [R]
Bob Spink
Andrew George
Peter Bottomley
Dr Desmond Turner
Sandra Gidley
* 74
 David Cairns
   That this House welcomes the Diabetes UK's campaign Your Vision; recognises that diabetes is the leading cause of blindness in the UK working age population; considers that all people with diabetes should have access to free annual retinal screening with a digital camera and that each primary care trust should have a systematic call and recall system to ensure that people with diabetes receive an annual letter inviting them for screening; notes with concern that Government targets, of all people with diabetes being offered free digital retinal screening by the end of 2007, were not met and as a result one in four, up to 470,000, people with diabetes in England, are needlessly being put at risk of losing their sight; further notes that retinal screening is one of the most cost-effective interventions known in medicine, with 90 per cent. of cases of retinopathy being treatable with early intervention; and calls on the Government to ensure that primary care trusts put in place the appropriate facilities and allocate the necessary budget to their screening programme to prevent people with diabetes from needlessly losing their sight.

[R] Relevant interest declared


74DIABETES UK MEASURE UP CAMPAIGN3:12:08
Mr Adrian Sanders [R]
Bob Spink
Andrew George
Peter Bottomley
Dr Desmond Turner
Paul Rowen
* 77
 Mr Russell BrownDavid Cairns
   That this House welcomes the Diabetes UK campaign Measure Up, which aims to raise awareness of diabetes; recognises that there are currently an estimated 750,000 people in the UK who have diabetes who are not aware of their condition; notes that the campaign aims to identify at least 25 per cent. of these people; further notes the seriousness of diabetes, which if left untreated can lead to blindness, kidney disease, heart attacks and other life-threatening complications; supports the key messages of the campaign that if you are a white or black male and your waist is 37 inches or more, a woman and your waist is 31.5 inches or more, or a South Asian man and your waist is 35 inches or more, you could need a test for diabetes; observes that keeping people with the condition healthier will also reduce the long-term impact on limited NHS resources; expresses its concern over Department of Health figures which show that only 72 per cent. of the diabetic population has been diagnosed across the UK; further notes that some primary care trusts have only diagnosed around half of their diabetic population; and calls on the Government to encourage primary care trusts to spell out their plans for early identification of people with diabetes in their local area.

[R] Relevant interest declared


85ROBBIE AND MARGARET HUGHES3:12:08
Tom Brake
Andrew George
Lynne Jones
Mr Mike Hancock
Mrs Betty Williams
Jeremy Corbyn
* 97
 John BarrettDr John Pugh
   That this House draws attention to the serious assault suffered by Robbie Hughes whilst in holiday in Crete; notes that the alleged perpetrators of the assault have been allowed to return to the UK; calls on the Greek authorities to pursue the case vigorously and the Greek and UK police to work closely together to ensure that the perpetrators are brought to justice; and commends Margaret Hughes for seeking to set up an effective support mechanism for families affected by violent crimes or serious accidents whilst abroad.


86ORANG-UTANS AND PALM OIL3:12:08
Bill Wiggin
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Mr James Paice
Miss Anne McIntosh
David Maclean
Andrew George
* 75
 Mr Don Foster
   That this House expresses concern about the growth of oil palm plantations in Borneo; notes that many oil palm plantations have replaced the rainforest, which is the habitat for the orang-utan; is further concerned that increasing habitat destruction could lead to the extinction of the orang-utan within five years; welcomes the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil; and urges the palm oil industry to take responsible action to protect orang-utan habitats and become sustainable.

As Amendments to Bill Wiggin's proposed Motion (Orang-utans and Palm Oil):

Dr Rudi Vis
* 1
Line 1, after `Borneo', insert ` and Sumatra'.
15:12:08(a1)
Dr Rudi Vis
Kelvin Hopkins
* 2
Line 4, leave out from `welcomes' to end and add `deplores the failure of the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil to act against members who continue to convert forest lands and peatlands to oil palm plantations; further notes the value of tropical peatlands in protecting rare megafauna such as the orang-utan, and the carbon dioxide emissions when such land is drained to support plantations of any kind; and urges the governments of Indonesia and Malaysia to rescind all licences for new plantations on peatland and implement a moratorium on further forest conversions to monoculture plantations.'.
15:12:08(a2)


92ACCESS TO INSULIN PUMP THERAPY FOR PEOPLE WITH TYPE 1 DIABETES3:12:08
Mr Adrian Sanders [R]
Peter Bottomley
Mr David Amess
Dr Desmond Turner
Sandra Gidley
Sir Nicholas Winterton
* 61
 Mr Russell BrownDavid Cairns
   That this House welcomes Diabetes UK's campaign to end the postcode lottery for insulin pump therapy; believes that making a small change through providing the technology can make a big difference to the lives of people with diabetes; notes the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) recommendation that insulin pump therapy should be available as a treatment option for people with Type 1 diabetes in cases where multiple dose insulin therapy has failed, and the person is willing and able to use insulin pump therapy effectively; notes with concern that this guidance is not being adhered to locally in a uniform manner; is aware that currently only two per cent. of people with Type 1 diabetes use pumps in the UK, compared to 10 to 20 per cent. in other European member states and around 15 to 20 per cent. in the United States; believes that the use of pumps can have cost benefits to the local NHS through a reduction in primary care contracts and a reduction in hospital admissions and hospital outpatient contracts; and calls on the Government to oversee the implementation of NICE guidance by primary care organisations to end the postcode lottery.

[R] Relevant interest declared


135ANIMAL PROTECTION POLICY4:12:08
Mr Mike Hancock
Jeremy Corbyn
John McDonnell
David Taylor
Paul Flynn
Mr David Drew
* 101
 Norman Lamb
   That this House notes the growing body of scientific evidence demonstrating that animals have complex mental and emotional lives; considers animals to be conscious, feeling beings with an interest in living, avoiding suffering and experiencing pleasure; acknowledges that each animal has inherent value and is worthy of serious moral consideration; further considers respect for animals to be indicative of the level of civilisation; is concerned that policy making is led by industries that inevitably compromise animals' welfare and interests, and that the most essential interests of animals and the public's concern for their protection are given insufficient consideration; endorses the Prime Minister's call for constitutional reform that entrusts more power to Parliament and the British people; further notes that there is no Government body whose primary purpose is to protect the interests of animals in policy-making; and calls upon the Government to establish an animal protection commission or similar body, answerable to Parliament via a Minister, with a remit which includes the ongoing examination of the ethical status and rights of animals and how they are affected by policy-making, the facilitation of genuine public participation throughout policy processes which affect animals, and the development of a cross-Government agenda for animal protection.

As an Amendment to Mr Mike Hancock's proposed Motion (Animal Protection Policy):

Mike Penning
* 1
Line 6, leave out from `civilisation' to end and add `notes that there is no Government body whose primary purpose is to protect the interests of animals in policy-making; and is concerned that policy-making may be led by industries that inevitably compromise the welfare and interests of animals, and that the most essential interests of animals, and the public's concern for their protection, are given insufficient consideration.'
8:5:09(a1)


161LEARNING DISABILITY COALITION8:12:08
Mr Tom Clarke
Mr Mike Hancock
Greg Mulholland
Roger Berry
Peter Bottomley
Bob Russell
* 205
 Mr Eric MartlewSir Alan Beith
   That this House is alarmed by the report from the Learning Disability Coalition, Tell It Like It Is, which reveals that 34 per cent. of people with a learning disability surveyed had had their daytime activities cut; is further alarmed by the number of people with a learning disability who are being squeezed out of the social care system by the tightening of eligibility criteria; is concerned that these cuts will worsen across the country as demographic and social changes and medical advances mean the number of people with a learning disability requiring social care continues to rise; is further concerned by a report from the Joint Committee on Human Rights which found that failures in social care were contributing to the social exclusion, poverty and isolation experienced by people with a learning disability; welcomes the work of the Learning Disability Coalition to highlight these cuts to services; and calls on the Government to ensure that all of these issues are directly addressed in the forthcoming Green Paper on adult social care.


174FIREFIGHTER SAFETY8:12:08
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Michael Clapham
John McDonnell
Mr David Drew
Ian Stewart
Mr Martin Caton
* 136
 Mr Edward Davey
   That this House notes the recent increased number of firefighter deaths highlighted in the Fire Brigades Union report In the Line of Duty; further notes the lack of safety-critical operational guidance for fire authorities highlighted in that report, and the absence of a properly resourced national body with overall responsibility for recording and investigating firefighter deaths and other serious incidents; and calls for work to be commenced with stakeholders leading to the creation of such a body with responsibility for developing and agreeing safety-critical operational guidance arising from those investigations.


176HM REVENUE AND CUSTOMS OFFICES IN WALES8:12:08
Mark Williams
Peter Bottomley
Mr Mike Hancock
Robert Key
Lynne Jones
Mr John Leech
* 17
 Mr Andy Slaughter
   That this House expresses concern at the recently announced closure of nine HM Revenue and Customs offices across Wales, including the office at Aberystwyth, which was scheduled to stay open under the original proposals; believes that compliance staff in Aberystwyth have not been given the opportunity of fully responding to the consultation as they were unaware of the threat to their jobs; notes the importance of public sector employment at a time when many private sector jobs are being lost and acknowledges the Government's moratorium on Jobcentre Plus closures; and calls on the Government to postpone closures and staffing cuts until a full reassessment of the impact on local economies has been made, and staff who were not aware that they would lose their jobs have been able to respond to a further consultation.


273DIABETES MANAGEMENT IN SCHOOLS11:12:08
Paul Rowen
Mr Lee Scott
Bob Spink
Mr Adrian Sanders
Mr David Drew
John McDonnell
* 61
 Laura MoffattDavid Cairns
   That this House notes that the UK has the highest number of children with diabetes in Europe with 20,000 children below the age of 15 years diagnosed; urges the Government to ensure that children suffering from diabetes receive vital checks required for good diabetes management; further notes with concern the recent Diabetes UK campaign highlighting the lack of support for children at school in the management of their diabetes; further urges the Government to aid schools in ensuring children with diabetes have a safe environment and are able to receive full access to medication and health monitoring in schools; and concludes that all schools should have trained staff to deal with medical emergencies concerning children suffering from diabetes to assist with and if required administer insulin injections and blood glucose tests.


292TASER GUNS15:12:08
Tom Brake
Chris Huhne
Lynne Jones
Lynne Featherstone
Peter Bottomley
Jeremy Corbyn
* 46
 Richard Younger-Ross
   That this House expresses concern at the decision to arm 30,000 police officers with Taser stun guns; believes that such weapons should be in the hands of a select group of highly trained officers and used for specific threat purposes; further believes that strict procedures are needed to prevent misuse of such guns; asks that Tasers should not be deployed any more widely than firearms; recalls that Tasers must be used as a weapon of last resort, in situations which fall only just below the point when lethal force should be used; and rejects any move towards fully-armed, US-style policing.

As an Amendment to Tom Brake's proposed Motion (Taser Guns):

Mr Gregory Campbell
Dr William McCrea
* 2
Line 2, after `guns', insert `; but accepts, given the increasing threat to the lives of both police officers and other members of the public, that there is a need for an effective weapon to prevent violent law breakers from causing injury.'.
16:12:08(a1)


299EMISSIONS PERFORMANCE STANDARD16:12:08
Mr Tim Yeo
Colin Challen
Malcolm Bruce
Joan Walley
Lynne Jones
Nick Harvey
* 186
 Tony BaldryMr Andrew LoveMiss Julie Kirkbride
 Mr Paul KeetchMr Jim CunninghamMr Kevin Barron
 Mike WoodSir Gerald KaufmanMr Martyn Jones
 Alistair BurtGregory BarkerMr Alistair Carmichael
 Stewart HosieMr Ben WallaceMr John Leech
 Mr Dai Davies
   That this House believes that, in light of the strong recommendation made by the Climate Change Committee that the power sector should be almost fully decarbonised by 2030, and its warning of the potential dangers of a purely market-led approach leading to carbon lock in, the Government should bring forward early legislation to introduce a greenhouse gas emissions performance standard to apply to all new power generation capacity.


308RECENT ATTACKS AGAINST CHRISTIANS IN ORISSA INDIA16:12:08
Mr Virendra Sharma
Mark Pritchard
Andrew George
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Mike Weir
Peter Bottomley
* 93
 Sandra GidleyHugh BayleyMr Peter Robinson
 Sarah TeatherNorman LambJulia Goldsworthy
   That this House is deeply disturbed by the systematic attacks perpetrated against the Christian community in Kandhamal and other districts of Orissa state in India following the deplorable assassination of Swami Lakhmananda Saraswati, which has been characterised by brutal murder, arson, destruction of Christian institutions and places of worship, looting of property and retributive rape and which has resulted in a significant number of deaths; notes the European Parliament resolution of 24 September 2008 which `expresses deep concern at the recent attacks on Christians in Orissa'; further reports that Christians in the area have been coerced into renouncing their faith; observes that anti-Christian violence has intensified in other states since the outbreak in Orissa; strongly condemns the violence; further notes that no effective prosecutorial action was brought after an outbreak of anti-Christian violence in Kandhamal district in December 2007; further notes that relatively few complaints have been registered by police in Orissa and that the capacity of the police force to investigate the violence is very limited; and calls for bilateral representations to be made to the Indian government to call for the restoration of peace and stability in Orissa and the bringing to justice of inciters and perpetrators of the violence, and to consider what assistance the UK may offer for relief and rehabilitation and addressing the root causes of the violence.


331RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS17:12:08
Greg Mulholland
Mr Eric Illsley
Mr Brian Binley
Andrew George
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
* 46
 Kate Hoey
   That this House is appalled at the use of restrictive covenants by pub operating companies, where a pub or licensed premises is sold with a condition of sale preventing the premises from being used as a pub in the future; believes that this is a scandal whereby the company concerned is taking an entirely self-interested decision permanently to shut pubs against the wishes of the community served by the pub simply to serve their own commercial interests; believes that this is against free and fair competition, and prevents other operators, individuals or co-operatives taking on such pubs; is further concerned that this will lead to the permanent closure of many community pubs up and down the country, when these pubs could be successful if another operator were allowed to run them; is aware of the benefits which pubs bring to their local community, particularly as a social hub and meeting point; and calls on the Government to act to outlaw the use of restrictive covenants on pubs and prevent the permanent loss of even more pubs from high streets and communities across the country.


337MARINE RESERVES17:12:08
Bill Wiggin
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Mr James Paice
Miss Anne McIntosh
Ms Katy Clark
Mark Durkan
* 214
 Mr Tom HarrisMr David Anderson
   That this House notes the recommendation made by the Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution in their 25th Report in 2004 that a widespread network of highly protected marine reserves throughout all UK seas is an important marine management tool which is required in order to rebuild UK commercial fish stocks and to halt the serious damage being caused to marine ecosystems; and calls upon the Government to develop selection criteria under the Marine Bill for establishing a network of protected marine areas based around science-based decision making.

As Amendments to Bill Wiggin's proposed Motion (Marine Reserves):

Bob Spink
* 1
Line 5, after `ecosystems;' insert `further notes that the main damage to fish stocks and the marine environment come from fishing by the non-British EU fishing fleet.'.
12:1:09(a1)
Bob Spink
Mrs Iris Robinson
* 2
Line 7, at end add `and the need to enable sustainable fishing by the British fishing fleet.'.
12:1:09(a2)


344TREATMENT OF CHRISTIANS IN IRAQ17:12:08
Mr Edward Leigh
Tim Farron
Mr Russell Brown
Mr Gregory Campbell
David Simpson
Mark Durkan
* 67
 Norman Lamb
   That this House is deeply concerned by the mass exodus of Iraqi Christians, which has decimated much of Iraq's ancient Assyrian-Chaldean community; notes that the Assyrian-Chaldeans make up over 95 per cent. of Iraq's Christians and that this exodus has largely been caused by escalating violence against Christians from fanatical extremists, including the bombing of churches and the assassination of Iraqi Christians; further notes that there has been illegal expropriation of Assyrian-Chaldean land and villages in Dohuk province and the Nineveh Plain in northern Iraq; recognises that Iraqi Christians are a major force for moderation, who can act as a significant buffer against the spread of extremism in Iraq; calls on the British and Iraqi governments urgently to encourage and support the creation of a self-governing province in Iraq for the Assyrian-Chaldeans, linked to the central government in Baghdad, situated in and around the Nineveh Plain and including the Tel Kaif, Al-Hamdaniya and Al-Shikhan districts, and governed by the Assyrian-Chaldeans and other ethnic groups living in that area, as these lands form part of the ancestral homeland of the Assyrian-Chaldeans and are still heavily populated by them; and urges the United Kingdom and Iraqi governments to support financially the reconstruction of the region, to end the political marginalisation of the democratically-elected Assyrian-Chaldean representatives in Iraq, to assist the Assyrian-Chaldeans in reclaiming their land and villages in Dohuk province and the Nineveh Plain, and to financially support internally displaced Assyrian-Chaldeans and the return and resettlement of Assyrian-Chaldean refugees.


357UNITED UTILITIES CHARGES FOR PLACES OF WORSHIP17:12:08
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mark Durkan
John McDonnell
Robert Key
Peter Bottomley
Mr Mike Hancock
* 52
 Laura Moffatt
   That this House expresses concern at the decision by United Utilities to introduce a new method of calculating surface water charges and highways drainage services, known as site area charging; recognises the negative impact this will have on churches and places of worship which, in some cases, will now face increases in their charges in excess of £1,000 per year as they are being treated in the same way as all other non-household customers; and calls on United Utilities to review the decision to impose site area charging on churches and places of worship which cannot afford such huge increases in their water bills.

As an Amendment to Mr Lindsay Hoyle's proposed Motion (United Utilities Charges for Places of Worship):

Dr Evan Harris
* 1
Line 1, leave out from `House' to end and add `does not believe that ordinary consumers should have to pay higher utility and water charges so that places of worship can benefit from lower charges just because they are places of worship, and that any reduction in utility charges should apply to all community facilities regardless of their purpose or religious affiliation.'.
18:12:08(a1)


361FIREFIGHTER SAFETY AND DATA COLLECTION18:12:08
Mr Stewart Jackson
Mr Simon Burns
Mr Lee Scott
Peter Bottomley
Mrs Betty Williams
Mr Mike Hancock
* 67
 David Cairns
   That this House notes with profound gratitude the selfless commitment of firefighters to their role, often in very stressful and dangerous circumstances; further notes the increased number of firefighter deaths in recent years, as highlighted in the Fire Brigades' Union report, In the Line of Duty; further notes the lack of safety-critical operational guidance for fire authorities highlighted in that report, and the deficiency of data collection in regard to firefighter deaths and other serious incidents; and therefore calls for greater clarity and standardisation in the recording and investigation of firefighter fatalities and injuries and for more comprehensive safety guidance for fire authorities.


377200th ANNIVERSARY OF THE BIRTH OF CHARLES DARWIN12:1:09
Dr Ashok Kumar
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
Ian Stewart
Dr Brian Iddon
Kelvin Hopkins
* 81
 Mr Kevin Barron
   That this House notes the extraordinary achievements of Charles Darwin; notes that 2009 marks both the 200th anniversary of Darwin's birth and the 150th anniversary of the publication of On the Origin of Species; welcomes proposals for the creation of a Darwin Day in recognition of the ground-breaking work of the British scientist responsible for the theory of evolution by natural selection; and calls for Darwin's birthday, 12 February, to be designated a public holiday in honour of one of the fathers of modern science and one of Britain's greatest, if not the greatest, scientific minds.


394FLOOD RESPONSE AND FIRE AND RESCUE SERVICE12:1:09
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr David Drew
Mr Michael Clapham
John McDonnell
Chris McCafferty
Mr Eric Illsley
* 99
 Mr Edward Davey
   That this House recognises the tremendous efforts of the Fire and Rescue Service in responding to the major floods in 2007; notes however the finding of the Pitt Review that the public and rescuers were put at unnecessary risk by the current lack of clarity over who is responsible for emergency response to flooding; recognises the Pitt Review's very strong backing for the Fire and Rescue Service to have a statutory duty for flood rescue; welcomes the Government's positive response to the recommendation of the Pitt Review that there should be a fully funded national capability for flood rescue, with fire and rescue authorities playing a leading role, underpinned, as necessary, by a statutory duty; and therefore calls on the Government to introduce legislative proposals for a statutory duty on the Fire and Rescue Service for flood rescue, supported by funding for adequate equipment and training.


405CITIZENS ADVICE BUREAUX12:1:09
Nick Herbert
Mr Alan Duncan
Mr Henry Bellingham
Mr Edward Garnier
Mr Jonathan Djanogly
Mr David Burrowes
* 78
 Anne Main
   That this House recognises the vital contribution of citizens advice bureaux in providing advice on debt to those in need during the recession; notes that personal debt is now the single biggest problem dealt with by bureaux; further notes that there has been a 51 per cent. increase compared to the previous year in cases involving mortgage or loan arrears, a 69 per cent. increase in redundancy cases and a 22 per cent. increase in bankruptcy cases dealt with by bureaux; is concerned that the way in which the Legal Services Commission is commissioning Community Legal Advice Centres and Networks may undermine the citizens advice bureaux network; further notes the Government's review of the funding and provision of civil legal advice; urges the consideration of a public interest test in the future commissioning process, as recommended by Citizens Advice; and believes that in the current economic downturn, and pending the outcome of its review, the Government should suspend the roll-out of Community Legal Advice Centres and Networks to ensure that citizens advice bureaux can maintain their services at a time when they are needed most.


426FINANCIAL SERVICES COMPENSATION SCHEME LEVY ON BUILDING SOCIETIES13:1:09
Mrs Ann Cryer
Mr Marsha Singh
Colin Challen
Mr David Curry
Chris McCafferty
Bob Russell
* 173
 Julia Goldsworthy
   That this House notes the disproportionate impact on building societies of the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) levy, resulting from the failure of Bradford and Bingley plc, the Icelandic banks and London Scottish Bank; recognises that building societies' share of the levy, approximately £200 million per annum in each of the next three years, is equivalent to about 15 per cent. of the sector's pre-tax profit for 2007-08 financial year ends; notes that building societies' share of the levy for years beyond 2011 is uncertain, but could well be higher than £200 million per annum; acknowledges that the impact on building societies contrasts starkly with the banking sector, where the FSCS levy is typically well below five per cent. of pre-tax profits over a similar accounting period; further notes that the current allocation of the FSCS levy works to the detriment of building societies' members, their savers and borrowers; acknowledges that no building society has ever made a call on the FSCS or its predecessor schemes; and calls on the Government to introduce a more equitable scheme for funding the insurance of deposits of failed banks.


431INTERNATIONAL BACCALAUREATE IN CARDIFF13:1:09
Julie Morgan
Alun Michael
Jenny Willott
John Smith
Mr Dai Havard
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
* 130
 Julia Goldsworthy
   That this House is gravely concerned by proposals by the International Baccalaureate to move out of Cardiff to another city in Europe; notes it has been based in Wales for nearly two decades and at its headquarters in Cardiff Gate Business Park since 2001, which offers head office functions for the worldwide organisation and employs 330 highly-trained staff; notes there is no reason related to staff recruitment, quality or loyalty to justify such a move; and urges the board of the International Baccalaureate to reject proposals that will result in the disruption of such a successful organisation and the loss of 330 jobs in Cardiff.


441EPILEPSY IN ENGLAND14:1:09
Chris McCafferty
Mr Paul Truswell
Dr Evan Harris
Andrew George
Mr David Amess
Mr Kevin Barron
* 190
 Mrs Louise EllmanTim Farron
   That this House notes the Epilepsy Action survey of January 2009; agrees that it is time for change for people with epilepsy; recognises that the majority of primary care trusts and acute trusts in England are failing to meet National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) Guidelines of 2004 for adults and children with epilepsy; congratulates Epilepsy Action for highlighting these issues in its campaign Epilepsy in England: time for change; believes that all health commissioners should carry out a review of their implementation of the NICE epilepsy guidelines and develop plans to ensure these are met; and calls on the Government to take a lead in driving improvements in epilepsy service provision and appoint a national clinical director to review service provision in England and lead change.


446BARKING TO GOSPEL OAK LINE ELECTRIFICATION14:1:09
Jeremy Corbyn
Harry Cohen
Mr Neil Gerrard
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Alan Meale
Mr Gordon Prentice
* 30
 Dr Vincent Cable
   That this House recognises that the Barking to Gospel Oak line is a very valuable part of the rail network; notes that it is the only section of the North London line without electrification; believes that to become an even more effective part of the passenger and freight network it should be electrified; and calls upon the Secretary of State to support this development and to open negotiations with Network Rail and Transport for London to achieve it.


458EQUALITY BILL AND AGE DISCRIMINATION14:1:09
Mr Gordon Marsden
Mr Mike Hancock
Hywel Williams
John Mason
Kelvin Hopkins
Andrew George
* 195
 Hugh Bayley
   That this House notes the Government's manifesto commitment to bring in a single comprehensive Equality Bill within the lifetime of this Parliament; welcomes the Government's commitment to banning age discrimination in the provision of goods, facilities and services as part of this Bill; urges all hon. Members to support this Bill; recognises that health and social care is one of the key areas in which older people face unfair discrimination; is concerned that this discrimination has a major impact on their quality of life and, in extreme circumstances, can deny them potentially life-saving treatment; understands that the Government intends to introduce provisions on age discrimination in health and social care by secondary legislation; and is concerned that the provision for this and detailed guidance should be brought forward as soon as possible after Second Reading of the Bill and not be subject to a lengthy delay before enactment.


465NEW WATER CHARGES AND THE VOLUNTARY SECTOR15:1:09
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Mr Jeremy Hunt
Greg Clark
Mr Eric Pickles
Miss Anne McIntosh
Hugh Robertson
* 59
 Laura MoffattGregory Barker
   That this House notes with concern that the imposition of new surface water drainage charges comes at the worst possible time for the voluntary sector, ranging from churches to sports clubs to local scout and guide huts, many of which are already suffering from a fall in donation income and investment income as a result of the crisis in the economy; regrets what is yet another sign of the Government's failure to appreciate the vital role of faith-based and voluntary sector organisations to our communities; and calls for the implementation of these new charges to be delayed until a proper assessment of their impact has been made.


496SHARED SURFACES AND DISABLED PEOPLE19:1:09
Roger Berry
Mr David Amess
Mr Paul Burstow
Bob Russell
Bob Spink
Mrs Joan Humble
* 167
 Mr David DrewMr David ClellandJo Swinson
   That this House supports the Guide Dogs for the Blind Association (Guide Dogs) and the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee in calling for a moratorium on new shared surface schemes in our towns and cities until the Department for Transport has published the results of its forthcoming research; recognises that in these schemes it is not possible for certain groups of vulnerable road users to use such areas independently because they cannot tell where the pavement ends and the road begins; and welcomes the research that Guide Dogs has already carried out to highlight the issue and to try to find an effective solution.


522TIME TO CHANGE CAMPAIGN TO END MENTAL HEALTH DISCRIMINATION20:1:09
Lynne Jones
Paul Rowen
Mr Kevin Barron
Mark Fisher
Tim Loughton
Bob Russell
* 112
 Laura Moffatt
   That this House supports Time to Change, England's biggest and most ambitious campaign to end mental health discrimination; notes that one in four people will experience a mental health problem in their lifetime; further notes that nine out of 10 people with mental health problems have been discriminated against at home, work or in the community; acknowledges that the stigma surrounding mental health problems must be challenged at every level of society; encourages greater and more open discussions in Parliament of the ways in which mental illness has impacted on the lives of hon. Members, their families and friends; and calls on the Government to speak out publicly in support of the Time to Change initiative.


545SCIENTIFIC PROCEDURES ON ANIMALS AND THE USE OF NON-ANIMAL ALTERNATIVES21:1:09
Martin Horwood
Mr Oliver Letwin
David Taylor
Bob Russell
Mark Durkan
Andrew George
* 207
 Mr John WhittingdaleMr James ArbuthnotSandra Gidley
 Dr Howard StoateMr Michael FallonLaura Moffatt
 Mr Tim YeoMr Paul KeetchCharlotte Atkins
 Mr Richard ShepherdMr Geoffrey RobinsonMr Alan Meale
 Mr Graham AllenMr Elliot MorleyMr Kevin Barron
 Mr Clive BettsIan StewartGeraldine Smith
 Mr Frank FieldMr Peter AtkinsonDr Kim Howells
 Lembit ÖpikJulie MorganAlun Michael
 Mr Russell BrownSir Menzies CampbellSir Robert Smith
 Mr David HamiltonAngus RobertsonNorman Lamb
 Mr Alistair CarmichaelMr Richard BaconDr Richard Taylor
 Albert OwenStewart HosieMr Robert Goodwill
 Mr Jeremy HuntMr Edward VaizeyJohn Penrose
 Tim FarronWillie RennieMr David Davis
   That this House is concerned that for the sixth successive year the number of scientific procedures on animals has steadily increased, reaching over 3.2 million in 2007, the highest level since 1991; notes that the use of animals in scientific procedures continues to outstrip the development of non-animal alternatives in spite of the valuable work of the National Centre for the Replacement, Refinement and Reduction of Animals in Research (NC3Rs) and other organisations involved in the development and promotion of non-animal alternatives, replacing the need for animal testing and offering hope of humane scientific research; further notes that this year it is 50 years since the 3Rs approach (replacement, refinement and reduction) was first advocated; considers that progress towards implementing the 3Rs has been desperately slow; and urges the Government to introduce measures to deal with barriers to implementing non-animal alternatives, halt increases in the numbers of animals used, and encourage more widespread implementation of non-animal alternatives across all sectors involved in research.


554PLAIN PACKAGING OF TOBACCO PRODUCTS22:1:09
Dr Richard Taylor
David Taylor
Dr Doug Naysmith
Mr Kevin Barron
Charlotte Atkins
Dr Howard Stoate
* 81
 Laura Moffatt
   That this House notes the recently adopted Article 13 guidelines to the World Health Organisation Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, which define tobacco packaging and display as a means of advertising and promotion; acknowledges that research has found that current tobacco packaging is misleading by implying that some tobacco products are less harmful than others; believes that misleading packaging is in contravention of the EU directive on tobacco products and that research also shows that removing colours and brand imagery from packs increases the effectiveness of health warnings; supports the prohibition of retail display of tobacco products; and urges the Government to introduce measures to require plain packaging of all tobacco products by regulation.


566FREE PRESCRIPTIONS FOR LONG-TERM CONDITIONS26:1:09
Mr Neil Gerrard
Norman Lamb
Bob Spink
Bob Russell
Peter Bottomley
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 149
 Mr Mike HancockLaura MoffattMr Anthony Wright
 Stephen PoundMike GapesMr Edward Davey
 Dr Vincent CableMr Robert WalterMr David Davis
   That this House is concerned that large numbers of people with long-term conditions are struggling to afford vital medication and that some are unable to pay; welcomes the commitment given by the Prime Minister in September 2008 to abolish prescription charges for people with cancer from April 2009 and for people with long-term conditions over the next few years; notes that the new Pharmaceutical Price Regulation Scheme will deliver substantial savings to the NHS drugs budget; further welcomes the announcement that Professor Ian Gilmore will conduct a review to consider how to implement this policy; and supports the Campaign for Free Prescriptions for Long-term Conditions in urging the Government to abolish prescription charges for all people with all long-term conditions before the next General Election.

As an Amendment to Mr Neil Gerrard's proposed Motion (Free Prescriptions for Long-term Conditions):

Mr Angus MacNeil
John Mason
Mr Mike Weir
Angus Robertson
Pete Wishart
Stewart Hosie
* 6
Line 10, at end add `, and notes the steps taken by the Scottish National Party-led Government in Scotland in this regard.'.
28:1:09(a1)


569SAFETY OF MEDICINES26:1:09
Bob Spink
Jeremy Corbyn
Mr David Amess
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Gordon Prentice
Dr Desmond Turner
* 207
 Mrs Louise Ellman
   That this House believes that the safety of medicines should be established by the most reliable methods available in order to reduce the large and increasing toll of serious adverse drug reactions; and calls on the Government to initiate an unprecedented comparison of currently required animal tests with a set of human biology-based tests, as required by the Safety of Medicines (Evaluation) Bill, to see which is the most effective means to predict the safety of medicines for patients.


581FOOD LABELLING AND THE WELFARE OF CHICKENS26:1:09
Mr Mike Hancock
Mrs Ann Cryer
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Bob Russell
Andrew George
* 261
 Laura MoffattMr Anthony WrightShona McIsaac
 Mr Kevin BarronMr Nigel DoddsJohn Mason
   That this House believes that all chicken meat, including imported chicken meat, should be labelled as to farming method and preferably stocking density; further believes the labelling regulation that requires packs of shell eggs to be labelled as to production method should be extended to chicken meat; congratulates Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall and Compassion in World Farming on their Chicken Out! campaign calling on supermarkets to introduce labelling as to farming method to allow consumers to make informed choices; notes that most UK chickens are still reared intensively in overcrowded conditions and have been bred to grow so quickly that many suffer from lameness and heart problems; and calls on the Government to make it a requirement for all chicken producers to meet the conditions of the RSPCA's Freedom Food scheme.

As an Amendment to Mr Mike Hancock's proposed Motion (Food Labelling and the Welfare of Chickens):

Mr Mark Todd
* 1
Line 9, after `Government', insert `to work with the European Union to'.
21:4:09(a1)


588BLINDNESS PREVENTION AND PEOPLE WITH DIABETES26:1:09
Mr George Howarth
Helen Southworth
Rosemary McKenna
Jeremy Corbyn
Peter Bottomley
Graham Stringer
* 84
 Mr David Clelland
   That this House regrets that diabetic retinopathy is the leading cause of blindness among the working age population in the UK; considers that all people with diabetes should have access to free annual retinal screening with a digital camera; welcomes the progress made by many primary care trusts across England in implementing retinal screening programmes for people with diabetes, but is concerned that the latest figures from the Department of Health show that 28 per cent. of people with diabetes are at risk of losing their sight because they have not received screening and 6.9 per cent. of these have not even been offered it; commends the ongoing campaign from Diabetes UK that calls for everyone with diabetes to have access to high quality, annual retinal screening and appropriate follow-up treatment as necessary; and calls on primary care trusts to do more to reduce the number of people who do not respond to screening invitations.


616SOUTH WEST REGIONAL SPATIAL STRATEGY28:1:09
Annette Brooke
Martin Horwood
Steve Webb
Mr Oliver Letwin
Mr David Heath
Mr Robert Walter
* 29
 Mr Gary Streeter
   That this House notes that around 35,000 responses from individuals and organisations have been submitted on the latest consultation on the South West Regional Spatial Strategy, and that this is the largest number ever received to such a consultation; further notes that the assumed growth rate of 3.2 per cent. on which the strategy is based now has no economic validity; calls on the Government to recognise that the protection of long-established Green Belt, flood risk areas and other valued green spaces from large-scale development is a priority, whilst recognising the need for small scale developments of social housing determined at local level; and further calls for the abandonment of the South West Regional Spatial Strategy.


653REPORT ON MAP OF GAPS: FUNDING VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN SERVICES2:2:09
Julie Morgan
Lynne Featherstone
Mr Terry Rooney
Peter Bottomley
Judy Mallaber
Bob Russell
* 82
 Sir Menzies Campbell
   That this House welcomes the `Map of Gaps' report and website by the Equality and Human Rights Commission and the End Violence Against Women coalition; notes with alarm that three million women across the UK experience violence each year; further notes that over a quarter of local authority areas across Britain have no specialised violence against women support services such as rape crisis centres, refuges, domestic violence outreach projects and services for black and minority ethnic women; recognises the need for local authorities and other public bodies to undertake needs assessments under their gender equality schemes and to ensure both sufficiency and diversity of provision; encourages local strategic partnerships to prioritise tackling violence against women, including within local area agreements; welcomes the Government's commitment to consult on a Violence Against Women strategy; and calls on the Government urgently to establish a funding strategy and work with local strategic partnerships to ensure that women's access to support does not depend on where they live.


660PARLIAMENTARY SCRUTINY OF TRIDENT REPLACEMENT3:2:09
Jeremy Corbyn
Mr Austin Mitchell
Mr Dai Davies
Mr Mike Hancock
Bob Spink
Mr Andrew Pelling
* 163
 Laura MoffattMr John HoramAlbert Owen
 Julia Goldsworthy
   That this House recalls the commitment given during the parliamentary debate on the prospective programme for the replacement of the Trident system on 14 March 2007, Official Report, column 309, by the then Foreign Secretary, the right hon. Member for Derby South, that the Government would ensure regular reports to Parliament as the programme proceeds; contrasts this with the answer given by the Permanent Under Secretary at the Ministry of Defence, Sir Bill Jeffrey, in oral evidence to the Public Accounts Committee on 19 November 2008, when it was highlighted that the Ministry of Defence had announced its intention to conclude the Initial Gate decision in September 2009, during the parliamentary recess, that these would normally be decisions taken by Ministers; notes that the Secretary of State for Defence said in a written Answer on 10 December 2008, Official Report, column 341W, that decisions will be taken on the Initial Gate in autumn 2009 and that the Government proposed to update Parliament on progress after Initial Gate; believes this undermines the commitment made to Parliament by the Foreign Secretary in March 2007; and requests that the Initial Gate decision be delayed until Parliament is in session and can be presented with the report for scrutiny.


663DAIRY FARMERS AND MILK PRICES3:2:09
Tim Farron
Bob Spink
Mr Andrew Pelling
Peter Bottomley
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr John Leech
* 48
 Lembit Öpik
   That this House welcomes the beginning of National Dairy Week; notes with regret the reduction in the number of UK dairy farms; further notes with concern Wiseman's decision to reduce its milk price by 2.2 pence per litre and the announcement by Dairy Crest that it would cut its February milk price by 1.75 pence per litre and its Davidstow price by one pence per litre; expresses concern that the quota price of milk has crashed from approximately 32 pence per litre in 1988 to approximately one pence per litre in 2008; recognises that although the selling price of milk has increased, the share going to farmers has fallen since 1995 from 24.5 pence to 18 pence; acknowledges the role played in this by major supermarket chains in pushing down the price of dairy products with little regard for the need to get a fair price for farmers; and calls on the Government to act to protect dairy farmers by introducing a genuine supermarket regulator to establish a proper pricing calculation, based on a transparent pricing formula, that is detached from commodity pricing and which develops long-term, trusting relationships with the supply chain.


666UNITED UTILITIES AND SURFACE WATER CHARGING3:2:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Jim Dobbin
Mr David Crausby
Mr Nigel Evans
Mr Andrew Pelling
Peter Bottomley
* 55
 Laura Moffatt
   That this House welcomes the decision taken by United Utilities to introduce a moratorium on the implementation of its new system of charging for surface water and highway drainage for 2009-10 for three categories of customer, faith buildings, community amateur sports clubs and Guide and Scout Association properties; recognises the huge financial burden this has already placed on places of worship and voluntary organisations since its introduction in April 2008, threatening the future viability of these organisations; notes the huge amount of public opposition to the new charging system; further notes that the new system of charging comes as a recommendation from OFWAT and is not compulsory; and calls on United Utilities to abolish this new form of charging permanently.


668POST OFFICE NETWORK3:2:09
Lorely Burt
Bob Spink
Mr Andrew Pelling
Sir Robert Smith
Bob Russell
David Taylor
* 77
 John Barrett
   That this House notes the vital importance of the Post Office network to communities both urban and rural; believes that the Post Office network is well placed to deliver a range of financial services and products which would assist in combating financial exclusion; further believes that the Post Office network offers an opportunity to act as an advisory interface between the state and the citizen in matters such as benefit and tax credit; and further believes that in light of the Hooper Review the Post Office network must be ring-fenced as a discrete, publicly owned network, and that the Government should invest in the network to create a postbank and advisory service.

As an Amendment to Lorely Burt's proposed Motion (Post Office Network):

Kate Hoey
* 1
Line 6, leave out from `believes' to `publicly' in line 7 and insert `the Post Office network must remain a'.
9:2:09(a1)


671CLOSURE OF CHURCHES IN RANGOON3:2:09
Mr Alistair Carmichael
Mr Stephen Crabb
Bob Spink
Bob Russell
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Peter Bottomley
* 117
 Robert Key
   That this House expresses deep concern at recent events in Burma with authorities in Rangoon ordering that services cease in at least a 100 local churches with a threat of prison for non-compliance; notes the concern of some of the local Christians who believe that the immediate cause of the crackdown is church involvement in providing relief for victims of Cyclone Nargis; further notes continued widespread discrimination against religious minorities and in some places violent persecution of Christians and Muslims in other parts of Burma; calls on the Government to raise concerns about religious freedom with the State Peace and Development Council (SPDC); urges the United Nations Special Rapporteur for Freedom of Religion and Belief to investigate violations of religious freedom in Burma; and calls on the United Nations Secretary General to increase and intensify efforts to urge the SPDC to cease its widespread violation of human rights, including violations of religious freedom, to release all political prisoners, to open all parts of the country to unhindered access for international humanitarian organisations and to engage in meaningful tripartite dialogue with the National League for Democracy and the ethnic nationalities.


675ACCESS TO LOCAL LEGAL ADVICE3:2:09
Mr Austin Mitchell
Bob Russell
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Peter Bottomley
Mr John Leech
Jim Dobbin
* 59
 Anne Main
   That this House welcomes the Local Legal Advice Review undertaken for the Ministry of Justice; notes that the economic recession has triggered a significant rise in the demand for legal aid and legal advice at the very time when the future of local advice agencies has been put in doubt by the Legal Service Commission's decision to proceed with plans to commission community legal advice centres and networks through a competitive tender process; further notes the very real concerns voiced by Citizens Advice and others that the procurement model adopted by the Legal Service Commission will result in services which do not best meet the needs of clients and communities and do not protect those multiple points of access that are so vital in making certain that help and advice is available where it is most needed; and calls on the Ministry of Justice to ensure that the existing community legal advice centres are evaluated for their effectiveness in meeting advice needs in communities, particularly the needs of vulnerable groups, those in debt, and those living in less accessible parts of the community, before any further tenders are rolled out.


689SOLAR ENERGY4:2:09
Colin Challen
John Hemming
Mr David Chaytor
Kate Hoey
Mr Roger Williams
Mr Peter Ainsworth
* 274
 Laura MoffattMr Anthony WrightMr Geoffrey Robinson
 Mr Kevin BarronMr Paul MurphyMr Peter Robinson
   That this House welcomes the launch of the We Support Solar campaign; notes that globally solar photovoltaic (PV) will be a key climate change mitigation technology and that solar PV in the UK can play an important role in contributing to the UK 2020 renewable energy target; expresses its concern at the negative treatment of solar photovoltaics in the Government's 2008 renewable energy strategy consultation; and urges Ministers to ensure that the potential of the technology to deliver significant carbon dioxide reductions in the built environment, to make a significant contribution to the 2020 target and to deliver many tens of thousands of new green UK jobs is supported in the final renewable energy strategy document.


713BRITISH MILITARY ASSISTANCE TO COLOMBIA5:2:09
Tony Lloyd
Mr Frank Doran
Mr Edward Davey
Peter Bottomley
Jim Dobbin
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
* 246
 Keith VazDerek TwiggGeraldine Smith
   That this House notes with concern the increase in trades unionists assassinated in Colombia during 2008 as compared to the number killed in 2007; further notes the recent statement by the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights that she believes the Colombian security forces to be involved in `widespread and systematic' killings of civilians; welcomes the findings of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee in relation to British policy towards Colombia, and specifically draws attention to the Committee's conclusion that UK military assistance to Colombia is `inappropriate' given the `serious' human rights situation in Colombia; and calls on the Government to freeze UK military assistance to Colombia until the Colombian regime fully implements the repeated human rights recommendations made by the UN.


715ALL PARTY PARLIAMENTARY SAVE THE PUB GROUP9:2:09
Greg Mulholland
Mr Brian Binley
Mr Eric Illsley
Mr Andrew Pelling
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Bob Russell
* 76
 Kate Hoey
   That this House welcomes the formation of the All-Party Parliamentary Save the Pub Group; shares the belief of the group that British pubs are an important part of this country's history and heritage and are hugely important to the communities they serve; believes that well-run community pubs are sociable, controlled environments in which to enjoy alcohol and so are part of the solution to problem drinking; further believes that too many pubs up and down the country are being closed, for a variety of reasons, and often when they do not need to and should not close; further believes there is an urgent need for the Government to take action in terms for support and legislative changes to address this; recommends that a range of measures are needed, from lower levels of beer duty, a more level playing field between on and off-trade pricing, reform of the current model of the tie to make it fairer and more transparent and addressing the market dominance of a few huge companies, the outlawing of restrictive covenants and changes to planning law that would offer much more protection to pubs; and further recommends that local authorities use all available powers to protect and support community pubs.


735BRITISH ASSOCIATION FOR PARENTERAL AND ENTERAL NUTRITION'S REPORT ON COMBATING MALNUTRITION9:2:09
Mr Paul Burstow
Bob Russell
Andrew George
Mark Hunter
Mr Adrian Sanders
Lynne Jones
* 44
 Julia Goldsworthy
   That this House welcomes the report Combating Malnutrition by the Advisory Group on Malnutrition led by British Association for Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition; thanks the Advisory Group's members for giving up their time to identify the steps which can be taken by the Government and by all those with caring responsibilities to address the condition; expresses concern over the Advisory Group's finding that three million people are malnourished in the UK at any one time and that the total costs to the public purse of disease-related malnutrition are in excess of £13 billion per annum; notes the findings of the Advisory Group that malnutrition is closely linked to socio-economic factors such as deprivation and that as a result the burden of malnutrition exacerbates health inequalities; endorses the Advisory Group's recommendation for joined-up action by the Government, the NHS, the voluntary sector and other parties to work together to tackle malnutrition; calls on the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) to consider the case for including malnutrition in the Quality and Outcomes Framework of the General Medical Services contract from 2010-11; and further calls on the Government to ensure that as many of the Advisory Group's recommendations are implemented in full and as soon as possible, including the requirement to undertake nutritional screening in line with the recommendations already made by NICE.


759SHEEP TAGGING10:2:09
Mr Nigel Evans
Graham Stringer
Mr Angus MacNeil
Lynne Jones
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
* 33
 Mr Alistair Carmichael
   That this House is opposed to the European Commission's proposal to force British sheep farmers to tag electronically and identify every single animal in the 30 million-strong national flock; recognises that the UK has more sheep than anywhere else in Europe; realises that farmers across the UK are already under enormous financial pressure and that these measures could have a crippling effect on the industry; believes that the proposals are unnecessary, disproportionate and not practicable; and calls on the Government to support the British sheep farming industry by making the strongest representation possible to the European Commission in order that these proposals may be abandoned.


768SALE OF TOBACCO FROM VENDING MACHINES11:2:09
Chris Ruane
Mr Roger Williams
Dr Howard Stoate
Mr Brian Binley
Bob Russell
Andrew Miller
* 133
 Sandra GidleyLaura MoffattMr Russell Brown
 Julia Goldsworthy
   That this House supports the call of over 100 health organisations for urgent action to ensure a new generation of young people do not become smokers; believes that children's easy access to cigarettes through tobacco vending machines undermines other important tobacco control measures; notes that the British Heart Foundation estimates that over 46,000 11 to 15 year-old regular smokers bought cigarettes through vending machines in England and Wales in 2006; recognises that this number may now be higher as the age limit for purchasing tobacco has been extended from 16 to 18 years; expresses concern that age verification systems for vending machines using remote-controls, tokens, identity cards or other means are insecure; further notes the UK's commitments as a party to the World Health Organisation Framework Convention on Tobacco Control and its guidelines which recommend banning sales of tobacco from vending machines as they constitute a means of advertising and promotion for smoking; and therefore calls on the Government to bring forward legislative proposals to bring an immediate end to all sales of tobacco products from vending machines in England and Wales through the Health Bill.


779THALIDOMIDE AND FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE (No. 2)11:2:09
Mr Martin Caton
Bob Spink
Andrew George
Mr John Leech
Dr Desmond Turner
David Taylor
* 233
 Mr David WilshireJim DowdMr John Horam
 Hugh BayleyJohn BattleGeraldine Smith
 Mr Gordon PrenticeDr Ashok KumarMr Stephen Hepburn
 Nick AingerMr Paul MurphyAnn Clwyd
 Mr Mohammad SarwarPaul HolmesMark Lazarowicz
 Mr David HamiltonAngus RobertsonGreg Mulholland
 Mr Peter Bone
   That this House recalls that side effects of the drug Thalidomide, prescribed for prevention of morning sickness in the 1960s and 1970s, caused nearly 500 babies to be born with a range of severe disabilities; pays tribute to the campaign by journalists, politicians and others that eventually resulted in the manufacturers having to increase their compensation offer tenfold; nevertheless recognises, however, that this could not take account of unforeseen future problems arising from Thalidomide; notes that, as the surviving victims enter their 40s and 50s, many of them face a host of new problems as their bodies suffer from the wear and tear that the overuse of certain muscles has caused, dramatically restricting movement and pushing the cost of mobility up; believes that these people should now receive direct help from the state; and calls on the Government to introduce a financial assistance package to improve the lives of Thalidomide victims.

As an Amendment to Mr Martin Caton's proposed Motion (Thalidomide and Financial Assistance (No. 2)):

Frank Cook
Mark Durkan
Mrs Iris Robinson
Mr Phil Willis
* 4
Line 11, at end add `at the earliest date.'.
23:2:09(a1)


784UN SECURITY COUNCIL AND THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT11:2:09
Paul Rowen
John Hemming
Mr David Laws
Mr Don Foster
Mr Michael Moore
Mr Adrian Sanders
* 40
 Jeremy Corbyn
   That this House is disappointed that the Government has not requested the Security Council of the UN to refer allegations of war crimes to the International Criminal Court; notes that both the UN Secretary General and Israel have agreed to undertake inquiries but is concerned that Israel has not ratified the Rome Statute and believes that without reference to the International Criminal Court it is unlikely that anyone will be indicted for war crimes.


826STEPS RESEARCH INTO DEVELOPMENT DYSPLASIA OF THE HIP23:2:09
Mr David Anderson
Ian Stewart
Peter Bottomley
Dr Doug Naysmith
Dr Desmond Turner
Mr Gordon Prentice
* 107
 Dr John PughMr Andy Slaughter
   That this House warmly welcomes Baby Hip Health Awareness Week from 23 to 28 February 2009, organised by the STEPS charity, which provides support and information for lower limb conditions in children and young adults; notes that the aim of the national screening policy is to identify and treat infants with a hip abnormality at an early stage, with a post-birth hospital check and another check at six to eight weeks, because late diagnosis can lead to complex surgery and lifelong problems, often impacting on psychological development; further notes that up to 2,000 children a year are diagnosed with development dysplasia of the hip (DDH) which requires treatment involving splints and plaster body casts; is concerned, therefore that a STEPS survey of acute trusts and of primary care trusts (PCTs) showed a staggering gap in health policy which, if it were correctly followed, could detect DDH at an early age and prevent years of pain and emotional distress; is disappointed that many PCTs refuse to take responsibility for checking babies' hips, leaving it to GPs and creating massive inconsistency in procedure; further welcomes the STEPS survey of parents with children affected by lower limb conditions which shows that while many praised the care received during treatment for DDH, the majority felt that they were not informed about the condition, which was not clearly explained to them; and urges the Government to meet STEPS to investigate how these shortcomings can be overcome.


845DEFORESTATION, CLIMATE CHANGE AND LIVESTOCK23:2:09
Andrew George
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Lynne Jones
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Mr David Drew
Tony Baldry
* 236
 Mr Edward DaveyMr Jim CunninghamDr Brian Iddon
 Mrs Louise EllmanMr Fraser Kemp
   That this House notes that global livestock and animal feed production contributes to 18 per cent. of global greenhouse gas emissions and is currently the most significant driver of biodiversity loss worldwide; further notes that the large-scale conversion of forests and other valuable habitats into croplands for the production of animal feeds such as soy for intensive livestock farming is a cause of particular concern; recognises the associated impacts on small farmers and communities in developing countries who are often forced off their land; urges the Government to undertake an assessment of the scale and impact of this trend and the UK's role in it, and to gauge whether the UK's livestock industry has become overly dependent on soy-based animal feed which has such an unwelcome and unsustainable impact upon the environment; and calls on the Government to bring forward the measures necessary to reduce the UK's impact on global greenhouse gas emissions and biodiversity loss from the livestock sector whilst avoiding the export of these impacts overseas and supporting a viable, sustainable and thriving UK farming industry.


866VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN24:2:09
Mr Alan Meale
Ms Diane Abbott
Dr Rudi Vis
Joan Walley
Bill Etherington
Rosemary McKenna
* 74
 Mr Joe Benton
   That this House is alarmed to note that every year about 3 million women in the United Kingdom experience violence, which alone costs the nation over £40 billion per annum, is aware that the Equality and Human Rights Commission, the End Violence Against Women Campaign, Amnesty International UK and a range of other like-minded organisations have published a new Map of Gaps Report which highlights inadequate services provisions available in certain areas of Britain for women who experience rape, forced marriage, domestic or other violence; and calls upon the Government to take action to fill such gaps to ensure that women who find themselves in violent situations are given the necessary level of support they need.


880ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND AND CLIMATE CHANGE25:2:09
Martin Horwood
Mark Durkan
Mrs Ann Cryer
Mr David Drew
Lynne Jones
John McDonnell
* 81
 Norman BakerSteve WebbMr Adrian Sanders
 Hugh BayleyPaul HolmesMr Alistair Carmichael
 Tim Farron
   That this House notes that one of the most significant outcomes of the recent financial crisis has been the Government's acquisition of a majority stake in the Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS); further notes that RBS has been identified by campaign groups People and Planet and Platform as the UK bank that is the most heavily involved in financing the expansion of fossil fuel projects around the world, and that the carbon dioxide emissions embedded in RBS's project finance in 2006 were calculated to be greater than the carbon dioxide emissions of Scotland itself; believes that the fact that banks play such a large role in providing finance to projects that are exacerbating climate change has been wholly unaddressed in Government policy; further believes that there is an urgent need for the Government's new banking regulations to include environmental concerns as well as financial concerns; calls on the Government to use its majority share in RBS to prioritise climate change as a principal concern in RBS's lending decisions; further calls on the Government to require RBS to calculate, publish and cap embedded emissions resulting from its lending to fossil fuel projects, and to set annual targets for reducing these emissions; and further calls on the Government to promote RBS investments in renewable energy, new green jobs and the infrastructure needed to decarbonise the economy.


909INTERNATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY AGENCY26:2:09
Colin Challen
Peter Bottomley
Mark Durkan
Lynne Jones
John McDonnell
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 39
 Mr Peter Ainsworth
   That this House regrets that the UK is not giving the establishment of the International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) its wholehearted support; notes that global subsidies to renewable energy have amounted to one-eighth of those given to fossil fuels and that a global approach to the promotion of renewable energy is urgently called for; and therefore urges the Government to recognise that it cannot claim to be a global leader on tackling climate change if it is not prepared to will the means to mitigate it and join with 76 other signatory countries seeking to make IRENA work.


912UN CONVENTION ON THE RIGHTS OF PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES (No. 2)26:2:09
Jim Dobbin
Mark Durkan
Lynne Jones
John McDonnell
Bob Spink
David Taylor
* 40
 Mrs Louise Ellman
   That this House congratulates the Government on its commitment to the protection and recognition of the rights of disabled people across the world by leading the way on the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities; applauds the current plans to ratify this Convention and praises the commitment to equality for disabled people by 2025; regrets however that the Government now plans to place a reservation on Article 24 on Education in the Convention, thereby preventing disabled and non-disabled people from living and learning together in their own local communities; and urges the Government to secure a full ratification of the Convention without reservations in order to guarantee that there will be no educational apartheid for future generations of disabled people.


918NATIONAL HOUSING FEDERATION AND PREPAYMENT METER CUSTOMERS26:2:09
John Austin
Peter Bottomley
Mr Andrew Dismore
Paul Holmes
Lynne Jones
John McDonnell
* 117
 Mr Anthony WrightJohn BattleGeraldine Smith
   That this House welcomes Government assurances that, if necessary, legislation would be introduced to outlaw the overcharging of prepayment meter customers; notes that E.ON, Scottish Power and npower have equalised charges which they make to their prepayment meter customers with those who pay by quarterly bill, but that British Gas, EDF and Scottish and Southern Energy (SSE) continue to charge their prepay customers more; further notes that the National Housing Federation calculates that British Gas, EDF and SSE will overcharge their 1.7 million prepay customers by £8.6 million every month over the next year, with British Gas charging its prepayment customers £77 more over 2009 than those on quarterly bills, SSE charging £38 more and EDF charging £19 more; refutes the claim by Ofgem that it has been successful in its campaign to stop this overcharging; congratulates the National Housing Federation on championing the cause of some of the most vulnerable people on low incomes; and believes it is time for the Government to introduce legislation to equalise prepay bills with those charged to people on a quarterly basis.


923AVAILABILITY OF VITAMINS AND MINERAL SUPPLEMENTS2:3:09
Mike Penning
Mr Andrew Lansley
Chris Grayling
Mr Stephen O'Brien
Mr Mark Prisk
Mr David Amess
* 64
 Mr Edward Vaizey
   That this House notes that the United Kingdom has a rigorous and effective regime for permitting onto the market under the provisions of the Food Safety Act 1990 only such higher potency vitamin and mineral supplements as are accepted as safe and appropriately labelled by the Food Standards Agency; is deeply concerned that the future availability of such safe and popular supplements is now threatened by the current process through which the European Union is proposing pan-European limits on the potencies of such supplements under the provisions of Article 5 of the Food Supplements Directive; further notes that successive Ministers have pledged to defend the future availability of such supplements but have not yet secured sufficient support from other member states and the European Commission to ensure that the policy objectives of the Government can be achieved; and calls on the Prime Minister personally to intervene with the President of the European Commission to ensure that the right of UK manufacturers to produce, specialist retailers to sell, and informed consumers to choose to buy such safe and popular supplements is not unacceptably curtailed through an unnecessarily restrictive interpretation of the legislation.


937ARREST AND TRIAL OF BAHÁ'ÍS IN IRAN2:3:09
Lembit Öpik
Peter Luff
David Lepper
Ian Stewart
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
* 111
 Stephen Williams
   That this House notes the arrests in March and May 2008 of Mahvash Sabet, Fariba Kamalabadi, Jamaloddin Khanjani, Afif Naeimi, Saeid Rezaie, Behrouz Tavakkoli and Vahid Tizfahm, members of an informal leadership council of the Iranian Bahá'i community; further notes with concern the announcement of 12 February 2009 by the deputy-prosecutor of Tehran that these seven Bahá'is are to face a revolutionary court to answer charges including, espionage for Israel, insulting religious sanctities and propaganda against the Islamic republic, despite no evidence produced against them to date; observes that such accusations can merit capital punishment under Iranian law; is concerned that the charges against these Bahá'i community leaders may be motivated by a growing culture of anti-Bahá'i repression in Iran; and calls on the Government to protest to the Iranian authorities and press for the immediate release of these seven individuals.


940FUNDING FOR THE TRAINING OF EDUCATIONAL PSYCHOLOGISTS2:3:09
Mr Greg Pope
Harry Cohen
Mr Paul Keetch
Mr Gordon Prentice
Mr Fabian Hamilton
John Mann
* 105
 Julia Goldsworthy
   That this House expresses concern that the basis of funding for the training of educational psychologists in England is undermined by the lack of long-term stability or security; notes that the funding of the training is the responsibility of individual local authorities; believes that a national need for educational psychologists should be met by a national supply, funded nationally; and calls on the Department for Children, Schools and Families to investigate methods of providing secure national funding for the training of educational psychologists.


948ANIMAL WELFARE IN CIRCUSES3:3:09
John Austin
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr Lee Scott
Bob Russell
Lynne Jones
Mark Hunter
* 96
 Mr Michael Mates
   That this House shares the RSPCA's deep concern at the recent introduction of elephants into a circus in Nottinghamshire; hopes that the public will boycott the circus in protest; believes that the Government should intervene in this case and state categorically that it opposes the use of wild species in circuses; and urges the Government to bring forward proposals to ban the use of wild animals in circuses without further delay.


960LET THEM WORK CAMPAIGN3:3:09
Lynne Jones
Andrew George
Peter Bottomley
Mark Durkan
Bob Russell
Mr Martin Caton
* 89
 Joan WalleyRuth KellyMr Edward O'Hara
 Mr Denis MurphyMr Chris MullinSir Menzies Campbell
 Mr David HamiltonNorman Lamb
   That this House welcomes the Let Them Work campaign to allow asylum seekers permission to work while they are waiting for a decision about their claim; notes with concern that asylum seekers who fled persecution in their own countries are among the most vulnerable people in the UK and are being denied the opportunity to work to support themselves and their families, to pay taxes, and to contribute to the economy; is additionally concerned about the situation of those asylum seekers without status who are unable to return home, many of whom spend years in limbo and are reliant on charity hand-outs or forced into illegal work just to survive; is alarmed that this leaves already vulnerable people open to destitution and exploitation; and therefore calls on the Government to allow asylum seekers to work if they have been waiting longer than six months for a full resolution on their asylum claim and to ensure that permission to work remains for people whose claim for asylum is refused, but who are unable to return home immediately through no fault of their own.


963ARCHER REPORT INTO CONTAMINATED BLOOD AND BLOOD PRODUCTS3:3:09
Mr Edward O'Hara
Jenny Willott
Charlotte Atkins
Bob Spink
Mark Durkan
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 193
 Patrick HallMiss Julie KirkbrideHugh Bayley
 Mr Eric MartlewFrank CookMr Frank Doran
 Sir Menzies CampbellDavid HowarthStewart Hosie
 Philip DaviesMark Hunter
   That this House welcomes the publication of the Archer Report on the use of contaminated blood and blood products in NHS treatments and hopes that the victims of the use of such products will receive swift and appropriate recompense; and calls on the Government to make a full and speedy response to the report's findings and to make a commitment to implement its recommendations as soon as possible.


976ANIMAL WELFARE IN CIRCUSES (No. 2)4:3:09
Mark Pritchard
Mr Lee Scott
Mr Andrew Dismore
David Taylor
Mr David Drew
Lynne Jones
* 65
 Mr Michael MatesSarah Teather
   That this House notes with concern the continuing use of non-domesticated animals in circuses and more recently the re-introduction of elephants by the Great British Circus; is increasingly concerned by the delay of the Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs in reporting on increasing amounts of evidence surrounding poor animal welfare standards in circuses; believes that the report of the Chair of the Circus Working Group fails to provide reliable information on this subject; supports the work of the Captive Animals Protection Society and others in achieving an end to animal use in circuses; and urges the Government to maintain its commitment to ban the use of non-domesticated animals in travelling circuses and to limit the use of domesticated species under a strict, accountable and open licensing system.


979BRISTOL TO LONDON RAIL LINE ELECTRIFICATION4:3:09
Stephen Williams
Mr Don Foster
Steve Webb
Mr David Heath
Norman Baker
Mr David Drew
* 24
 Sandra Gidley
   That this House notes that the Great Western main railway line uses diesel trains originally brought into service in the 1970s and designed to travel at 125 miles per hour; believes that in the 21st century modern rolling stock travelling at higher speeds than those envisaged 40 years ago is a reasonable expectation for passengers; and further believes that the journey should be along a sustainable electrified line and that investment in high-speed rail for the West Country and other regions is preferable to an unsustainable expansion of aviation and a third runway at Heathrow Airport.

As an Amendment to Stephen Williams's proposed Motion (Bristol to London Rail Line Electrification):

Mr David Wilshire
* 1
Line 5, leave out from `line' to end.
6:3:09(a1)


985WATER CHARGES FOR SCOUT GROUPS4:3:09
John Battle
Mr Andrew Dismore
David Taylor
Jim Dobbin
Mr David Drew
Lynne Jones
* 95
 Gwyn ProsserLaura MoffattSteve Webb
 Miss Julie KirkbrideCharlotte AtkinsClare Short
 Derek TwiggMr Paul MurphyAnnette Brooke
 Paul Farrelly
   That this House notes the enormous contribution scout groups and other voluntary organisations make in helping local communities; notes with dismay the water regulator Ofwat's decision to change the way water companies charge small charities and community groups for surface water run-off, and the impact that this will have on the financial future of organisations that rely on fund-raising and members' subscriptions for income, and are therefore particularly ill-placed to afford the huge increases in bills as a result; considers that this highlights the need to protect the ability of such organisations and the communities they serve to access water services; and therefore calls on Ofwat to support the Scout Association's call for a social tariff regime for community and voluntary groups by enabling such a pricing system to be used by water companies.


994JOBS AND BUSINESSES IN THE UK LOGISTICS SECTOR5:3:09
Gwyn Prosser
Mr Greg Knight
Mr Eric Martlew
Mr Tim Boswell
Mr Mike Hancock
Paul Rowen
* 119
 Dr Richard Taylor
   That this House supports the goals of the Every Penny Counts campaign which is supporting jobs and businesses in the road freight sector; notes that the success of the British economy is dependent on the success of its logistics sector, which directly employs some 2.3 million people and indirectly supports the work of many millions of others; recognises that the current economic downturn has had a severe and highly damaging impact on the logistics sector, causing insolvencies in the sector to double from fourth quarter 2007 to fourth quarter 2008; notes with concern that increases in costs to the logistics sector's operations, such as increases to fuel duty and road vehicle testing charges are specifically targeting UK logistics companies that are struggling to stay afloat; and calls on policymakers to give greater priority to the impact of economic measures on the freight sector before more companies are forced out of business and more jobs are lost.


1008LOCAL AUTHORITIES AND THE PROVISION OF LAND FOR ALLOTMENTS9:3:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Jim Dobbin
Dr Brian Iddon
Bob Spink
Mr Colin Breed
* 58
 Mr Robert Walter
   That this House recognises the importance of allotments within the local community; notes local authorities' statutory obligation to provide land for allotments is not being met; further notes that demand from the public for allotments exceeds current provision and is increasing; and calls on the Government to bring forward legislative proposals to deliver an increase in the volume of land provided by local authorities for allotments.

As an Amendment to Mr Lindsay Hoyle's proposed Motion (Local Authorities and the Provision of Land for Allotments):

Mr Mike Weir
Sammy Wilson
Pete Wishart
Angus Robertson
Dr Kim Howells
* 5
Line 5, at end add `; further urges private owners to consider the provision of unused land for allotments; and applauds the decision of Dalhousie Estates to provide a portion of land in Brechin for allotments.'.
10:3:09(a1)


1034POLITICAL SITUATION IN TIBET10:3:09
Norman Baker
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
Bob Russell
Graham Stringer
Mark Durkan
* 51
 Laura Moffatt
   That this House condemns the state of de facto martial law that Tibet has been subjected to by the Chinese government on the eve of the 50th anniversary of the Tibetan Uprising and the flight of the Dalai Lama; recognises the severe impact on basic human rights and freedoms the present Chinese approach is having on the Tibetan people; notes that Tibetans continue to be tortured and killed and that thousands are subject to arbitrary and heavy-handed restrictions of movement; and calls on the Chinese government to end the de facto martial law and to lift the official ban on access to Tibet for journalists and aid organisations.


1042EXPERIMENTS ON PRIMATES10:3:09
Bob Spink
Andrew George
Bob Russell
David Taylor
Mr Mike Weir
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 52
 Mr David Crausby
   That this House is concerned to note that thousands of primates are used in experiments across Europe each year; further notes with deep regret that the European Commission refuses to implement a ban on live primate experiments across Europe; further notes that this is contrary to the wishes of 80 per cent. of the population; and therefore calls on the Government to promote strongly a timetabled replacement of all primate experiments in Europe.


1060NATIONAL DEMENTIA STRATEGY11:3:09
Robert Key
Mrs Betty Williams
Greg Mulholland
Mr Tim Boswell
Mr Gordon Marsden
Dr Richard Taylor
* 126
 Mr Mark OatenLaura MoffattMr Tom Harris
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House welcomes the publication of the National Dementia Strategy; is concerned that within 30 years dementia will affect 1.4 million people in the UK alone, costing the economy at least £50 billion annually; agrees with the Alzheimer's Research Trust that dementia research must have substantially more financial support than its current 2.5 per cent. share of the medical research budget; and urges the Government to increase support for the UK's world-class dementia scientists in their search for new prevention, treatments and cures for Alzheimer's and other dementias.

As Amendments to Robert Key's proposed Motion (National Dementia Strategy):

Dr Evan Harris
* 1
Line 5, after `budget' insert `where funding bodies, through peer review, agree that the quality of applications merits funding approval.'.
20:4:09(a1)
Dr Evan Harris
* 1
Line 7, at end add `; and recognises the important part played by animal research in such work as well as the potential of embryonic stem cell science.'.
20:4:09(a2)


1064LOCAL SPENDING REPORTS AND THE SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITIES ACT 200711:3:09
Mr David Drew
Mr Nick Hurd
Julia Goldsworthy
Bob Russell
Bob Spink
Tony Baldry
* 201
 Sir John StanleyMrs Maria MillerWillie Rennie
 Robert Neill
   That this House welcomes the provisions of the Sustainable Communities Act 2007 requiring the publication of local spending reports; believes that people have a right to know how their money is spent by public bodies; especially welcomes the assurances given by the Minister for Local Government, the hon. Member for Oldham East and Saddleworth, that the local spending reports will include all public agencies; further welcomes the Minister's assurance that the purpose is to achieve a report that identifies how much will be spent in each area by the authorities; is therefore very alarmed that the consultation now issued on the local spending reports proposes only to include local authorities, including fire authorities and police authorities, and primary care trusts, and to exclude all other public bodies despite the assurances of the Minister; believes it to be unacceptable that this document is now in blatant contravention of the expressed assurances of the Minister; and calls for proper local spending reports to be published, which give effect to those assurances.


1069FUEL POVERTY BILL11:3:09
Alan Simpson
Mark Williams
Dr Brian Iddon
Mr David Drew
David Taylor
Nick Ainger
* 206
 Dr Ashok Kumar
   That this House notes that 418 hon. Members of all parties supported the Warm Homes and Energy Conservation Act 2000 during its passage through Parliament; notes that the Act brought about a statutory duty to end fuel poverty in vulnerable households by 2010 and in the rest of the sector by 2016; regrets therefore that a recent High Court judgment ruled that that statutory duty set pursuant to the Act was merely a duty to make efforts and that the targets were merely aspirations; further notes with concern that five million UK households will be unable to afford to heat their homes this winter and that a recent Help the Aged survey found that 4.5 million pensioners were planning to live in one room to keep warm; welcomes the introduction with cross-party support by the hon. Member for Somerton and Frome of the Fuel Poverty Bill, which reinstates the statutory duty to end fuel poverty by requiring the homes of the fuel poor to be brought up to the energy efficiency standards currently required for new homes and by the use of social tariffs for vulnerable customers in the short term; and calls on the Government to support this Bill and do everything that it can to ensure that it becomes law in this session of Parliament.


1078POSTAL SERVICES BILL [LORDS]12:3:09
John Thurso
Dr Vincent Cable
Lorely Burt
Danny Alexander
Mr David Heath
Mr Paul Burstow
* 47
 Mr Edward Davey
   That this House notes the introduction of the Postal Services Bill in the House of Lords; notes that it fails to offer the investment needed to modernise the Post Office network and to enable it to develop new services, fails to facilitate the creation of a Postbank to offer banking services to all, fails to give the Royal Mail the ability to borrow on capital markets, fails to provide the enabling powers to widen the remit of the Post Office and Royal Mail to enable them to compete in new markets, fails to facilitate the creation of any form of employee shared ownership scheme or staff council for Royal Mail and fails to give customers a proper voice to hold the activities of Royal Mail and Post Office Limited to account; believes that the Bill will not therefore secure a sustainable and competitive future for either the Royal Mail or the Post Office network; and calls on the Government to incorporate all these features within the Bill and in addition to ensure that there is a universal service obligation in place on a statutory basis six days a week throughout the UK and to ensure that the Post Office network is ring-fenced as a discrete, publicly-owned network.


108130th ANNIVERSARY OF HEADWAY THE BRAIN INJURY ASSOCIATION12:3:09
Bob Russell
Mrs Ann Cryer
Lynne Jones
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Gordon Prentice
Mr Robert N. Wareing
* 103
 David Howarth
   That this House congratulates Headway, the brain injury association, for providing outstanding help and support to brain injury survivors and their families for the last 30 years; acknowledges the vital role that the charity plays in helping to improve quality of life after brain injury; notes that half a million people live with the long-term effects of brain injury; wishes the charity well in its future endeavours; and encourages hon. and right hon. Members to support the charity on a local and national level.


1082POST BANK COALITION12:3:09
Jon Cruddas
Mr Andrew Dismore
Colin Burgon
Mr Gordon Prentice
Mr Robert N. Wareing
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
* 218
 Richard BurdenMr Kevin Barron
   That this House congratulates the Post Bank Coalition of the Communication Workers Union, Federation of Small Businesses, New Economics Foundation, Unite the Union, National Convention of Pensioners and Public Interest Research Centre, on its plans for a new state-owned Post Bank based on the Post Office network; recognises the importance such a Bank could have in underpinning the future sustainability of the Post Office network; and calls on the Government, as a matter of urgency, to set up a Post Bank to combat financial exclusion and allow communities and local businesses to access a fair and trusted banking system.


1100INDEPENDENT INQUIRY INTO IRAQ WAR16:3:09
John Barrett
Mr Edward Davey
Paul Holmes
Mark Hunter
Jeremy Corbyn
Lynne Jones
* 57
 Sarah Teather
   That this House believes the invasion of Iraq was a serious foreign policy error that has destabilised the Middle East; notes that public opinion is strongly in favour of a full public inquiry into the UK's role in the 2003 invasion of Iraq; believes that such an inquiry would in no way detract from the efforts of UK armed forces personnel in Iraq who have served with bravery and distinction while helping to rebuild the country; and calls on the Government to launch a full independent inquiry into the invasion of Iraq without delay.


1107ARCHER INQUIRY INTO CONTAMINATED BLOOD AND BLOOD PRODUCTS17:3:09
Bob Spink
Andrew George
Mr Mike Weir
Mr John Leech
Mr Martin Caton
Peter Bottomley
* 35
 Mr John WhittingdaleLorely Burt
   That this House congratulates Lord Archer on his Independent Public Inquiry into Contaminated Blood and Blood Products; welcomes his recommendations on forms of relief for the haemophilia community; notes with concern that these forms of relief are restricted to that community and therefore discriminate against other patient groups that have been similarly affected; and calls on the Government to extend the scope of the relief to include all other patient groups which have been infected.


1124IR3518:3:09
Lorely Burt
Dr Vincent Cable
Sir Robert Smith
Chris Huhne
Bob Spink
Andrew George
* 109
 Dr Tony WrightJulie MorganMr Mike Weir
 Albert OwenDavid SimpsonJohn Mason
   That this House notes with concern the 10 year anniversary of the Government's implementation of IR35; further notes that the 1.4 million freelancers in the United Kingdom face a perpetual threat of a costly and distressing HM Revenue and Customs investigation under IR35; further notes that IR35 obliges freelancers to spend time and money assessing their status as best they can, with contract reviews, tax investigation insurances and negotiations with clients and agencies, and that this effort would be better spent generating wealth for the UK economy; highlights concerns expressed by the Professional Contractors Group (PCG) that 1,462 of the 1,468 cases known to PCG have resulted in no extra tax being owed; further notes that there is no evidence that IR35 is raising any money for the Exchequer; and calls on the Treasury, in light of the current economic difficulties, to remove unnecessary barriers to enterprise and to abolish IR35 at the earliest opportunity.


1142PUPPY FARMS20:3:09
John McDonnell
Mrs Ann Cryer
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
David Taylor
Jeremy Corbyn
Peter Bottomley
* 72
 Laura Moffatt
   That this House notes the continuing reports of allegations of cruelty and animal suffering associated with puppy farms; and calls upon the Government to review the effectiveness of the current procedures and legislation relating to animal safety in puppy farms.


1148ANIMAL WELFARE AND THE PRODUCTION OF FOIE GRAS23:3:09
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Kelvin Hopkins
Mark Durkan
Bob Russell
Lynne Jones
* 48
 Laura Moffatt
   That this House notes that foie gras is traditionally produced by forcing metal pipes down the throats of ducks and geese and over-feeding them, causing their livers to swell to 10 times the normal size; further notes that the production, but not the sale, of foie gras is banned in the UK; applauds the work of banfoiegras.org.uk; calls on restaurants to use brands of faux gras which are supported by the RSPCA and Compassion in World Farming and are produced from free-range ducks and geese without force-feeding; and further calls on the Government to prohibit the sale of traditionally-produced foie gras in the UK.


1154TENANTS IN THE PRIVATE RENTED SECTOR AND REPOSSESSIONS23:3:09
Ms Sally Keeble
Martin Linton
Peter Bottomley
Mr Colin Breed
Andrew George
Mark Durkan
* 123
 David CairnsAnne Main
   That this House recognises that tenants in the private rented sector risk losing their homes through repossession when landlords default on mortgages; notes that many tenants are evicted with little or no notice, sometimes only finding out when the bailiff arrives on their doorstep; further notes that many of these tenants could be at risk of homelessness through no fault of their own; and calls on the Government to take urgent action to avert a potential crisis by giving courts the discretion to defer possession and allow tenants sufficient time to find another home.


116310 YEAR ANNIVERSARY OF NATIONAL MINIMUM WAGE24:3:09
Mr David Blunkett
Tony Lloyd
Mr David Anderson
Jon Cruddas
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Andrew George
* 120
 Laura Moffatt
   That this House welcomes the 10th anniversary of the introduction of the National Minimum Wage on 1 April 2009; applauds the fact that employees in more than one million jobs have benefited, two-thirds of them women; believes that annual uprating and effective enforcement are the key to its continued success; regards the current economic climate as an opportunity to increase the spending power of the low paid; calls for an end to discriminatory lower age rates for young workers; and further calls on the Low Pay Commission and Government to end the exemption of some apprenticeships from the national minimum wage.


1166GET WALKING DAY 30 MAY 200924:3:09
Ms Angela C. Smith (Sheffield, Hillsborough)
Bob Russell
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
Graham Stringer
Mr Mike Hancock
* 110
 Richard Younger-Ross
   That this House welcomes the Ramblers' second annual Get Walking Day on 30 May 2009, offering thousands of people in England, Scotland and Wales the opportunity to enjoy a short walk with the Ramblers; applauds the Get Walking Day goal to inspire families and individuals of all ages to go for a walk and to continue walking regularly; notes that doctors agree that moderate exercise like walking helps protect people from many illnesses and conditions including obesity, depression, heart disease and stroke, high blood pressure, osteoarthritis, the most common type of diabetes and many cancers; recognises that walking for a total of 30 minutes a day, or 60 minutes for children, meets the Chief Medical Officer's minimum recommendations for physical activity; is alarmed that 70 per cent. of adults and 40 per cent. of children do not meet the target, with serious consequences for public health; further notes that the cost to the NHS of obesity alone will rise to £10 billion a year by 2050 if current trends continue; believes that walking is the easiest form of exercise for the greatest number of people and that almost everyone can do it, anywhere and at any time, for free, with no special equipment or training; and urges hon. Members to support Get Walking Day and to encourage people to join in by going for a local walk.


1171UK RELATIONS WITH CUBA24:3:09
Mr Ian Taylor
Paul Holmes
Robert Key
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Colin Burgon
Sir Peter Viggers
* 202
 Sandra GidleyMr Mark ToddMr Frank Field
 Mrs Louise EllmanMr Roger WilliamsRichard Younger-Ross
 Julia GoldsworthyTim FarronSir Peter Soulsby
 Willie Rennie
   That this House welcomes the fresh approach to international relations with Cuba including recent legislation in the US to lift family visiting restrictions on Cuban-Americans; notes the recent formal visits to Cuba by the Irish and Spanish Foreign Ministers and Presidents of Chile and Argentina; further notes the recent visit by the Shadow Foreign Secretary to Cuba; welcomes the fact that the UK enjoys excellent relations with Cuba in the fields of sport, biotechnology and the arts; and calls on the Government to send a high level Ministerial delegation to Cuba, led by the Foreign Secretary, to build on UK-Cuba relations and UK interests in the region.


1195SHARK FINNING26:3:09
Martin Horwood
Mr Richard Benyon
Mr Russell Brown
Peter Bottomley
Mr Nigel Evans
Mr Mike Hancock
* 42
 Norman LambJo SwinsonEmily Thornberry
   That this House notes that over 70 per cent. of UK sharks, skates and rays are categorised by the International Union for Conservation of Nature as threatened or near threatened with extinction; further notes the recent publication of the European Community Plan of Action for Sharks, and the context of EU legislation EC No. 1185/2003, prohibiting the removal of shark fins at sea; believes the UK Government should build on the foundation of previous shark conservation actions and lead the way in Europe as a champion of shark conservation, promptly implementing effective shark conservation and management measures; further believes that, on no occasion should the UK Government approve any derogation from the shark finning legislation in order to allow UK-registered vessels to remove shark fins at sea; and urges the Government to lead the way in Europe by ceasing provision of special permits to remove shark fins at sea, thus enforcing the original intention of the shark finning legislation, and supporting improved shark fisheries monitoring, management and conservation measures.


1196TAX STATUS OF NON-PARTY POLITICAL PEERS26:3:09
Mr Gordon Prentice
Peter Bottomley
Paul Flynn
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Martin Caton
Mrs Janet Dean
* 23
 Jo Swinson
   That this House notes with approval the revised criteria to be used by the House of Lords Appointments Commission in respect of new non-party political peers, requiring nominees to be resident in the UK for tax purposes and to confirm their acceptance of the requirement to remain so.


1201WINTER FUEL PAYMENTS FOR PEOPLE WITH SPINAL CORD INJURIES26:3:09
Ms Katy Clark
Mr Charles Kennedy
Lindsay Roy
Peter Bottomley
Sandra Osborne
Sir Robert Smith
* 37
 Jo Swinson
   That this House notes that people with paralysis and serious spinal cord injury have an impaired ability to regulate their body temperature due to an inability to constrict their blood vessels; further notes that this often leads to people with serious spinal cord injuries having to heat their homes at higher temperatures than other households and therefore increasing many of their fuel bills; expresses concern that many single people with spinal cord injury who have a carer or who do not live alone only have access to a minimum income of £84.40 or £96.70 depending on the level of disability living allowance they receive; and calls on the Government to make people with spinal cord injury eligible for either the £200 annual winter fuel payments currently paid to pensioners or an equivalent winter fuel payment scheme.


1208OFFICE OF FAIR TRADING SAVE XMAS CAMPAIGN27:3:09
John Mason
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Dr Brian Iddon
Mrs Ann Cryer
Lynne Jones
* 32
 Jo Swinson
   That this House supports the Office of Fair Trading Save Xmas campaign which was established in response to the Farepak collapse and encourages households to start saving now for Christmas 2009; welcomes the campaign's sensible advice for savers at a time of economic uncertainty, with jobs at risk and poor interest rates; and expresses continued concern that victims of the Farepak Christmas collapse in 2006 are still waiting to receive compensation.


1212SAVE OUR HIGH STREETS CAMPAIGN27:3:09
John Mann
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Jeremy Corbyn
* 54
 Jo Swinson
   That this House welcomes the Daily Mirror and Federation of Small Businesses' Campaign to Save Our High Streets which calls for monthly instead of quarterly rents to ease bills, the abolition of upward only rent reviews, and measures to force banks to lend to small business firms again; believes that local town centres are the lifeblood of the local community, providing jobs, services and entertainment; and calls on the Government to work with partners to save the UK's high streets and help communities through this difficult period.


1213TEACHER TRAINING AND PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT30:3:09
Mr Fabian Hamilton
Mr Phil Willis
Mr Tim Boswell
Kelvin Hopkins
Bob Spink
Mr John Leech
* 38
 Jo Swinson
   That this House is concerned that initial teacher training and continuing professional development available for teachers does not adequately train them to use the resources available in a twenty-first century classroom; believes that because of this the potential of ICT resources such as interactive whiteboards and virtual learning environments is not being fully exploited; and calls on the Government to support teachers' development in the context of their schools' present and future needs.


1221SATURATED FATS30:3:09
Mike Penning
Mr Andrew Lansley
Mr Mark Prisk
Greg Mulholland
Mr Peter Bone
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
* 53
 Jo Swinson
   That this House congratulates Asda, Boots, The Co-operative Group, Iceland, Marks and Spencer, Sainsbury's, Tesco and Waitrose for their commitment to reducing the levels of saturated fat consumed in the UK; welcomes retailers proactively taking voluntary steps to reformulate existing foodstuffs, introduce lower fat alternatives of popular products, use labelling to inform consumers of the levels of saturated fat in their food and use their understanding of consumer purchasing behaviour to raise awareness and develop long-lasting change; recognises that tackling the nation's obesity crisis requires a multi-faceted approach; and further welcomes members of the British Retail Consortium leading by example and playing their part.


1233CLIMATE CHANGE (SECTORAL TARGETS) BILL31:3:09
Mr Martin Caton
Mr David Heath
Joan Walley
Mr David Chaytor
Colin Challen
Mr Michael Meacher
* 131
 Mr Ronnie CampbellJo Swinson
   That this House welcomes the Climate Change (Sectoral Targets) Bill introduced on 11 February by the hon. Member for Gower, which would require the Secretary of State to set long-term targets for energy efficiency in the domestic and non-domestic sectors, for renewable energy, for microgeneration and for other low carbon sources of energy generation in order to satisfy all of the UK's energy needs, provide for security of supply and also help achieve carbon reduction targets; notes that the Bill would also require a strategy to be drawn up and implemented by the Secretary of State in order to achieve those targets, and believes that such an approach will provide an immediate, flexible, realistic and cost-effective way of delivering the stated objectives of energy policy which would also create jobs and help regenerate the economy.


1235ALLEGATIONS OF WAR CRIMES IN GAZA (No. 2)31:3:09
Martin Linton
Ms Karen Buck
Dr Phyllis Starkey
Richard Burden
Andrew George
Bob Russell
* 76
 Jo Swinson
   That this House notes the allegations which have been made in respect of war crimes committed during Operation Cast Lead in Gaza in December 2008 and January 2009 on the basis of investigations by Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and The Guardian newspaper; notes that these allegations include the use of human shields, unmanned aerial vehicles and the targeting of medical staff and medical facilities, all of which are prohibited under the Fourth Geneva Convention; recalls that Britain is a High Contracting Party to the Convention and is, therefore, legally required to uphold its provisions; and urges the Government to call for an independent inquiry sanctioned by the UN Security Council into allegations of war crimes during Operation Cast Lead.


1239CONTACTPOINT DATABASE31:3:09
Annette Brooke
Mr David Laws
Bob Russell
Mr Mike Hancock
Paul Holmes
Mr Colin Breed
* 41
 Sarah Teather
   That this House notes the announcement of another delay to the implementation of ContactPoint because of further concerns about the accuracy and security of the database; expresses concern over the safety implications of such a vast database containing potentially sensitive information in the light of security breaches in various Government departments; further expresses concern over the Joseph Rowntree Foundation's recent report stating that the database is almost certainly illegal under human rights and data protection law; further notes continued concerns over the projected cost of ContactPoint; further notes the conclusion of the House of Lords Select Committee on the Merits of Statutory Instruments that the Government has not conclusively demonstrated that a universal database is a proportionate response to the problem being addressed; and therefore calls on the Government to scrap the database.


1240SIZES OF MODELS31:3:09
Richard Younger-Ross
Mrs Ann Cryer
Paul Holmes
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
John Hemming
* 20
 Jo Swinson
   That this House notes that approximately 24,000 16 to 18 year old women and men suffer from anorexia; further notes that for many the desire to be thin is driven by societal pressures that determine thin as beautiful; further notes that such pressures are fuelled by the media and fashion magazines, and therefore welcomes those positive images for average-sized and larger women such as the selection of Crystal Renn, a size 16, as the face and body of Evans and the promotion of this in the April edition of Cosmopolitan magazine; and therefore calls on all in the fashion industry to select models who are of larger sizes for inclusion in magazines.


1248CONFLICT PREVENTION1:4:09
Simon Hughes
Mr Gary Streeter
John McDonnell
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
John Hemming
* 80
 Hugh Bayley
   That this House recognises that for every dollar spent globally on conflict prevention nearly two thousand times as much is spent on defence and the military; applauds the many local initiatives around the world that help to prevent conflict; calls on the Government to carry out a study into the cost-effectiveness of local and regional peace building initiatives in the run up to the Global Summit on Security and Peace Building in 2010; and encourages the Government through the Department for International Development and the Foreign and Commonwealth Office to give greater priority to conflict prevention work and in particular to fund from existing resources more local conflict prevention initiatives.


1250REPORTING ON CARBON LIABILITIES1:4:09
Colin Challen
Mr Tim Yeo
Simon Hughes
Peter Bottomley
John Hemming
Mr David Drew
* 172
 Mr Ian TaylorMs Diane AbbottCharlotte Atkins
 Mr Jim CunninghamMr Phil WillisTony Lloyd
 Mrs Joan HumbleMr Joe BentonAlun Michael
 Lady HermonJim SheridanJenny Willott
 Jo SwinsonGreg MulhollandLorely Burt
   That this House acknowledges the need to mitigate and adapt to climate change; looks forward to a successful global deal on climate change at Copenhagen later this year; notes that in a future carbon-constrained world businesses will need to account for the carbon intensity of their operations and products, particularly in the oil, gas and power sectors; believes that transparent reporting of the lifecycle carbon impacts of these operations and products as financial liabilities is the best way to enable investors and pension funds to factor in carbon risks to investment analysis and support emissions reductions and low-carbon growth; further notes the massive hidden carbon costs of the exploitation of unconventional fossil fuels such as oil sands, which emit on average three times more carbon dioxide in their extraction and production than conventional oil and represent a significant carbon risk for investors; also notes that new coal-fired power stations have lifespans of over 40 years; and therefore calls on the Government to require all UK-listed companies in the oil, gas and power sectors to report on their total carbon liabilities.


1251CERVICAL CANCER SCREENING1:4:09
Mr Fraser Kemp
Mr Lee Scott
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
Mr David Drew
Jeremy Corbyn
* 69
 Robert Key
   That this House welcomes the recent Written Ministerial Statement by the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State at the Department of Health announcing that the Independent Advisory Committee on Cervical Screening will now formally review all available evidence relating to the issue of screening women under 25 years old and take evidence from interested parties; and congratulates families, individuals and the cervical charity Jo's Trust on their campaigning work; and hopes the results of the review will result in a reduction in the number of women who develop invasive cervical cancer and the number of women who die from it.


1252SATELLITE NAVIGATION DEVICES1:4:09
Norman Baker
Mr John Leech
Mark Hunter
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
John Hemming
* 45
 Tom Levitt
   That this House is extremely concerned that satellite navigation devices (sat navs) continue to direct large vehicles down narrow and unsuitable routes; notes with regret that this has a serious impact upon other road users and many communities; and calls on the Government to eradicate this problem by ensuring that sat navs take account of the height, width and length of the vehicle before selecting a route.


1253FURTHER PARLIAMENTARY OMBUDSMAN REPORT ON EQUITABLE LIFE1:4:09
Daniel Kawczynski
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
John Hemming
Jeremy Corbyn
Sir Nicholas Winterton
* 55
 Jo Swinson
   That this House notes the findings of the report by the Parliamentary Ombudsman on Equitable Life; further notes the Ombudsman's letter to all hon. Members in which the Ombudsman indicated her intention to take the unusual step of using powers under the Parliamentary Commissioner Act 1967 to present Parliament with a further report; recognises the vital role the Ombudsman plays in public life; reaffirms the duty of Parliament to take adequate account of the Ombudsman's decisions; and further notes with concern that over 30,000 Equitable Life policyholders have died without seeing their situation resolved since the Society's near-collapse in 2000.


1260WOMEN IN AFGHANISTAN1:4:09
Ms Katy Clark
Jo Swinson
Ms Diane Abbott
Laura Moffatt
Michael Connarty
Mark Fisher
* 74
 Mrs Iris Robinson
   That this House deplores the actions of President Hamid Karzai for recently introducing a law severely curtailing the rights of Afghan women; expresses its gravest concerns that reportedly under this law women must seek the permission of their husband to work, go into education or seek medical treatment; condemns the fact that this law may legalise marital rape and believes that this would violate both the United Nations Convention on Human Rights and the Afghan constitution; notes that the United Nations and leading human rights activists have expressed serious criticisms about the law; and calls on the Government to condemn strongly this law and seek immediate talks with President Karzai on the subject and urge him seriously to reconsider the move.


1261PRESCRIPTION CHARGES (No. 2)1:4:09
Mr Russell Brown
Michael Connarty
Sandra Osborne
Mr David S. Borrow
Mr Bob Laxton
Mr Tom Harris
* 35
 Jo Swinson
   That this House notes that from 1 April 2009 cancer patients will be exempt from prescription charges in England, whereas in Scotland they will be required to pay £4 per prescription; congratulates the Government for this targeted and responsive measure and is disappointed that the devolved Scottish administration has failed to provide similar support to those requiring prescription drugs to deal with cancer in Scotland in a similarly timely manner.


1263OFGEM AND PREPAYMENT METER PRICES1:4:09
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
David Taylor
John Hemming
Kelvin Hopkins
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 44
 Tom Levitt
   That this House welcomes Ofgem's proposals to ban unjustified price differences; notes that Ofgem's measures will prevent the very worst differentials of up to £500 but feels these new proposals do not go far enough as online direct debit prices will be far lower than prepayment meter prices; and calls on Ofgem to ensure that prepayment meter customers do not pay a penny more than quarterly billed customers.


1271RAILWAY SERVICES AND JOBS1:4:09
John McDonnell
Mr David Drew
David Taylor
Jeremy Corbyn
Kelvin Hopkins
Lynne Jones
* 38
 Geraldine Smith
   That this House notes rail transport can provide a lower carbon emission alternative to the car and lorry; believes the railways during the recession can be a powerhouse for promoting green jobs, a green stimulus to the economy and managed in a way which alleviates the effects of the economic downturn; is therefore dismayed that despite being heavily reliant on billions of pounds of Government subsidy, thousands of passenger services, infrastructure and freight jobs are being threatened or have been lost on the railways and London Underground with the Government in effect subsidising redundancy; is appalled that these cuts will also affect the level and quality of service and are taking place despite private railway companies continuing to pay a dividend to shareholders and presiding over the most expensive fares in Europe; supports the call of the rail unions for an immediate industry-wide moratorium on cuts in jobs and services on the railways and London Underground and a freeze in dividends with all profits instead invested to protect services and jobs; and further believes that the Government should create an integrated, publicly-owned and accountable people's railway where passengers and workers have a real voice, which puts people before profit by ensuring all revenues are used to safeguard and expand rail services, jobs and skills, to expand electrification, develop high speed lines and introduce affordable and fair fares.


1272PUB TIES1:4:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr Nigel Evans
Mr David Crausby
Jim Dobbin
Jon Cruddas
Mr Alan Meale
* 45
 Tom Levitt
   That this House notes with concern the number of pubs and clubs that are struggling to survive, particularly during the current economic downturn; recognises that the most significant difficulty facing pubs is being tied into contracts with the brewers in relation to the purchase of alcohol which restricts the ability to make profits; and calls on the Government to outlaw the pub tie and allow landlords greater flexibility in the purchasing of alcohol in addition to reviewing the duty placed on alcohol in order to ensure that this reflects alcohol volume rather than flat rate increases in duty.


1278ON-PACK RECYCLING LABEL2:4:09
Miss Anne McIntosh
Mr Richard Benyon
Angela Watkinson
Peter Bottomley
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr James Gray
* 40
 Jo Swinson
   That this House welcomes the launch of the British Retail Consortium's (BRC's) On-Pack Recycling Label, which is supported by the Waste and Resources Action Programme; notes that the label will help to support consumers to recycle more packaging; further notes that the label will help local authorities and others to increase recycling rates for those materials that could be recycled but that currently have low collection and recycling rates; supports the BRC's aim to encourage at least 60 retailers and suppliers to join the scheme by the end of 2009; and calls on as many companies as possible to support the scheme.


1280HEALTH SUPPORT IN SCHOOL2:4:09
Mr Jim Cunningham
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
Mr Mike Hancock
Bob Spink
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
* 115
 Jo Swinson
   That this House notes with considerable concern that the health of around a million children with specified health conditions, including asthma, cancer, coeliac disease, cystic fibrosis, diabetes, epilepsy, heart conditions, HIV, mental health problems, multiple sclerosis, sickle cell disease and conditions that can cause stroke, is put at risk because they are not receiving sufficient support at school; further notes that poor support at school stops children from fulfilling their potential; recognises that while guidance on medicines in schools remains voluntary, inequality of experience will continue; and acknowledges that by providing better support, children with medical needs will have improved health outcomes and reduce the financial burden on the NHS.


1282NUCLEAR WEAPONS CONVENTION2:4:09
Jeremy Corbyn
Frank Cook
Paul Holmes
Peter Bottomley
Paul Flynn
Michael Connarty
* 78
 Laura Moffatt
   That this House notes the forthcoming 41st anniversary of the Nuclear Non-proliferation Treaty; further notes the continued failure of the international community to abolish nuclear weapons or prevent their further proliferation; endorses the unanimous opinion of the International Court of Justice that there exists an obligation to pursue in good faith, and bring to a conclusion, negotiations leading to nuclear disarmament in all its aspects under strict and effective international control; further notes the recent 10th anniversary of the submission of a model nuclear weapons convention by Costa Rica to the United Nations for discussion; and calls upon the Government to work to achieve progress on multilateral negotions with the aim of achieving implementation of a nuclear weapons convention by 2020.


1286SAVINGS SUMMARY BOX2:4:09
Dr Vincent Cable
Mr Mike Hancock
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
Mr Adrian Sanders
Bob Russell
* 74
 Mr Edward DaveyAngus RobertsonJo Swinson
   That this House recognises that recent cuts in interest rates have led to a significant loss of income for many savers; condemns the fact that most savings statements do not clearly indicate the correct current interest rate of the account and that Bank of England interest rates have changed dramatically over the last six months, leaving many savers confused about the level of interest which they are receiving; notes that there is no technical barrier to publishing a bespoke rate; calls on the Financial Services Authority to give savers the same protection as credit card holders by mandating savings account providers to include a savings summary box in every online and paper statement; further calls on the Financial Services Authority to require that this summary box include the current bespoke interest rate, bonus rates including expiry date, penalties for withdrawal and lay out what institution the account is linked to for the purposes of the Financial Services Compensation Scheme; and anticipates that this simple step will greatly improve the transparency of many savings accounts, enabling hard-pressed savers to ensure they are maximising their savings.


1287SCIENTIFIC PROCEDURES USING ANIMALS AND THE 3RS APPROACH20:4:09
Mr George Howarth
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
Mr Martin Caton
Mrs Ann Cryer
Lynne Jones
* 33
 Andrew Rosindell
   That this House notes that it is 50 years since the introduction of the 3Rs approach of replacement, refinement and reduction with regard to scientific procedures using animals; recognises the continuing importance of the use of animals in developing cures and treatments for several serious and life threatening diseases; further notes the excellent work of the National Centre for Replacement, Refinement and Reduction in this field; celebrates the fact that the welfare of animals monitoring and control in the UK is more ethically focused and effective than in many other parts of the world; and urges the Government to continue to promote the 3Rs.


1296MARGARET HAYWOOD AND STANDARDS OF CARE20:4:09
Mr Paul Burstow
Mr Adrian Sanders
Peter Bottomley
Mrs Ann Cryer
Mr John Leech
Andrew George
* 55
 Hywel WilliamsJo Swinson
   That this House supports nurse Margaret Haywood who raised issues of concern around poor patient care; believes that Margaret was justified in exposing the worrying conditions at her local hospital and that the Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) was wrong to strike her off the nursing register; notes the e-petition in support of Margaret Haywood organised by the Royal College of Nursing; calls on the NMC to reverse its decision; and further calls on the Government to take steps to ensure that the procedures and protection afforded to whistleblowers are understood and applied by all in positions of responsibility in the NHS.

As an Amendment to Mr Paul Burstow's proposed Motion (Margaret Haywood and Standards of Care):

Mr William Cash
* 1
Line 8, at end add `including the Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust and the University Hospital of North Staffordshire NHS Trust.'.
23:4:09(a1)


1298DOMESTIC VIOLENCE IN THE UK20:4:09
Ms Diane Abbott
Bob Russell
Lynne Jones
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Bob Spink
Jim Dobbin
* 77
 Tom Levitt
   That this House is concerned at the consistently high levels of domestic violence taking place in the UK; is alarmed that recent statistics suggest two women a week are killed by their male partner or former partner; recognises the severe effects of domestic violence on children who witness or experience incidents of violence; further recognises the links between domestic violence and homelessness, miscarriage and mental health problems; notes the estimated overall costs of domestic violence to the Government for England and Wales is £25 billion per year; and calls on the Government to increase funding for organisations working to support victims of domestic violence, including specific provisions for children staying in refuges with their mothers, to increase awareness-raising work in schools and medical centres and to address the variation in quality of service provision across the country.


1299RIGHTS OF TRIBAL AND INDIGENOUS PEOPLES20:4:09
Martin Horwood
Mr David Drew
Harry Cohen
Andrew George
Bob Russell
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
* 94
 Jo SwinsonLynne Featherstone
   That this House welcomes the 20th anniversary of International Labour Organisation Convention 169 on Tribal and Indigenous Peoples, which recognises and respects the land rights of indigenous peoples; notes that protecting the land rights of indigenous peoples is the most effective way to protect the world's rainforests, crucial in the battle against climate change; further welcomes a memorandum submitted to the Environment Audit Committee by the Department for International Development and the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs which recognises the importance of ensuring indigenous peoples' rights are respected in terms of ownership of the carbon asset; notes the Government's continued refusal to put these rights on a firm legal footing and ratify Convention 169, on the grounds that there are no indigenous peoples in the United Kingdom; further notes that this has not prevented either the Netherlands or Spain from joining the list of 20 countries, including Brazil, that have ratified the Convention; believes that protecting the rights of indigenous peoples is a matter of international concern; and calls on the Government to ratify Convention 169 without delay.


1301OVERSEAS AID BUDGETS20:4:09
Pete Wishart
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Mr Martin Caton
Mrs Ann Cryer
Lynne Jones
* 28
 Jo Swinson
   That this House recalls the commitments made by the UK Government at the G8 in 2005 to increase aid spending and reduce poverty; is very concerned by reports that the Chancellor of the Exchequer is considering cuts to the overseas aid budget; and believes that economic downturns should not be used as an excuse to renege on aid commitments.


1306RADIO SPECTRUM FOR PORTS AND AIRPORTS21:4:09
Mr Austin Mitchell
Peter Bottomley
Mrs Ann Cryer
John McDonnell
Kelvin Hopkins
Mr Mike Hancock
* 39
 Julia Goldsworthy
   That this House, concerned that the radio spectrum used by United Kingdom ports and airports is essential for the safety of aircraft and shipping and mandated under international agreement, rejects the proposal from Ofcom that administered incentive pricing should be applied to the spectrum used by ports and airports, on the grounds that this would be a tax on safety which would have to be passed on to customers in higher charges and would therefore damage the competitiveness of British ports and airports; and proposes that the Secretary of State for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform veto any proposal to apply charges to the spectrum used by ports and airports.


1307HON. MEMBER FOR ASHFORD21:4:09
Sir Menzies Campbell
Mr Frank Field
Mr Michael Howard
Mr William Cash
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
* 40
 Jo Swinson
   That this House notes the statement of the Director of Public Prosecutions on 16 April 2009 announcing his decision that no charges would be brought against the hon. Member for Ashford in relation to the documents leaked and stating that, `Mr Green's purpose in using the documents was apparently to hold the Government to account'; and calls for the House to be given the opportunity to debate a motion to refer the matter to the Committee on Standards and Privileges.


1308SECRET EVIDENCE21:4:09
Ms Diane Abbott
Mr David Drew
David Lepper
Sarah Teather
Lynne Featherstone
Peter Bottomley
* 87
 Mr Paul KeetchClare ShortMr Lindsay Hoyle
 Mark LazarowiczNorman LambPete Wishart
 Jo SwinsonJulia GoldsworthyMr Angus MacNeil
   That this House believes the use of secret evidence in UK courts is fundamentally wrong; notes that secret evidence is evidence held by the Home Office against an individual that neither the individual, nor their legal representation, may see; further notes that in recent cases secret evidence has been used to detain individuals in prison for up to three years without charge or trial; further notes that these individuals may also be put under a control order or severe bail conditions, greatly limiting their movements and ability to lead a healthy life; further believes that the use of secret evidence by the state against individuals runs entirely contrary to Habeas Corpus; recognises the European Court of Human Rights' ruling that detaining individuals on the basis of secret evidence is unlawful because detainees had not been able to effectively challenge the allegations against them; and calls on the Government to begin an immediate independent review into the use of evidence that is not ever heard by the defendant or their lawyer but which is used to justify indefinite detention, severe bail conditions or control orders.


1309ENERGY PRICES (No. 2)21:4:09
John Barrett
Andrew George
Bob Russell
Peter Bottomley
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 49
 Mr David ClellandDavid CairnsJo Swinson
   That this House notes that natural gas wholesale prices have declined by 54 per cent. in the last year while the average British household has seen their gas bill decline by only around three per cent.; is aware that approximately 54 per cent. of the cost of supplying gas to consumers is made up by natural gas wholesale prices; recognises that if household gas bills had reduced at the same rate as wholesale prices, the average UK household would save over £200 per year; and calls on the Government to ensure that the prices charged by energy companies better reflect reductions in wholesale energy prices.


1312OVERNIGHT ALLOWANCES FOR HON. MEMBERS21:4:09
Mr Gregory Campbell
Mr Peter Robinson
Mr Nigel Dodds
Mr Jeffrey M. Donaldson
Mrs Iris Robinson
Sammy Wilson
* 11
 Laura Moffatt
   That this House notes the statement from the Leader of the House regarding hon. Members' allowances and expenses; welcomes the move towards openness; notes with alarm that, in connection with the flat rate allowance proposal for overnight accommodation while engaged in parliamentary duties, some distinction may be drawn between hon. Members representing constituencies in Northern Ireland and other hon. Members; and would be appalled by and would totally oppose any outcome of this section of the proposals which would lead to payments being made to those who do not attend and carry out their duties in the House.


1314SPEED LIMIT AND ROAD SAFETY22:4:09
Keith Vaz
Mark Durkan
Andrew George
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Bob Russell
Mr Mike Hancock
* 44
 Laura MoffattDavid Cairns
   That this House welcomes proposals that would result in speed limits being reduced in areas where there is a high risk of accidents, in particular the recommendation that there be a 20 mph speed limit around schools and in residential areas; notes that between 2005 and 2007, 2,376 people were killed and 14,577 were seriously injured in road accidents where excessive speed was recorded as a contributory factor and that on average eight people die on the road every day; recognises the need for roads to be made safer; and calls for these recommendations to be implemented as soon as possible throughout the country.


1317WORLD HEPATITIS DAY 200922:4:09
Mr Bob Laxton
Mr David Amess
Dr Brian Iddon
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Jim Dobbin
Mr David Crausby
* 98
 Laura MoffattJo Swinson
   That this House notes that 19 May 2009 is World Hepatitis Day; is concerned that more than 500 million people worldwide have either chronic hepatitis B or C which is equivalent to one in 12 of the global population; is deeply concerned that these two diseases kill one million people annually; believes that worldwide action is needed in order to save millions of lives; hopes that World Hepatitis Day will increase public awareness of hepatitis B and C in the UK and internationally; and urges the Government to give its full backing to World Hepatitis Day and to support the resolution calling for a world day for the struggle against viral hepatitis at the 62nd meeting of the World Health Assembly in May 2009.


1318PULMONARY ARTERIAL HYPERTENSION TREATMENT CAMPAIGN22:4:09
Chris Ruane
Andrew George
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Alan Meale
Mr Greg Pope
* 66
 Mrs Iris Robinson
   That this House welcomes the announcement by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) that it has, following an outcry from patient groups and clinicians and with the agreement of Ministers, removed from its work programme the proposed appraisal of drugs for the treatment of pulmonary arterial hypertension (PH); notes that 75 per cent. of PH patients are now alive two years after diagnosis and that if the earlier, preliminary, recommendations from NICE had been carried out, it would have been a sentence of death for a significant number of the PH patient community; further notes that these lifesaving treatments are subject to national specialist commissioning arrangements and are only available in eight specialist and world-renowned PH centres in the UK; is pleased that NICE and Ministers recognise that NICE could not add value to this existing guidance and so removed it from the work programme; congratulates the Pulmonary Hypertension Association UK on its campaign to ensure patients have access to these lifesaving drugs; and congratulates Ministers and NICE for taking a common sense approach to this issue.


1326OFFICE OF FAIR TRADING SCAMS AWARENESS MONTH22:4:09
Mark Williams
Mr Roger Williams
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Alan Meale
Mr Mike Weir
Paul Holmes
* 52
 Jo Swinson
   That this House welcomes the events organised as part of the Office of Fair Trading's Scams Awareness Month; notes with concern that an estimated three million United Kingdom consumers fall victim to scams sent by email, internet, post, text and the telephone, collectively losing £3.5 billion; recognises the success of the Scamnesty campaign, run in partnership with nearly 90 Local Authority Trading Standards Services, which calls on consumers to drop scam mailings they have received into designated Scamnesty bins or boxes at local libraries and public areas across the country, and which last year collected more than 15,000 mailings; and believes that widespread advice on how to spot scams will help people avoid being deceived in future.


1328CHILD POVERTY IN MUMBAI22:4:09
Keith Vaz
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Alan Meale
Hugh Bayley
Paul Holmes
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 50
 Jo Swinson
   That this House notes the serious problem of child poverty in Mumbai; congratulates Celador Films and Film4, the makers of Slumdog Millionaire, for their commitment to provide a £500,000 funding package to tackle child poverty in Mumbai; notes with grave concern recent media coverage regarding the child actors in the film, in particular Rubina Ali; welcomes the efforts of the Indian authorities to investigate these allegations; encourages other filmmakers to provide sufficient support for the communities in which they produce films; and calls on the Government to work with the Indian government and the organisations involved in the delivery of the funding package to ensure that the film leaves a positive legacy in Mumbai.


1330FUTURE OF ROYAL MAIL (No. 2)22:4:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Jon Cruddas
Mr David Crausby
Jim Dobbin
Colin Burgon
Mr Alan Meale
* 62
 Adam Price
   That this House expresses concern following figures published by Compass which show that the sale of Royal Mail at this time would raise £900 million less than just a year ago; recognises that this significantly weakens the case set out by the Government for the part-privatisation of Royal Mail and also raises concerns about achieving value for money; believes that the involvement of the private sector is not required given that all sectors of the Royal Mail Group are now profitable; and calls on the Government to abandon its plans for part-privatisation of the Royal Mail as a matter of urgency, particularly given the current economic downturn, and to pursue alternative funding options which keep the Royal Mail wholly public and competing on a level playing field.


1332MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS22:4:09
Mr James Gray
Mr Lee Scott
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Alan Meale
Mr Mike Weir
Mr Nigel Waterson
* 72
 Jo Swinson
   That this House congratulates the MS Society, MS Trust, MS Resource Centre and MS Therapy Centre for their outstanding work in supporting people living with multiple sclerosis (MS) across the UK; but notes with concern the results of a recent YouGov survey that revealed common myths and misconceptions among the general public about how MS affects people's lives; regrets that only one in four people know that MS is most commonly diagnosed in people aged 25 to 34 years old and that 40 per cent. of the public were unable to name a single symptom associated with MS; but commends MS Awareness Week, taking place from 27 April to 3 May 2009, for helping to address these misconceptions about the often variable and fluctuating nature of multiple sclerosis.


1333100th ANNIVERSARY OF SUFFRAGETTES' PROTEST23:4:09
Jo Swinson
Lynne Featherstone
Ms Katy Clark
Ms Diane Abbott
Mrs Eleanor Laing
Mrs Theresa May
* 76
 Mrs Iris Robinson
   That this House commemorates the 100th anniversary on 27 April 2009 of the day that Margery Humes, Theresa Garnet, Sylvia Russell and Bertha Quinn, suffragettes from the Women's Social and Political Union, chained themselves to statues in St. Stephen's Hall to protest for the right of women to vote; pays tribute to those and all other heroic women who fought for the rights of women during a time when society, and Parliament, thought them undeserving of equal rights; admires their courage and dedication; encourages women to make full use of the hard-earned right to vote and to stand for election; calls on all parties to encourage women's political participation; and looks forward to a day when gender balance in Parliament becomes a reality.

As an Amendment to Jo Swinson's proposed Motion (100th Anniversary of Suffragettes' Protest):

Ann Winterton
* 1
Line 9, at end add `without positive discrimination but by the will and support of the electorate at the ballot box.'.
27:4:09(a1)


1342WARM FRONT SCHEME (No. 2)24:4:09
Mr David Crausby
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Dr Brian Iddon
Jim Dobbin
Mrs Ann Cryer
Kelvin Hopkins
* 54
 Mr David Clelland
   That this House welcomes the announcement in the recent Budget Statement to increase the level of grant available to householders through the Warm Front Scheme; recognises the maximum grants currently available are £2,700 and £4,000 and will be increased to £3,500 and £6,000 respectively; and calls on the Government to ensure that this increase will be administered exclusively to benefit people in households vulnerable to fuel poverty rather than the Warm Front service provider and the sub-contractors.


1350FREE REGIONAL RAIL TRAVEL FOR PENSIONERS27:4:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Mr Nigel Evans
Jim Dobbin
Mr Lee Scott
Bob Spink
* 54
 Mr David Clelland
   That this House welcomes the success of free bus travel for pensioners and disabled people; recognises the huge boost this has created in the use of bus services and the benefit this has brought to many pensioners, particularly those on lower incomes; realises that there are limits to the distance an individual can travel by bus; and therefore calls on the Government to work with rail operators to introduce a scheme of free regional rail travel helping pensioners travel even further afield free of charge.

As an Amendment to Mr Lindsay Hoyle's proposed Motion (Free Regional Rail Travel for Pensioners):

Paul Holmes
* 1
Line 6, at end add `but notes that first the Government should keep its promise of April 2008 and fully fund the cost of the national concessionary bus fares scheme instead of underfunding at least 10 councils by over £1 million per year, including Chesterfield Borough Council by £1.6 million per year, equal to 11 per cent. of that council's entire annual revenue, having wiped out the council's financial reserves and caused 45 job losses to pay for the bus scheme.'.
28:4:09(a1)


1351UNITE FOR JOBS CAMPAIGN AND NATIONAL MARCH27:4:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Jim Sheridan
Jim Dobbin
Jeremy Corbyn
Kelvin Hopkins
* 178
 Mr Anthony WrightAngus RobertsonMr Alistair Carmichael
 Dr John PughRichard Younger-RossStewart Hosie
   That this House supports the Unite for Jobs national march organised by Unite; fully supports the union's Unite for Jobs campaign which calls for urgent action to defend jobs across the economy; particularly supports the need for a national strategy for creating and protecting jobs and having a clear road map out of this recession, for speedier access to credit from state-supported banks to ensure immediate cash for businesses and jobs, for the implementation of a temporary short-time working subsidy, for investment in schools, hospitals and homes to create green jobs and to support those most in need during the recession, and for greater protection for UK workers by increasing statutory redundancy pay, giving agency workers full redundancy rights and putting the UK on a level playing field with the rest of Europe; believes that hard working people across the country would significantly benefit from the introduction of these measures; and calls on the Government to work with Unite to ensure their implementation.


1352BURTON ALBION FC BLUE SQUARE PREMIER CHAMPIONS27:4:09
Mrs Janet Dean
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Bob Russell
John McDonnell
Colin Burgon
David Taylor
* 50
 Mr Russell Brown
   That this House congratulates Burton Albion Football Club on winning the Blue Square Premier title and its promotion to the Football League; notes that this is the first time that Burton Albion will be playing in the Football League; commends the players and the leadership of Chairman Ben Robinson, Manager Roy McFarland and former Manager Nigel Clough; thanks the fans for their magnificent support over the course of this historic season; and looks forward to the Brewers building on this success in the future.


1354AFGHAN WOMEN PARLIAMENTARIANS27:4:09
Ms Sally Keeble
Nick Ainger
Mr Jim Cunningham
Jim Sheridan
Bob Russell
John McDonnell
* 73
 Sandra GidleyDavid Cairns
   That this House supports the brave stance taken by women members of the Afghan parliament to attack the now shelved family law proposals drafted by the Karzai government, which potentially could have decriminalised rape; furthermore expresses concern that the Afghan government has drawn up legislation which amounts to severe restrictions to women's rights; and calls on the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs to continue to express concern at the highest level over this issue and ensure that the Karzai government acts in a way that is consistent with the UN Charter on Human Rights and the Afghan constitution.


1355CARERS WEEK27:4:09
Mrs Anne McGuire
Tony Baldry
Mr Terry Rooney
Hywel Williams
Richard Younger-Ross
Dr Hywel Francis
* 206
 Norman Lamb
   That this House expresses its gratitude to and respect for the six million people in the UK who provide unpaid help, care and support to a relative or friend who has an illness or disability; notes that the huge contribution that carers make is often unrecognised by society, communities and sometimes within carers' own families and that as a consequence of this lack of recognition carers go without the support they need; acknowledges that most will provide care at some point in their lives and need to have access to information and services and to be listened to; is concerned that professionals may not always understand the role of a carer, nor offer them appropriate support, which risks damaging carers' own health; further notes that Carers Week, a partnership of 10 national charities, takes place this year from 8 to 14 June, with the theme Carers: the UK's Secret Service; and believes that carers need to have a higher profile across all services and be prioritised alongside other groups at risk of social exclusion at a local and national level.


1356HOUSE OF COMMONS CLEANERS27:4:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Jim Dobbin
Bob Russell
John McDonnell
Bob Spink
* 82
 Mrs Iris Robinson
   That this House recognises the invaluable contribution made by the House of Commons cleaners; notes that hon. Members depend on the vital services provided by these workers to ensure the smooth running of the House; expresses concern and disappointment that the House of Commons cleaners are receiving an hourly wage below the London Living Wage and that they have been waiting months for an agreed 45 pence rise in their hourly rate; and calls on KGB Cleaning and Support Services, the cleaners' employers, and the House authorities urgently to resolve this unacceptable situation and give these workers the pay they deserve.


1359WORKERS' MEMORIAL DAY (NO. 2)27:4:09
Mr Michael Clapham
Jim Sheridan
Mr Stephen Hepburn
Jim Dobbin
Mr David Crausby
Sir Menzies Campbell
* 84
 Mr Russell Brown
   That this House notes that Tuesday 28 April is International Workers' Memorial Day; joins in remembering those who died as a result of work; calls on the Government to take measures to reduce the death toll caused by work by increasing resources for the prevention of ill-health and injury in the workplace; and welcomes the Government's consultation on official recognition for Workers' Memorial Day.


1360ENGLISH HERITAGE AND THE PROPOSED PAY SYSTEM27:4:09
John McDonnell
Bob Russell
Mark Fisher
Mr David Drew
Jim Cousins
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
* 55
 Sandra GidleyMs Sally KeebleMrs Joan Humble
 Sarah TeatherDr John PughLynne Featherstone
   That this House values the expertise and hard work of English Heritage staff based on sites across the country who preserve heritage sites for future generations; is concerned that over 800 staff who work in visitor operations are facing proposals for a new pay system that will have a drastic impact by introducing a complex pay system which rewards staff on higher salaries and penalises those on lower salaries and in visitor operations by introducing market rates, performance-related bonuses and regionalised levels of remuneration, setting levels for lower bands that are considerably below the current statutory salary; notes that visitor operations are the main source of revenue through on-site shops, membership sales, guide books, events and entry charges, and that visitor operations staff take tours, assist with site conservation and maintenance and educate school children; is concerned that many staff claim benefits to support working for English Heritage and under these proposals may find it financially impossible to do the job they are so proud of; and therefore urgently calls on the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport to demand that English Heritage management scrap these proposals and ask HM Treasury for the maximum paybill increase of 3.7 per cent. to address the low pay issues in English Heritage.


1365BREAKTHROUGH BREAST CANCER'S LYMPHOEDEMA SERVICES CAMPAIGN28:4:09
Annette Brooke [R]
Mrs Ann Cryer
Dr Doug Naysmith
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Anne Main
Dr Evan Harris
* 130
 Laura MoffattRichard OttawayMr Michael Ancram
 Sir Alan BeithMr Roger WilliamsMr Andrew Pelling
 Lynne Featherstone
   That this House believes that people with breast cancer who develop symptoms of lymphoedema should be able to access services which enable them to manage their condition more effectively; notes that current service provision may not in all areas provide the specialist services and treatment needed by people with lymphoedema; further notes that local services are vital to ensuring that the pain and discomfort of lymphoedema can be reduced; further notes that healthcare policies and initiatives have been introduced which if delivered would provide much needed lymphoedema services to those areas where they currently may not exist; further notes that more effective data gathering on the incidence of lymphoedema should be implemented at local and national level to ensure that high quality services can be developed and delivered where needed; and supports Breakthrough Breast Cancer's campaign Constant Reminder? - Living with Lymphoedema, which seeks to improve services for people who develop lymphoedema after breast cancer.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1366GANGMASTERS LICENSING AUTHORITY28:4:09
John McDonnell
Geraldine Smith
Jim Sheridan
Paul Holmes
Stephen Pound
Mark Durkan
* 82
 Sarah TeatherPaul Rowen
   That this House notes that the Gangmasters Licensing Authority was created in the aftermath of the Morecambe Bay tragedy to protect workers from exploitation in agriculture, horticulture, shellfish gathering and food processing and packaging; congratulates Gangmasters Licensing Authority staff for the good work they do to safeguard the welfare and interests of workers while ensuring that labour providers operate within the law; further notes that the limitations of the Authority's remit leaves workers in other industries vulnerable as gangmasters are diversifying into construction, textiles, catering and cleaning trades, outside the remit of the Gangmasters Licensing Authority; and therefore calls for a widening of the Gangmasters Licensing Authority remit to incorporate all vulnerable workers whether migrant or casual workers, and improved resourcing to enable the Gangmasters Licensing Authority to carry out its functions to achieve the best results possible.


1369DEPRESSION AND ITS TREATMENT28:4:09
Dr Brian Iddon
Dr John Pugh
Mrs Joan Humble
Mr Nigel Evans
Kelvin Hopkins
Mr Andrew Pelling
* 73
 Laura MoffattMr David Clelland
   That this House welcomes the launch of the Depression Alliance's report Daring to Choose: ten ways to deliver choice for people with depression and anxiety; supports the work of the Depression Alliance and Depression Awareness Week, 20 to 26 April 2009; notes with concern that one in six people in the UK will suffer from depression in their lives; believes that choice is vital to empower people and combat stigma and discrimination; welcomes the Improving Access to Psychological Therapies programme but recognises that it needs to be integrated with a wide range of other services for it to be effective; and calls on the Government to make depression and anxiety an urgent public health priority, make available a full range of treatment options, psychological, pharmacological, social and others, and implement the recommendations set out in the Depression Alliance's report.


1370ZERO-GRAZED LIVESTOCK28:4:09
David Taylor
Mr David Drew
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Eric Martlew
Bob Russell
Stephen Pound
* 89
 Mr Edward DaveyMr Jim HoodMartin Horwood
 Greg Mulholland
   That this House notes the growing trend towards the zero-grazing of dairy cows, lambs and milk-producing goats; further notes that this process confines animals to sheds for all or most of the year; is concerned that such systems are unduly restrictive and oppressive and that the limited investigations that have so far been carried out point to a higher incidence of health problems such as lameness, mastitis, laminitis, acidosis and infertility; and calls on the Government to commission and make publicly available independent research that assesses the scale of zero-grazing of dairy cattle, goats and sheep in the UK, as well as the physical and behavioural problems associated with this method of livestock farming.


1371CARERS' ALLOWANCE28:4:09
Mr David Clelland
Mr David Anderson
John Cummings
Mark Durkan
Bob Spink
Kelvin Hopkins
* 75
 Sandra GidleyTom Levitt
   That this House believes that to mark the end of Carers Week positive action should be taken to improve support to carers by ending the anomaly of the cliff edge effect of earnings rising slightly above the carers' earnings limit, resulting in the loss of the whole allowance; and calls on the Government to make carers' allowance a fixed allowance, up-rated at the same time as other state benefits and paid to all carers, regardless of income and including retired carers, in the same way as child benefit is paid to all parents regardless of income.


1373DEATH PENALTY IN TIBET28:4:09
Kate Hoey
Norman Baker
Mr Frank Field
John Mason
Mr Chris Mullin
Mr George Howarth
* 120
 Sandra GidleyRichard Younger-Ross
   That this House opposes the use of the death penalty; condemns the recent imposition of the death penalty by the Lhasa Intermediate People's Court on Tibetans, Lobsang Gyaltsen and Loyak, having found them guilty of arson attacks in Lhasa in March 2008 which led to confirmed deaths; further condemns the recent imposition of the death penalty, each with a two year reprieve, by the same court on Tibetans Tenzin Phuntsok, Kangtsuk and on a 21-year-old Tibetan woman, Penkyi, also for arson attacks in Lhasa in March 2008, which led to confirmed deaths; is concerned that evidence against these individuals is unsound, with one of the convicted found guilty on the basis of a confession only months after the UN Committee Against Torture concluded that China regularly uses torture as a means of extracting confessions in criminal proceedings; is further concerned that the trials of those named above were not conducted in accordance with judicial standards and that the death sentences passed are therefore unsafe; calls on the relevant Chinese authorities to rescind the aforementioned death sentences and to provvide unfettered access to Tibet and all Tibetan-populated regions, including court proceedings, for journalists, consular staff based in Beijing and independent observers; and further calls on the British Government publicly to raise its concerns regarding the cases with the Chinese government.


1374ANZAC DAY28:4:09
Andrew Rosindell
Bob Spink
Mr Lee Scott
Peter Bottomley
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Sir Nicholas Winterton
* 46
 Mrs Iris Robinson
   That this House remembers the heroic campaign that followed the landings of allied forces at Anzac Cove, Gallipoli, on 25 April 1915; joins with all Australians and New Zealanders in commemorating the bravery of the Australian and New Zealand Army Corps who, together with their British colleagues and others, sacrificed so much in defence of freedom; expresses its pride at the close association that exists between the people of the three nations, bound together by language, history, culture and in sharing Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II as Head of State; and commends all those involved in the organisation of this year's Anzac Day commemorations in London.


1375ADVERTISING AND THE FUTURE OF LOCAL AND REGIONAL MEDIA28:4:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Mr Nigel Evans
Jim Dobbin
Mr Alan Meale
Bob Spink
* 36
 Adam Price
   That this House recognises the important role played by local and regional media; expresses concern about the huge difficulty facing local newspapers as advertising revenues plummet during the current downturn, resulting in staff, sub editors and editors facing redundancy, such as Vanessa Taylor at the Chorley Guardian, who is taking voluntary redundancy after over 20 years of providing quality journalism at the local newspaper; and looks to the Government and local authorities to support local newspapers through placing adverts in the paper as opposed to producing their own publications, which attracts advertising away from local newspapers and only further challenges the future of local newspapers.


1376DEAF AWARENESS WEEK 200928:4:09
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mark Durkan
Mark Hunter
* 65
 Tom Levitt
   That this House notes that there are nine million deaf and hard-of-hearing people in the UK; and welcomes the opportunity to promote deaf awareness across all parts of society through Deaf Awareness Week, running from 4 to 10 May, involving over 100 deaf charities and organisations.


1378IMPACT OF THE ECONOMIC RECESSION ON VOLUNTARY SECTOR28:4:09
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mark Durkan
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Jim Dobbin
* 39
 David Cairns
   That this House notes with concern the wide-ranging and adverse effects of the global economic recession; recognises the growing problem of unemployment facing British workers; commends those unemployed workers who have turned to the voluntary sector as a way to gain new skills, get a head-start in an highly competitive job market and make valuable use of their time out of work; and calls on the Government to further promote the merits of voluntary work and the benefits it offers people seeking a route back into employment.


1379UNEMPLOYMENT AND OLDER WORKERS28:4:09
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Mark Durkan
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Mr David Drew
David Simpson
* 36
 David Cairns
   That this House expresses concern at the recent sharp increases in unemployment; welcomes the Government's announcement of £1.7 billion of funding for Jobcentre Plus; notes that those over 50 years old have lost their jobs at the highest percentage rate over the past year and that the chance of older men finding future employment falls by a quarter each year they are out of the labour market; recognises that the skills, experience and contribution of older workers should not be lost to the economy; and calls on the Government to introduce a new package of support for unemployed people over the age of 50 years to be made available within three months of them losing their jobs and to train Jobcentre Plus staff to improve the support provided to older clients, including targeted work with older clients who need to change their careers, who face age discrimination and who sometimes need confidence-building for interviews.


1381ACOUSTICS IN SCHOOLS28:4:09
Bob Spink
Mr David Drew
Mrs Ann Cryer
Dan Rogerson
Glenda Jackson
Jeremy Corbyn
* 71
 Charlotte AtkinsMrs Joan HumbleAlbert Owen
   That this House is deeply concerned that new schools are being built which do not comply with government standards on acoustics; notes that children suffering from deafness are much less likely to get five good GCSEs than hearing children; agrees with the National Deaf Children's Society that deafness is not a learning disability and that poor quality acoustics is one of several barriers preventing deaf children being able to achieve their full potential; and calls on the Government to require new schools to be tested for acoustics pre-completion, to monitor and review the quality of acoustics in schools annually, and to ensure that all schools adhere to acoustic standards.


1385SPECIALIST HELP FOR VETERANS29:4:09
Angus Robertson
Mr Mike Weir
Stewart Hosie
Bob Spink
John Mason
Mr Mike Hancock
* 17
 Mrs Iris Robinson
   That this House notes that Scotland is leading the way in helping ex-servicemen and servicewomen rebuild their lives as civilians; welcomes the establishment of a dedicated veterans' hub which will help those leaving the armed forces to access specialist help and support to get into work, find a home and increase their wellbeing; understands that this is the first time in the UK that specialist help and advice has been brought under one roof for veterans and their families; and believes that this is an excellent example of the Scottish government, Ministry of Defence, NHS and veteran charities all working together to deliver services that will improve the lives of veterans in Scotland.


1389EXCHEQUER CONTRIBUTION TO THE PARLIAMENTARY CONTRIBUTORY PENSION FUND29:4:09
Steve Webb
Mr Frank Field
Dr Vincent Cable
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
Andrew George
* 24
 David Howarth
   That this House welcomes the fundamental review of the Parliamentary Contributory Pension Fund (PCPF) being undertaken by the Senior Salaries Review Board; but believes that until that review is complete the Exchequer contribution to the PCPF should not be increased beyond its 2008-09 level.


1392PROTECTION OF RIVER HABITATS29:4:09
Mr Oliver Heald
Mr Peter Lilley
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Jeremy Corbyn
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Gregory Campbell
* 60
 Mr Dominic GrieveMr Bernard JenkinMr Simon Burns
 Mr Humfrey MalinsMrs Jacqui LaitNadine Dorries
 John HemmingDavid HowarthDavid Mundell
 Mr Ben Wallace
   That this House believes that the chalk rivers of England provide a unique habitat for a rich diversity of fish, riparian creatures and rare plant species which is under serious threat; expresses concern at the recent Environment Agency finding that less than 20 per cent. of the rivers and lakes of England and Wales are currently at good status due to growing pollution, over-abstraction of water and habitat destruction; and calls on the Government to develop a plan to protect and enhance the condition of rivers, including the chalk rivers, setting firm and demanding targets.


1394CHARITIES AND ICELANDIC BANKS29:4:09
Mr Graham Brady
Mr Michael Fallon
Jim Cousins
John Thurso
Nick Ainger
Mr Colin Breed
* 83
 Mr Andrew Pelling
   That this House urges the Government to accept the recommendations of the Treasury Select Committee report into the Banking crisis and the impact of the failure of the Icelandic banks (Fifth Report from the Treasury Committee, Session 2008-09, HC 402); notes the recommendation that on this occasion, all charities be compensated for their losses; and further urges the Government to take immediate action to compensate charities so that they can continue with their important work.


1399RACIST BULLYING IN SCHOOLS30:4:09
Keith Vaz
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Alan Meale
* 45
 Sandra Gidley
   That this House notes with concern the Teachers TV survey of education employees which found that 55.1 per cent. of respondents are aware of racist bullying in their school; further notes with alarm that 68.3 per cent. of respondents commented that their school does not have a strategy to help combat racist bullying; commends the work of the Anti-Bullying Alliance in attempting to counter bullying of all kinds; applauds the makers of Channel 4 soap opera Hollyoaks for drawing public attention to this important issue; and calls on the Government to provide sufficient resources to help ensure that schools successfully implement comprehensive strategies against racist bullying.


1410WOMEN AND CYCLING30:4:09
Jo Swinson
Mr Mike Hancock
Peter Bottomley
Mr Alan Meale
Mr Martin Caton
Bob Spink
* 35
 Sandra Gidley
   That this House welcomes the Bike Belles initiative, recently launched by Sustrans, that seeks to persuade more women to take up cycling; notes that fewer than one in 10 women cycle more than once a month and that 79 per cent. of women think cycling is not suitable for them; further notes the many health benefits that cycling brings at comparatively low cost compared with many other methods of keeping fit; and therefore encourages more women to visit the Bike Belles website to see whether cycling could be right for them.


1415PAYMENT ARRANGEMENTS FOR STATE RETIREMENT PENSION5:5:09
David Heyes
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Bob Russell
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
Bob Spink
* 41
 Julie Morgan
   That this House believes that the state retirement pension should become payable from the actual date that a person reaches pensionable age, rather than from the first Monday thereafter, as is currently the case; and calls on the Government to take the necessary steps to facilitate payment of pension from the actual date that a person reaches the age of entitlement.


1416WELSH POLICE FORCES FUNDING5:5:09
Jenny Willott
Mark Williams
Lembit Öpik
Mr Roger Williams
David T. C. Davies
Mr Gregory Campbell
* 9
 Adam Price
   That this House is deeply concerned that the current system for funding Welsh police forces is leaving them seriously underfunded; calls on the Home Office to reform the central government grant funding system so that all Welsh police forces receive a fair grant based on their respective policing needs; and calls on the Home Secretary, Welsh Secretary and Welsh Assembly Government to ensure that the costs of both the extra duties involved in policing the Welsh capital city, and the large, sparsely populated rural areas of Wales are properly covered.


1419MUSCULAR DYSTROPHY CAMPAIGN AND THE TRAILBLAZERS REPORT5:5:09
Jo Swinson
Bob Russell
Mrs Ann Cryer
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
Bob Spink
* 49
 Mr Russell BrownMrs Iris Robinson
   That this House welcomes the launch of a hard-hitting report by Trailblazers revealing that young disabled people face a more limited choice when travelling by public transport and pay more for the privilege; notes that this reduces independence and quality of life; commends Trailblazers on their very first campaign; further notes that Trailblazers is the Muscular Dystrophy Campaign's new exciting v-funded young campaigners' network which will turn the aspirations of young disabled people into action; and calls on the Government, local authorities and transport providers to act on the recommendations of Trailblazers and undertake a major review of accessibility policies.


1422REPLACEMENT OF TRIDENT MISSILES5:5:09
Mr Roger Godsiff
Mrs Ann Cryer
Bob Spink
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Ken Purchase
Mr Martin Caton
* 43
 Sandra Gidley
   That this House believes that the spending of upwards of £20 billion capital on the replacement of the Trident missile system cannot be justified in view of the Government's other spending commitments, particularly as the Vanguard Class submarines which carry the missiles, supplied from the United States, will remain useable until 2024.

As an Amendment to Mr Roger Godsiff's proposed Motion (Replacement of Trident Missiles):

Mr Dai Davies
John McDonnell
* 2
Line 4, at end add `but believes that in order to comply with obligations as a member state of the 1968 Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, Trident should immediately be entered into multilateral nuclear disarmament negotiations.'.
7:5:09(a1)


1423PARLIAMENTARY OMBUDSMAN AND EQUITABLE LIFE POLICYHOLDERS5:5:09
Dr Vincent Cable
Susan Kramer
Daniel Kawczynski
Derek Wyatt
Mr Andrew Tyrie
Dr Tony Wright
* 300
 Martin SalterJoan RyanMr David Heathcoat-Amory
 Ms Gisela StuartHugh BayleyMr Michael Jack
 Geraldine SmithMr Stephen HepburnMr Mark Francois
 Richard Younger-RossDavid MundellStewart Hosie
 Mr Philip DunneRobert Neill
   That this House notes the Parliamentary Ombudsman has taken the unusual step of using powers under the 1967 Act to present Parliament with a further and final report on Equitable Life; also notes that the Public Administration Select Committee's second report on Equitable Life, Justice denied? concluded that the Government response to the Parliamentary Ombudsman's report was inadequate as a remedy for injustice; recognises the vital role the Ombudsman plays in public life; reaffirms the duty of Parliament to support the office of the Ombudsman; believes the Government should accept the recommendations of the Ombudsman on compensating policyholders who have suffered loss; welcomes the formation of the All-Party Group on Justice for Equitable Life Policyholders; and notes with regret its necessary formation and the fact that over 30,000 people have already died waiting for a just resolution to this saga.


1424NEWSPAPER AND MAGAZINE DISTRIBUTION MARKET5:5:09
Simon Hughes
Bob Russell
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
Mr Mike Hancock
Mark Hunter
* 92
 David LepperSandra GidleyJulia Goldsworthy
   That this House notes that newsagents across the country, as represented by the National Federation of Retail Newsagents and the Association of News Retailers, have expressed serious concern about the recent consolidation of the newspaper and magazine distribution market and the likely emergence of two regional monopolies; values the important role of independent newsagents and is concerned that these changes in the market may force many to close, restricting consumer choice and harming local communities, as well as causing up to 2,800 job losses in news distribution branches across the UK; and calls on the Secretary of State for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform to request that the Office of Fair Trading looks urgently at these recent developments in the distribution market and takes action to safeguard competition for the benefit of consumers, independent newsagents and distribution employees alike.


1425RACISM IN FOOTBALL5:5:09
Keith Vaz
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
Bob Spink
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr George Howarth
* 62
 Mr David ClellandDavid Cairns
   That this House welcomes the steps being taken by the Football Association to counter racism in football; applauds the proposals of the Football Association's working group on tackling Islamophobia and anti-Semitism in football to introduce tribunals to investigate racist and religious abuse at all levels of the game; encourages the football authorities fully to utilise the powers at their disposal to tackle all forms of abuse; recognises the need for the football community as a whole to unite to stamp out intolerance in the sport; and looks forward to the publication of the working group's report containing their full recommendations later in the year.


1431SAFETY IN NUMBERS FOR CYCLISTS6:5:09
Gwyn Prosser
Sir Peter Soulsby
Andrew George
Mrs Ann Cryer
Emily Thornberry
Mr Don Foster
* 191
 Dr Howard StoateMr Michael FallonMr Anthony Wright
 Mr Kevin BarronTony LloydStephen Hesford
   That this House acknowledges the evidence that cyclists gain from safety in numbers, in other words cycling gets safer the more cyclists there are; welcomes the target in the Government's draft Road Safety Strategy to halve the risks of cycling within 10 years; believes that this target can best be met by also aiming for substantial increases in cycle use in order to maximise the safety in numbers effect, thereby also benefiting health, communities, the economy and the environment; urges that the Road Safety Strategy should tackle the fears which deter people from cycling, such as traffic speeds, irresponsible driving, hostile roads and junctions and lorries; and calls for cycle training to be made available to people of all ages so as to achieve more as well as safer cycling.


1432LEHMAN-BACKED STRUCTURED PRODUCTS6:5:09
Mr Edward Vaizey
Tony Baldry
Bob Spink
Sir John Butterfill
Adam Price
Dr Richard Taylor
* 54
 Mr Keith SimpsonDavid T. C. Davies
   That this House notes that more than 6,000 people invested more than £200 million of their savings in structured products backed by Lehman Brothers; further notes that such products were marketed as 100 per cent. secure by the companies that sold them, such as NDFA; is dismayed that, following the collapse of Lehman Brothers, investors appear to have lost their savings; and urges the Financial Services Authority to conduct a rapid and detailed investigation into the marketing of these products.


1433CAROL ANN DUFFY'S APPOINTMENT AS POET LAUREATE6:5:09
Mr John Leech
Andrew Stunell
Mark Hunter
Mr Don Foster
Andrew George
Mr Edward Vaizey
* 38
 Mr David ClellandDavid Cairns
   That this House congratulates Carol Ann Duffy on being appointed Poet Laureate; notes that she is the first woman to hold the position; celebrates her contribution to the British literary landscape as well as that of Manchester; notes also her involvement in local events such as the Chorlton Arts Festival; and wishes her every success in the coming years.


1436MINER'S KNEE6:5:09
Mr Michael Clapham
Mr Dennis Skinner
Mr Denis Murphy
John Cummings
Bill Etherington
Mr David Hamilton
* 62
 Mr Paul Murphy
   That this House welcomes the Government's acceptance of the Industrial Injuries Advisory Council recommendations that osteoarthritis of the knee be declared an industrial disease for coal miners and payments under the Industrial Injuries Disablement Benefit scheme be made available shortly for those disabled by the condition; notes that certain firms of solicitors are seeking to make yet more money out of disabled miners by offering to assist them complete their application forms at a cost of £300 when applications to the Department of Work and Pensions are cost-free; and believes that this activity combined with the likelihood that litigation will grind on for years at an enormous cost makes an overwhelming case for the introduction of a no-fault compensation scheme.


1440REGULATION OF VULTURE FUNDS6:5:09
Ms Sally Keeble
Tony Baldry
Mr David S. Borrow
Susan Kramer
Mr David Anderson
Mr Lee Scott
* 125
 David LepperSandra GidleyGwyn Prosser
 Mr Don FosterCharlotte AtkinsTom Levitt
 Hugh BayleyAnn WintertonMr George Howarth
 Mr Denis MurphyMr Michael MooreSarah Teather
 David HeyesAnnette BrookeAngus Robertson
 Mr Alistair CarmichaelJulia GoldsworthyEmily Thornberry
 Tim Farron
   That this House expresses concern at the activities of vulture funds which seek to profiteer from the defaulted debts of developing countries; notes that the international community has already deemed many of these countries' debts unsustainable and agreed to cancel them; further notes the continuing actions brought by vulture funds which try to claim payment via international trade and even aid transactions with poor countries; is concerned at the use of UK courts for a high proportion of these cases; welcomes the work by the Jubilee Debt Campaign to highlight the activities of the vulture funds; supports the provisions of the Developing Country Debt (Restriction of Recovery) Bill introduced, with the support of a cross-party group of hon. Members, by the hon. Member for Northampton North to limit the activities of vulture funds; and calls on the Government to support this bill.


1444SUPPLEMENTARY CHARGES FOR OXYGEN BY AIRLINES6:5:09
Nick Ainger [R]
Dr Richard Taylor
Dr Vincent Cable
Chris Ruane
Mr Michael Clapham
Sir Nicholas Winterton
* 228
 Robert KeyMr Kevin BarronGeraldine Smith
 Mr Martyn JonesJohn McFallRichard Younger-Ross
 Stephen WilliamsJo SwinsonRobert Neill
   That this House recognises that patients with pulmonary hypertension, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, muscular dystrophy and other conditions require supplemental oxygen when travelling by air; is dismayed that the vast majority of airlines operating in the UK currently charge passengers requiring supplemental oxygen on flights; applauds the work of the Pulmonary Hypertension Association, the British Lung Foundation and the Muscular Dystrophy Campaign to end the unfair financial impact of what is effectively a tax on the disabled; calls on all airlines flying from or through UK airports to allow passengers requiring in-flight supplemental oxygen to either bring personal oxygen equipment on board and use it, subject to necessary security checks, or to have supplemental oxygen provided for them by the airline, in both cases without charge; welcomes the recent decision by British Airways, Emirates and Cathay Pacific to drop all charges; notes that as of 1 May 2009 airlines in the United States of America will have to allow passengers requiring supplemental oxygen to be able to use their own portable oxygen concentrator free of charge; and urges all airlines operating in the UK to follow suit.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1447SCHOOL REPORT CARDS7:5:09
Mr David Laws
Mr David Heath
Annette Brooke
Stephen Williams
Peter Bottomley
Lynne Jones
* 27
 David Howarth
   That this House would welcome the introduction of school report cards provided that they give a broader and more meaningful assessment of school performance and quality; awaits the publication of the Government's White Paper on report cards later this year; welcomes the decision to abolish compulsory national curriculum tests at Key Stage 3; and believes Key Stage 2 tests are an important accountability measure but should be reformed and slimmed down with more teacher assessment coupled with external moderation to ensure high standards are maintained.


1450PRISONS AND THE PRIVATE SECTOR7:5:09
Paul Rowen
Lynne Jones
Jim Dobbin
Mrs Linda Riordan
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr Robert N. Wareing
* 30
 Mark Hunter
   That this House notes the recent trend towards privatisation of prisons; further notes the persistently low performance of such privatised prisons in the prison service league table and the prison quarterly league tables; questions the ability of privatised prisons to maintain prison discipline and a safe environment for prison employees; agrees with the Prison Officers' Association in its opposition to prison privatisation; and calls for an end to further privatisation of prisons including HMP Buckley Hall in Rochdale which is currently tendering private applications.


1452POLITICAL PRISONERS IN BURMA7:5:09
Andrew Stunell
Mr Nigel Evans
Peter Bottomley
Lynne Jones
Mr Andrew Dismore
Jim Dobbin
* 118
 Sandra GidleyMrs Iris Robinson
   That this House welcomes the Free Burma's Political Prisoners Now campaign being organised by former political prisoners from Burma; congratulates the organisers on securing 250,000 signatures in support of the campaign; notes that more than 2,100 political prisoners languish in Burma's gaols, having committed no crime other than to want freedom and democracy, or to deliver aid to victims of Cyclone Nargis; expresses deep concern that political prisoners are deliberately being denied medical treatment; supports the call for UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon to make it his personal priority to secure the release of all of Burma's political prisoners; and calls on the Government to do all it can to assist the UN Secretary General in this objective.


1455MIND WEEK CAMPAIGN ON MEN'S MENTAL HEALTH11:5:09
Lynne Jones
Tim Loughton
Sandra Gidley
Mr Lee Scott
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
* 71
 David Lepper
   That this House supports the Mind Week campaign to raise awareness of men's mental health in England and Wales; notes that 75 per cent. of all suicides are by men and that one in seven men who experience prolonged unemployment will develop a mental health problem; is concerned that the recession will have a disproportionately negative effect on the mental health of men in England and Wales; and further supports Mind's call for greater awareness of men's mental health problems.


1459SMART METERS11:5:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Jim Dobbin
Bob Russell
Andrew George
Bob Spink
* 55
 Sandra GidleyMr David Clelland
   That this House welcomes the Government's announcement to equip all homes with smart meters by 2020; notes that smart meters will be a significant step forward in reducing the UK's energy use, cutting carbon emissions, making headway in the Government's pledge to create a smart grid and, further, significantly saving customers money; further notes that smart meters will end the need for utility companies to dispatch meter readers, estimate bills and employ large numbers of call centre staff, resulting in cost savings that can responsibly be passed on to customers; and looks forward to smart meters allowing customers increased awareness of their energy consumption and enabling an estimated two to three per cent. saving of their energy use each year, thereby cutting £100 million from UK bills by 2020 and reducing national carbon dioxide emissions by 2.6 million tonnes.


1461EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES BILL11:5:09
Mr John Prescott
Mr Kevin Barron
Mrs Betty Williams
Clive Efford
Mrs Anne McGuire
Helen Southworth
* 145
 Michael Connarty
   That this House, in celebrating 10 years of the minimum wage, welcomes the above-inflation overall increase in its value over that time; notes with concern the proposal to give the Employment Opportunities Bill, which would abolish the minimum wage, a second reading; calls on the Leader of the Opposition to distance his party from attempts seeking to impoverish low paid workers by this means; and welcomes the Wage Concern campaign to protect the minimum wage.

As Amendments to Mr John Prescott's proposed Motion (Employment Opportunities Bill):

Mr Christopher Chope
Mr James Gray
Mr Greg Knight
Philip Davies
Mr John Whittingdale
Mr Brian Binley
* 8
Line 1, leave out `celebrating' and insert `noting'.
12:5:09(a1)
Mr Christopher Chope
Mr James Gray
Mr Greg Knight
Philip Davies
Mr John Whittingdale
Mr Brian Binley
* 8
Line 1, leave out from `welcomes' to end and add `the publication of the Employment Opportunities Bill which would inter alia give a right to work to asylum seekers whose applications for asylum are awaiting determination and which would also enable any employee who would otherwise qualify for entitlement to the national minimum wage to elect to opt out from such entitlement; notes that the Bill does not abolish the minimum wage; regrets that the right hon. Member for Kingston upon Hull East and his colleagues have failed to comprehend the contents of the Bill; and calls on them to bring to the attention of the public the contents of Clause 2(5) of the Bill which makes clear that nothing in the Bill shall require a person to take employment below the minimum wage and that no person shall suffer any detriment to their entitlement to national insurance benefits by reason of their unwillingness to take employment below the minimum wage.'.
12:5:09(a2)


1462ARRESTS OF DEMOCRATIC SOCIETY PARTY MEMBERS IN TURKEY11:5:09
John Austin
Graham Stringer
Mr Andrew Dismore
David Lepper
Bob Russell
Peter Bottomley
* 42
 Mr Paul KeetchMr Tom ClarkeDavid Howarth
   That this House is concerned about the recent wave of arrests in Turkey of members of the Democratic Society Party (DTP), a legal political party which, in the recent Turkish local elections, achieved a resounding endorsement from Kurdish voters; notes that the Party's success awakened hope for many millions of Kurds that their voice would be heard in Turkish politics; regrets that in responding to the DTP's electoral victories with repression, the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) is revealing itself to be little different from previous administrations which have refused to acknowledge the existence of a Kurdish issue and thus offered no solutions for resolving it; believes that it is the duty of all those who seek peace and stability in Turkey to support the responsible calls for a just democratic solution to the issue of the rights of the Kurdish people; calls for the immediate release of all those DTP members who have been arrested; and urges the UK Government to put the utmost diplomatic pressure on Turkey to turn away from conflict and to open negotiations with DTP leaders forthwith as it believes the DTP has a key role to play in any peace process and bringing stability to the region.


1463INTERNATIONAL NURSES DAY11:5:09
Mr David Anderson
Andrew George
Mr Lee Scott
John Cummings
Mr Andrew Dismore
Bob Russell
* 95
 Mr David ClellandMr Paul MurphyMrs Iris Robinson
   That this House joins the rest of the UK in celebrating International Nurses Day on 12 May which is also the birthday of the founder of modern nursing, Florence Nightingale; recognises the vital role the nursing workforce plays in maintaining the health of the nation and the dedication and commitment they show in providing patient care in a wide variety of settings in which they work in the NHS, private sector and elsewhere; acknowledges the expertise, compassion and professionalism nurses display in treating patients of all ages from neonatal care to end-of-life provision; praises the wide range of specialist settings where nurses work as practitioners at the forefront of modernising the healthcare system and the role nurses play in the leadership and innovation of the NHS; and gives thanks to those nurses serving in the armed forces and recognises the essential role they play both in the UK and areas of conflict abroad.


146564th ANNIVERSARY OF THE LIBERATION OF THE CHANNEL ISLANDS11:5:09
Andrew Rosindell
Jim Dobbin
Mr Henry Bellingham
Daniel Kawczynski
Geraldine Smith
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
* 42
 Mrs Iris Robinson
   That this House joins with the people of the Channel Islands of Jersey, Guernsey, Alderney and Sark in celebrating the 64th anniversary of their liberation by British military forces from German occupation on 9 May 1945; pays a heartfelt tribute to the courageous stand for freedom taken by the Channel Islanders during their years of occupation when, despite the extreme persecution and hardship they faced, they never lost hope that their liberation would take place; and calls on the Government to continue to fulfil its historic duty to stand shoulder to shoulder with the people of the Channel Islands, guaranteeing their safety, freedom and independence for centuries to come.


1471BOGUS COLLEGES12:5:09
Mrs Janet Dean
Mr Gary Streeter
Tom Brake
Martin Salter
Peter Bottomley
Jeremy Corbyn
* 109
 Mr Oliver HealdFrank DobsonMr Graham Allen
 Sarah TeatherStewart Hosie
   That this House believes that bogus colleges set up with the express purpose of enabling prospective immigrants to bypass ordinary UK immigration controls, and not providing education and training, prey on unsuspecting students from overseas and are damaging the reputation of UK education; and further believes that the future use of the word `college' in business titles should be restricted under the Companies Act 2006.


1473BAN ON SNARES12:5:09
Mr Eric Martlew
Miss Ann Widdecombe
Mr David Drew
Stephen Williams
Ms Diane Abbott
Mark Durkan
* 146
 Mr Don FosterDr Doug NaysmithTom Levitt
 Andrew MillerStephen HesfordMichael Connarty
 Annette BrookeNorman LambDavid Howarth
 Jenny WillottGordon Banks
   That this House congratulates the League Against Cruel Sports for producing the report War on Wildlife highlighting the indiscriminate suffering caused by snares; notes a recent poll conducted by the League Against Cruel Sports in conjunction with the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons which found that 90 per cent. of respondents were strongly behind a ban on snares; and therefore calls on the Government to outlaw the manufacture, sale and use of all snares.


1475HOUSE OF COMMONS CATERING STAFF12:5:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Jon Cruddas
Mr David Crausby
Jim Dobbin
Mr Bob Laxton
Graham Stringer
* 66
 Mrs Iris Robinson
   That this House expresses concern and disappointment that the House of Commons catering grade staff are still waiting for their pay settlement from April 2008; notes the dedication and commitment of the House of Commons catering staff to delivering a first-class catering service in the House of Commons; believes it is unacceptable that these workers have not yet received the pay increases they deserve; and calls on the House authorities urgently to resolve this unacceptable situation.


1476DETENTION OF TRADE UNIONISTS AND STUDENTS IN IRAN12:5:09
John McDonnell
Harry Cohen
Peter Bottomley
Mark Durkan
Mr Robert N. Wareing
Jeremy Corbyn
* 47
 Michael Connarty
   That this House notes with concern that during the May Day rally in Laleh Park, Tehran over 100 participants were physically attacked and arrested, including leading members of the Free Trade Union, and that at the May Day rally in Sanandaj in western Iran a further attack took place with 10 arrested; further notes that the Iranian authorities continue to detain Mr Mansour Osaloo, the President of the Tehran Bus Drivers Syndicate and students from the Freedom and Equality Seeking Activists movement; and calls on the Government to condemn these human rights abuses and to urge the Iranian government for the release of these detainees.


14782009 LOCAL AUTHORITY ROAD MAINTENANCE SURVEY13:5:09
Mr Christopher Chope
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Mr Andrew Dismore
Peter Bottomley
Bob Russell
Mr Greg Knight
* 35
 Sandra GidleyMr Roger Williams
   That this House is appalled at the waste and neglect revealed in the findings of the 2009 Annual Local Authority Road Maintainance Survey; is concerned that the number of potholes on England's local roads has increased by a third in one year, that there is now a 13 year backlog of maintenance work and that the annual cost of compensating victims of pothole related incidents now exceeds £53 million; and calls on the Government to come forward urgently with an action plan to restore road and pavement surfaces to a standard that is safe for users.


1481EARLY SETTLEMENT BY INSURANCE COMPANIES13:5:09
Mrs Linda Riordan
Mr Andrew Dismore
Bob Spink
Jeremy Corbyn
Peter Bottomley
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
* 38
 Mr Ian TaylorMichael ConnartyMr Nigel Dodds
   That this House is concerned that people who have been injured through no fault of their own are being subjected to high pressure tactics from some insurance companies; notes that such tactics can impede proper access to justice for injured people and compound their distress; believes that all injured people should be made aware of their right to independent legal advice; and calls on the Government to work with the Financial Services Authority to introduce regulation in this area to protect injured people.


1482NATIONAL MINIMUM WAGE UPRATING13:5:09
John McDonnell
Kelvin Hopkins
Mr David Drew
Ms Diane Abbott
Mr Austin Mitchell
Lynne Jones
* 33
 Michael Connarty
   That this House welcomes the 10th anniversary of the National Minimum Wage introduced by this Labour Government in 1999; further welcomes recent Government measures to extend the minimum wage to apprentices and to exclude tips from minimum wage calculations; notes that the Low Pay Commission states that the minimum wage has had no discernible adverse impact, in contrast to the dire warnings of the Conservative Party at the time of its introduction; is therefore disappointed that this year's uprating of the minimum wage is the lowest on record, barely over one per cent. and between 4p and 7p for different age groups; and calls on the Government to end the age discrimination in the minimum wage and to legislate so that the minimum wage should always increase above both inflation and average earnings so as to narrow the inequality gap.

As an Amendment to John McDonnell's proposed Motion (National Minimum Wage Uprating):

Mr Gordon Prentice
Mr John Leech
* 2
Line 10, at end add `and to require employers to print on wage slips the rate of minimum wage in force after each uprating.'.
19:5:09(a1)


1487MANDATORY MICROCHIPPING OF DOGS14:5:09
Martin Horwood
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Peter Bottomley
Mr Adrian Sanders
Ann Winterton
Martin Linton
* 40
 Dr Brian Iddon
   That this House is concerned that over 97,000 dogs are picked up as strays by local authorities annually; congratulates Speaking Out for Animals, the animal action club at Thorpe House School, Norwich for campaigning hard to promote the mandatory microchipping of dogs as a means of reducing the huge numbers of strays and for its work to promote responsible pet ownership; commends the Dogs Trust, RSPCA and other animal charities for microchipping all dogs at point of adoption; believes that microchipping should be compulsory for all dogs at the point of sale; and urges the Government to introduce legislation on the mandatory microchipping of dogs.


1490AUNG SAN SUU KYI14:5:09
Ann Clwyd
Peter Bottomley
Mr Lee Scott
Mr Andrew Dismore
Glenda Jackson
Kelvin Hopkins
* 71
 Sandra GidleyTom Levitt
   That this House deplores the decision of Burma's regime to move the democracy leader and Nobel Peace Prize winner, Aung San Suu Kyi, to Insein prison to face charges relating to an incident involving a US citizen who broke into her compound last week; is dismayed by her unlawful detention under house arrest for 13 of the 19 years since the military junta refused to recognise the 1990 landslide victory of her party, the National League for Democracy; is concerned that this incident could give the military junta a convenient reason to extend her unlawful detention, which was meant to end shortly; is concerned about reports of a deterioration in Ms Suu Kyi's health; calls on the international community to do more to secure the release of political prisoners in Burma and to disregard the results of next year's elections if they are not free and fair; and applauds the European Union for extending its sanctions against the regime, including an arms embargo, a travel ban on Burma's leaders and a freezing of their assets in Europe.


1491EQUITABLE LIFE COMPENSATION (No. 3)14:5:09
John Barrett
Mr Alan Reid
Dr Evan Harris
Richard Younger-Ross
Peter Bottomley
Mr George Galloway
* 39
 Sandra GidleyMrs Iris RobinsonMr Douglas Carswell
   That this House notes that the collapse of Equitable Life affected more than one million people; further notes that an estimated 32,000 people have died while waiting for just compensation; welcomes the Parliamentary Ombudsman's recent report Injustice Unremedied: The Government's Response to Equitable Life; accepts the report's findings that the Government's response was unsatisfactory; strongly supports the Ombudsman's previous recommendation for the establishment of a just compensation scheme; and calls for the Government to accept immediately all of the findings of the Ombudsman's original report.


1497SEAT RESERVATION CHARGES AND NATIONAL EXPRESS14:5:09
Norman Lamb
Danny Alexander
Bob Russell
John Barrett
Mr Phil Willis
Greg Mulholland
* 32
 David HowarthJo Swinson
   That this House notes with disapproval the decision of National Express to introduce charges for seat reservations on its train services in East Anglia and on the East Coast Mainline; observes that the charge of £2.50 per single and £5 return journey is the highest seat-booking charge ever imposed by a private rail company in the UK and that it follows an increase of over 10 per cent. in its train fares over the last two years; further notes that the charge will only apply in standard class which will hit families and the elderly hardest as these groups often cannot risk being forced to stand on long train journeys; observes that the longest timetabled journey on National Express services is in excess of eight hours and that forcing people to pay extra to guarantee a seat on these services represents outrageous profiteering by National Express; further notes that National Express Group reported profits of £194 million last year; and calls on National Express to reconsider this unfair and disappointing policy as a matter of urgency.


1499REDUNDANCIES IN UNIVERSITIES15:5:09
Tony Lloyd
Jon Cruddas
Kelvin Hopkins
Ms Katy Clark
Chris McCafferty
Frank Dobson
* 100
 Mr Edward DaveyRoger BerryMike Wood
 Mr Marsha SinghMr Frank DoranMichael Connarty
 Annette BrookeColin ChallenJohn Hemming
 Jo Swinson
   That this House notes with extreme concern that up to 100 universities are currently planning redundancies, which amounts to two-thirds of higher education institutions cutting jobs; agrees that in a time of recession, higher education and higher level skills should be at the forefront of any plan for long term recovery, and that cutting jobs, course provision and student places is not in the interests of the economy or society; and calls on universities to work in partnership with the trades unions to provide a national plan to avoid cuts and defend provision, quality and access to higher education.


1504BIG LOTTERY FUND AND HEROES RETURN 2 PROGRAMME18:5:09
Nick Harvey
Mr Gerald Howarth
Dr Andrew Murrison
Mr Gordon Marsden
Derek Twigg
Peter Bottomley
* 103
 Dr Desmond Turner
   That this House welcomes the announcement of further funding from the Big Lottery Fund to support Second World War veterans wishing to attend overseas anniversary events throughout 2009 and 2010 to commemorate the end of the Second World War; notes that the Heroes Return 2 programme builds on over £16 million of previous funding from the Big Lottery Fund's Heroes Return programme that helped over 39,000 veterans, spouses, widows and carers to make commemorative trips to overseas Second World War battlesites; fully acknowledges the sacrifices that British servicemen and women made during the Second World War; recognises their bravery in defending the United Kingdom; and is pleased that this is rightly recognised through funding that will enable veterans to participate in commemorative visits across the world to mark the anniversaries of events that led to the end of the Second World War.


1513LEGAL SERVICES COMMISSION18:5:09
Kelvin Hopkins
Jeremy Corbyn
Ms Diane Abbott
Peter Bottomley
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr Martin Caton
* 46
 David Lepper
   That this House notes that the proposed restructuring of the Legal Services Commission (LSC) will lead to approximately 600 redundancies in England and Wales; is concerned that the level of redundancies is far too high given the current economic climate; and expresses serious concern about the negative impact this may have on the service delivery for the most vulnerable people in England and Wales requiring the services of the LSC, especially in a time of recession when the demand for legal aid services the LSC provides is increasing.


1514MOBILE NUMBER PORTING18:5:09
John Robertson
Peter Bottomley
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Bob Spink
Lynne Jones
Mark Durkan
* 33
 Mr Paul KeetchMrs Joan Humble
   That this House registers its concern about the slow progress made to fully reform the UK's mobile number porting system; believes that the current lengthy porting process undermines the ability of UK consumers properly to exercise choice; notes that the proposal made by Ofcom back in November 2007 would have enabled consumers to move their mobile number between operators within two hours rather than the two days it presently takes; regrets that the September 2009 deadline for the implementation of the new system will be missed; and calls on all mobile operators to support the delivery of two hour recipient led number porting for the benefit of UK consumers as a matter of urgency.


1515WELFARE OF FARMED RABBITS18:5:09
Mr Adrian Sanders
Bob Russell
Peter Bottomley
Mr Martin Caton
Lynne Jones
Mr Mike Hancock
* 73
 Mr David AmessMr Michael MatesSandra Gidley
 Jim DowdMike WoodMrs Joan Humble
 Julie MorganMr Roger WilliamsMr David Anderson
 Martin HorwoodMr Andrew Pelling
   That this House notes with concern the lack of detailed regulations concerning the welfare of domestic rabbits farmed in the UK; believes that farmed rabbits should not be kept in cages as this practice is not consistent with good welfare; notes that the welfare of farmed rabbits, including breeding does, is improved by housing in enriched group pens that provide greater environmental complexity, freedom of movement and opportunities for social interaction; further believes that rabbits should be provided with sufficient height and floor space to allow them to adopt normal postures such as rearing up on their hind legs and to carry out meaningful exercise such as hopping; supports a provision for solid flooring to reduce foot injuries in rabbits; further believes that all farmed rabbits should have access to environmental enrichment, including hay or straw and wooden sticks or blocks for gnawing, and improved housing design that allows for hiding and retreat; supports the work of the Four Paws organisation in this area; and calls on the Government to introduce regulations to phase-out the keeping of farmed rabbits in cages and to make detailed provisions for their welfare.


1516LANCE CORPORAL JOHNSON BEHARRY VC18:5:09
Bob Russell
Mr Mike Hancock
Peter Bottomley
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mark Hunter
Stephen Williams
* 41
 Jo Swinson
   That this House calls on all decent British citizens to condemn the British National Party (BNP) for stating on its website that Lance Corporal Johnson Beharry was awarded the Victoria Cross, not for bravery in the face of the enemy in Iraq in 2005 and saving the lives of comrades in two individual acts of great heroism as set out in the Citation, but for what the BNP disgracefully says was a `politically correct' decision by the Ministry of Defence for an action limited to the Grenada-born soldier driving away very fast from a combat zone; is proud that HM Armed Forces comprises men and women from all ethnic backgrounds, from the UK and the Commonwealth, plus Gurkhas from Nepal; notes as an historic fact that people of all racial groups served, and lost their lives, fighting fascism in the Second World War and thus helped to preserve this country's freedoms against such evils; deplores the use in BNP election literature of a false photograph of a British soldier, with false quote, claiming support for the BNP; and urges the Government to ensure that the British people are made fully aware that the BNP represents the views which Britain went to war to defeat.


1517COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FINANCE18:5:09
Dr Vincent Cable
Bob Russell
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Stephen Williams
Mr Martin Caton
* 90
 Julie MorganDavid HowarthJulia Goldsworthy
 Willie Rennie
   That this House recognises that for the last decade the community development finance sector has been an effective way of providing loans and support to small businesses, social enterprises and entrepreneurs in deprived communities; further notes that these community development finance institutions have financed over 24,000 businesses and individuals, created 15,800 jobs and sustained 70,000 more; believes that this sector has the infrastructure and expertise in place quickly to deliver finance directly into the communities most affected by the downturn; and urges the Government to follow the lead set by President Obama in the United States by introducing measures to support these innovative organisations which are helping communities to help themselves out of recession.


1518MARINE AND COASTAL ACCESS BILL [LORDS]18:5:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Jim Dobbin
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Mr Martin Caton
* 39
 Jo Swinson
   That this House congratulates the Government on the introduction of a bill to preserve the marine environment; notes the concerns expressed by the Wildlife Trust, the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds, World Wildlife Fund and the Marine Conservation Society to strengthen aspects of the Marine and Coastal Access Bill to ensure that effective conservation legislation is delivered; calls on the Government to bring forward amendments to provide that those causing reckless damage to marine conservation zones are as accountable as those found to be causing the damage purposefully; and further calls on the Government to address these issues and work with these organisations as the Bill progresses.


1519SUPPORT FOR CARERS (No.2)18:5:09
Mr Stephen O'Brien
Angela Browning
Tim Loughton
Mr Simon Burns
Mr Bernard Jenkin
Mr Peter Bone
* 75
 Mr David Clelland
   That this House recognises the vital role of carers in the lives of those they care for all year round; acknowledges the huge amount of time, effort and devotion involved; welcomes Carers Week 2009 as an opportunity to highlight the contribution of carers; thanks carers for the sacrifices they make in order to improve the lives of others; and recognises that helping carers is one of the best ways to help those they are caring for.


1521PROBATION SERVICE18:5:09
Mr Neil Gerrard
David Howarth
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
John McDonnell
Bob Russell
Bob Spink
* 55
 Mr Bob Laxton
   That this House urges the Government to ensure that the Probation Service in England and Wales has sufficient resources to ensure that it can carry out its statutory duties in an effective and efficient manner.


1523TRIDENT REPLACEMENT18:5:09
Bob Spink
Mr Martin Caton
Lynne Jones
Mark Durkan
Paul Rowen
Mr John Leech
* 38
 Sandra GidleyDavid HowarthJo Swinson
   That this House values its unique role of scrutiny in the democratic process; and therefore calls on the Government to make no decision on Trident replacement during a Parliamentary recess.


1524BRITISH ARMED FORCES RETURNING FROM IRAQ18:5:09
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Mr Martin Caton
Lynne Jones
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Gregory Campbell
* 30
 Mrs Iris Robinson
   That this House warmly welcomes home the last of the British armed forces from Iraq; notes with great sadness the loss of 179 personnel with many others wounded or traumatised; and congratulates the UK's servicemen and women involved in the conflict on an excellent job and thanks them wholeheartedly.


1527UK-US EXTRADITION TREATY19:5:09
Chris Huhne
David Howarth
Mark Durkan
Lynne Jones
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
* 38
 Sandra Gidley
   That this House notes that under the Extradition Act 2003 and UK-US Extradition Treaty, the United States is not required to provide prima facie evidence when requesting extradition from the UK, although the United Kingdom is still required to provide evidence to satisfy the US constitution's probable cause requirement when seeking extradition from the US; further notes that the Extradition Treaty was agreed without any recourse to Parliament; and calls on the Government to renegotiate the Extradition Treaty immediately to reinstate the requirement for prima facie evidence, and to reform the Royal Prerogative so that international agreements can no longer be entered into without meaningful reference to Parliament.


1529GET FAIR COALITION AND POVERTY IN THE UK19:5:09
John Battle
Mark Durkan
Bob Russell
Lynne Jones
Bob Spink
Andrew George
* 64
 David LepperHugh BayleyMr Jim Hood
 Danny Alexander
   That this House believes that as the fifth largest economy in the world it is unacceptable that 12.8 million people, 1 in 5 of the population, are living in poverty in the UK; further believes that with the economy in recession and rising unemployment, the Government must commit to further measures to protect the poorest in society; and supports calls by the Get Fair Coalition of charities, faith and community groups for the Government to increase levels of income to a minimum living standard for a lasting reduction in poverty in the UK.


1531MOBILE TERMINATION RATES (No. 2)19:5:09
Mr Nigel Evans
Mark Durkan
Bob Spink
Mr Martin Caton
Peter Bottomley
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 130
 Mr Andrew MackayMr John WhittingdaleMr Edward Davey
 Charlotte AtkinsMr Richard ShepherdClare Short
 Shona McIsaacHugh BayleyMr Kevin Barron
 Mr Clive BettsMr Fabian HamiltonGeraldine Smith
 Sandra OsborneSir Menzies CampbellDr William McCrea
 Sarah TeatherAnnette BrookeNorman Lamb
 Albert OwenStewart HosiePhilip Davies
   That this House welcomes the European Commission's recent recommendation providing clear principles to EU national telecoms regulators to set a fair cost for termination rates; further welcomes the Terminate the Rate campaign, which calls for a significant lowering of mobile termination rates (MTRs) in the future, and is supported by a number of companies and organisations including the Federation of Small Businesses and Carers UK; notes that MTRs increase the cost of calling a mobile telephone from a fixed-line or mobile telephone on another network, and hold back innovation in the telecommunications sector; further notes that significantly lowering MTRs would pave the way for an end to per-minute call charges and high bills and would enable communication providers to offer flat-rate unlimited tariffs giving consumers better value for money; and calls on Ofcom to take action to reduce excessive mobile termination charges and deliver a better deal for hard-pressed UK consumers.


1536JOINT FORCES ALLIANCE GROUP20:5:09
Mr Alan Meale
Dr Rudi Vis
Bill Etherington
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 28
 David Cairns
   That this House commends the work of the Joint Forces Alliance Group which, with the Royal British Legion and other charities, including the Gulf War Veterans Group, is active in gaining housing and welfare support for disadvantaged ex-servicemen and women and their families; and calls on the Government to positively recognise the work done by these groups.


1537PRIVATE MILITARY COMPANIES20:5:09
Ms Diane Abbott
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Neil Gerrard
Lynne Jones
Kelvin Hopkins
Mr Mike Hancock
* 38
 Sandra GidleyRoger BerryJo Swinson
 Emily Thornberry
   That this House is concerned by the recent recommendation by the Foreign and Commonwealth Office that private military companies operating on behalf of the Government need not be regulated by a formal licensing system; notes that the Foreign and Commonwealth Office has recommended instead drawing up a code of conduct; is further concerned that this means private military companies guilty of malpractice whilst operating on behalf of the Government in war zones would face no legal sanctions other than the loss of their contract; further notes that the Foreign and Commonwealth Office is recommending private military companies be monitored by the British Association of Private Security Companies; believes a more independent body should monitor the private military industry; and calls on the Government seriously to reconsider the introduction of a formal licensing and monitoring system and to discontinue or at least reduce the use of private military staff as soldiers in war zones.

As an Amendment to Ms Diane Abbott's proposed Motion (Private Military Companies):

Mr Peter Kilfoyle
Mr Edward O'Hara
Mr Eddie McGrady
* 3
Line 9, leave out from `Companies;' to end and add `and calls on the Government to bring forward proposals for legislation against the use of private military staff on its behalf as soldiers in war zones.'.
1:6:09(a1)


1540PEDIGREE DOG BREEDS AND THE KENNEL CLUB20:5:09
Bob Spink
Mr Andrew Dismore
Kelvin Hopkins
Peter Bottomley
Mr Marsha Singh
Julie Morgan
* 31
 Mr Edward Davey
   That this House is concerned about health problems faced by some pedigree dog breeds; is pleased that the objective of the Kennel Club is to improve the welfare, health and general well-being of all dogs and to encourage responsible dog ownership and breeding; welcomes the actions taken by the Kennel Club to improve dog health; and urges the Government to apply the basic principles of the Kennel Club's Accredited Breeder Scheme to the breeding of all dogs in the UK.


1541MARINE CONSERVATION ZONES20:5:09
Mrs Linda Riordan
Mr Andrew Dismore
David Taylor
Lynne Jones
Derek Twigg
Kelvin Hopkins
* 35
 Michael ConnartyJo Swinson
   That this House congratulates the Government for bringing forward the world's first comprehensive system to plan and protect the seas now and for the future; notes the commitment of the Government to deliver an ecologically coherent network of marine conservation zones by 2012; further notes the commitment of the Government to deliver coastal access around the UK; and urges the Government to bring forward proposals to put these commitments on the statute book as soon as possible.


1545SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITIES BILL21:5:09
Mr David Drew
Peter Bottomley
Mr Mike Hancock
Glenda Jackson
Jeremy Corbyn
Mr John Leech
* 86
 Sandra GidleyMr Peter AinsworthFrank Dobson
 Mrs Joan HumbleJulie MorganDavid Howarth
 Jo SwinsonJulia GoldsworthyWillie Rennie
   That this House notes the success of the Sustainable Communities Act 2007 as the first step towards building a bottom up democracy; further notes the enthusiasm shown by local authorities across England in deciding to use the Act, with 115 councils, nearly one third of all principal councils, having opted to use that process; notes also the genuine cross-party support that the original Act commanded; welcomes the Sustainable Communities Bill which will extend the 2007 Act in two ways, firstly by involving parish and town councils and their county associations in the process, and secondly by ensuring that the process of involvement established by the Act becomes an on-going process rather than a one-off event; and so supports the Sustainable Communities Bill.


1547DISCRIMINATION IN RECRUITMENT AGAINST PEOPLE WITH INVISIBLE DISIBILITIES21:5:09
Lynne Jones
Sandra Gidley
Peter Bottomley
Mr Marsha Singh
Mr Mike Hancock
Glenda Jackson
* 52
 Dr Evan HarrisMs Diane Abbott
   That this House acknowledges the current levels of discrimination suffered by people with HIV and mental health problems in the job recruitment process; notes that fewer than 50 per cent. of people with HIV are in paid employment and more than 60 per cent. of employers write off people with any form of mental illness; further notes that it is currently legal for employers to ask a wide range of questions about a job applicant's medical history when they are recruiting, regardless of whether existing conditions will have any bearing on their ability to do the job applied for; supports calls from Rethink, the Terrence Higgins Trust and the National AIDS Trust for the Government to use the Equality Bill to restrict the use of pre-employment health questionnaires; recognises that employers in many other countries, including the US, are only legally able to ask a candidate about a disability once a job offer has been made; and calls on the Government to use the Equality Bill to bring British law in this area in line with the American system.


1551AUTISM AND THE CARER'S ALLOWANCE1:6:09
Mr Lee Scott [R]
Bob Spink
Bob Russell
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Martin Caton
Glenda Jackson
* 51
 Mr David Clelland
   That this House pays tribute to and acknowledges the valuable contribution made by thousands of parents and carers in supporting the needs of children and adults with autism and Asperger's Syndrome; supports the call of the UK Autism Foundation urging the Prime Minister and the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions to consider a substantial increase to the carer's allowance; shares the concern of the UK Autism Foundation that the present economic crisis is plunging some parents, carers and families with autism into poverty; and backs the call of autism campaigners for the Government to increase tax credits, the disability living allowance and the carer's allowance in order for parents, carers and children and adults with autism and Asperger's Syndrome to survive the credit crunch and the deepening recession.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1553HIV TREATMENTS AND CHILDREN1:6:09
Mr David S. Borrow
Sandra Gidley
Mr Neil Gerrard
Dr Evan Harris
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
* 87
 Dr Phyllis StarkeyTony BaldryTom Brake
 Dr Doug NaysmithCharlotte AtkinsMr Bob Laxton
 Mr Mark ToddMr Fabian HamiltonDr Brian Iddon
 Mrs Claire Curtis-ThomasJim CousinsMr Mohammad Sarwar
 Sarah TeatherMr Mike WeirHywel Williams
 Mr Dai HavardMr Alistair CarmichaelDr John Pugh
 Richard Younger-RossAlbert OwenJo Swinson
 Willie Rennie
   That this House notes with concern that globally most children who need treatment for HIV are not receiving it; further notes that there is a lack of appropriate HIV treatments for children and that the number of adults who have become resistant to basic HIV treatment and require more expensive medicines is increasing; recognises that the price of medicines and patents are closely linked; commends the Government's financial backing for UNITAID, the international drugs purchasing facility, and its support for the establishment of a patent pool; and calls on pharmaceutical companies to show their commitment to access to medicines for the world's poorest people by signing up to the UNITAID patent pool.


1557BASIC STATE PENSION AND WOMEN1:6:09
Stewart Hosie
Bob Spink
Lynne Jones
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Martin Caton
Glenda Jackson
* 47
 Sandra Gidley
   That this House recognises the predicament of many women who took breaks from work prior to the introduction of Home Responsibilities Protection after it was introduced in 1978 and who, as a result, have been unable to accrue 39 years qualifying contributions which would entitle them to a full basic pension; further recognises that many women are willing to pay for missing contributions; and calls on the Government to reconsider the rules on qualifying contributions for those women with broken national insurance contributions prior to April 1978.


1559ARCHBISHOP VINCENT NICHOLS1:6:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Jim Dobbin
Mr Joe Benton
Ruth Kelly
Jon Cruddas
Mr David Crausby
* 17
 Mr Paul Murphy
   That this House welcomes the installation of the Most Reverend Vincent Nichols as the 11th Archbishop of Westminster; commends his strident defence of Catholic values, particularly in respect of maintaining the dignity of human life, the family, education and championing the needs of the most marginalised; and believes that his leadership will further strengthen the role of the Catholic Church and religion in society.


1561DECRIMINALISATION OF SINGLE DISPENSING ERRORS1:6:09
Dr Howard Stoate
Sandra Gidley [R]
Bob Russell
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Colin Breed
* 175
 Mr John WhittingdaleMr Ian TaylorHon Nicholas Soames
 Mr Anthony WrightSiobhain McDonaghMr John Horam
 Mr Don FosterMr Kevin BarronMike Wood
 Mr Marsha SinghMr David CrausbyIan Stewart
 Mrs Louise EllmanMr Stephen HepburnMr Paul Murphy
 Michael ConnartyEric JoyceSir Menzies Campbell
 Sarah TeatherPaul FarrellyMr Alistair Carmichael
 Richard Younger-RossJo SwinsonMr Andy Slaughter
 Julia GoldsworthyDanny AlexanderMr Ben Wallace
 Jeremy WrightMr Robert GoodwillWillie Rennie
   That this House recognises that community pharmacists are on the front line in providing vital services to NHS patients in a high-pressure environment; notes that under the Medicines Act 1968 pharmacists who make an error while dispensing medicines are regularly tried for a criminal offence; is concerned that this discourages healthcare professionals who fear being criminalised from reporting dispensing errors; is further concerned that this limits opportunities to record mistakes and to learn from these errors; notes that the Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency is currently undertaking a project to review medicines legislation; and calls on the Government to work with the Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain to ensure that amended legislation offers a more proportionate response with the flexibility to recognise a genuine single dispensing error.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1563FOOTBALL AND THE SPORTING LISTED EVENTS REVIEW1:6:09
Mr John Grogan
Paul Rowen
Jim Sheridan
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Bob Spink
Miss Anne Begg
* 63
 Jim DowdMr Frank Doran
   That this House welcomes the review of sporting listed events which must be made available to free-to-air broadcasters such as the BBC and ITV at a fair and reasonable price; is concerned that FIFA and UEFA want to take most of the World Cup and European Championship finals matches off the A List to allow them to be auctioned off to subscription or pay TV; believes that it would be a travesty if England were to host the 2018 World Cup finals and most of the matches could not be watched live by those who could not afford to pay; further believes that the World Cup and European Championship finals are unique sporting events of national and international significance which should remain accessible to all in their entirety; and in addition recommends that all qualifying matches of the home nations should be available live free-to-air in the home nation concerned and that the A List should be amended accordingly.


1564IVF TREATMENT FOR OXFORDSHIRE COUPLES2:6:09
Mr Edward Vaizey
Tony Baldry
Dr Evan Harris
Robert Key
Kelvin Hopkins
John Hemming
* 30
 Sarah Teather
   That this House notes that National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) guidance states that IVF treatment should be funded for people aged between 23 and 39 years; further notes with concern that Oxfordshire Primary Care Trust only funds such treatment for couples aged between 35 and 38 years and refuses treatment to those where either partner has had a child, even if that child was born in a previous relationship; is encouraged that the Trust is currently reviewing its guidelines to reduce the age range to 30 years; and calls on Oxfordshire Primary Care Trust to go further and bring its guidelines into line with NICE guidance so that this vital treatment is available to the many couples in Oxfordshire who currently require such treatment but who fall outside the Primary Care Trust's current guidelines.


1565THE ELIZABETH FOUNDATION2:6:09
Mr Marsha Singh
Bob Spink
Kelvin Hopkins
Mr Robert N. Wareing
John Hemming
Philip Davies
* 20
 Mike Wood
   That this House recognises the unique and vital service that The Elizabeth Foundation provides to deaf children from newborn to five years old and their families; notes with concern that the foundation will close at the end of July 2009 if funding of £120,000 per annum cannot be secured; and calls on the Government to help save this service.


1569SUPPORT FOR THE BINGO INDUSTRY2:6:09
Mr Parmjit Dhanda
Lynne Jones
Bob Spink
Mark Durkan
Jim Dobbin
Sir Nicholas Winterton
* 121
 Dr Desmond TurnerSandra GidleyJim Dowd
 Mr Paul KeetchMr Elliot MorleyMike Wood
 Mrs Claire Curtis-ThomasJulie MorganMichael Connarty
 Mr Roger WilliamsHywel WilliamsMr Mark Field
 Albert OwenMr Douglas Carswell
   That this House congratulates the bingo industry on the contribution it makes to leisure and the economy in the UK; is concerned about the loss of 4,000 jobs in the bingo industry since 2003; calls on the Treasury to work closely with the bingo industry to preserve this popular leisure activity; and urges the Government to work closely with the industry to consider the future impact of the increase in bingo duty from 15 per cent. to 22 per cent., whilst the duty has remained at 15 per cent. for online versions of the game and for football pools.


1571BRITAIN'S GOT TALENT AND THE DANCE GROUP DIVERSITY2:6:09
Keith Vaz
Mrs Ann Cryer
Mr David Clelland
Dr Alasdair McDonnell
John Battle
Mrs Linda Riordan
* 10
 Sandra Gidley
   That this House congratulates Diversity for their victory in the ITV1 show Britain's Got Talent; notes that they received 24.9 per cent. of the votes cast; praises the group for their fantastic performance and for highlighting the positive impact of multiculturalism on the UK; encourages more young people to follow their example and to engage in positive community-based activities; and calls on the Government to do more to promote ethnic minority participation in the arts.


1572TIPAIMUKH DAM2:6:09
Mr George Galloway
Mark Durkan
Lynne Jones
Mr Robert N. Wareing
Jeremy Corbyn
Mr John Leech
* 30
 Clare Short
   That this House notes that the Indian government intends to proceed with the building of the Tipaimukh Dam near the border with Bangladesh; further notes that there is widespread and justified concern amongst many Bangladeshis, people of Bangladeshi origin, environmentalists and naturalists about the implications of this project and in particular for the future of Sylhet; further notes that many British citizens have family and property in Sylhet; and believes that the British Government should make urgent representations to the Indian government not to proceed with this project until such time as there are sufficient reassurances about water supply, the security of the dam and its full environmental impact, and that the project should be abandoned if such reassurances are not forthcoming.


1573CITIZENS CONVENTION (ACCOUNTABILITY AND ETHICS) BILL2:6:09
Mr Martin Caton
Mr David Drew
Norman Lamb
Mr Douglas Carswell
Julia Goldsworthy
Jim Dowd
* 93
 Sandra GidleyTom BrakeDr Rudi Vis
 Ms Diane AbbottMr Edward DaveyDr Vincent Cable
 Matthew TaylorMr Paul KeetchMr Jim Cunningham
 Mr Alan MealeHugh BayleyMrs Joan Humble
 Mr Robert N. WareingFrank CookJulie Morgan
 Sir Menzies CampbellSarah TeatherMr Alistair Carmichael
 Richard Younger-RossMartin HorwoodLorely Burt
 Willie RennieJohn Mason
   That this House is concerned at the current crisis of confidence regarding the political system; maintains that electors and not just politicians should be involved in initiating change; therefore supports the Citizens Convention (Accountability and Ethics) Bill; and believes that this measure should become law expeditiously and so calls for sufficient additional time to be made available in the House to achieve that end.


1574TAX HAVENS AND HM REVENUE AND CUSTOMS2:6:09
John McDonnell
David Taylor
Mrs Janet Dean
Alan Simpson
Mr David Drew
Mark Durkan
* 36
 John Mason
   That this House notes that the UK plays a major role in tax dodging, with many of the world's tax havens being British dependencies or territories, and with many tax lawyers and accountants working in the City of London; believes that companies have a social responsibility to pay their fair share of tax, not only in the UK but also in the developing world; further notes that since its creation HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) has pursued a programme of job cuts and office closures, and plans to close over 200 offices and cut 25,000 jobs by 2011, undermining HMRC's ability to assess, enforce and collect taxes and monies at a time when the tax gap is estimated by the Tax Justice Network to be costing the UK £100 billion a year and developing countries £250 billion a year; and calls on the Government to halt staff cutbacks and tax office closures in HMRC, to work with other countries to eradicate tax dodging practices, such as trade mis-pricing, and to promote transparency through country-by-country reporting by companies on the tax they owe, to abolish all UK tax havens, to prosecute those corporate executives, lawyers and accountants for profit laundering and tax dodging, and to use the taxes collected to help fund vital public services in the UK and in developing countries.


1575NATIONAL HOUSING FEDERATION'S SAVE OUR VILLAGES CAMPAIGN2:6:09
Mr Roger Williams
Mr David Curry
Mr David Drew
Andrew George
Mark Durkan
Mr Adrian Sanders
* 47
 Bob RussellMr Michael MatesSandra Gidley
 Matthew TaylorMr Robert WalterMr Paul Keetch
 Peter LuffMr Frank FieldMr Hugo Swire
 Jo Swinson
   That this House is deeply concerned about the desperate shortage of affordable housing in rural areas; recognises that without sufficient affordable housing many lower income earners and young people will be forced to leave the countryside, putting local businesses and services under further threat of closure; notes the lack of research about the true level of rural housing need; and therefore supports the National Housing Federation's Save Our Villages campaign calling on the Government and local authorities to ensure that every rural ward is assessed for housing need and covered by an action plan to address that need every three years.


1576FINANCIAL COST OF CONTACTING GOVERNMENT2:6:09
John Battle
Bob Spink
Mark Durkan
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Lynne Jones
Mr David Drew
* 59
 Michael ConnartyTim FarronJohn Mason
   That this House notes with concern the high cost of calls to Government helplines from mobile telephones; recognises that many people only have access to a mobile telephone and do not have a landline and therefore have no choice but to pay these high call costs; further notes the recent Citizens Advice Bureau report, Hung Up, which provided evidence from 65 citizens advice bureaux that many vulnerable and destitute people are unable to claim a crisis loan because of the expense of calling the Government freephone claim line on a mobile telephone; recognises that it is possible to make freephone numbers free to call from a mobile telephone, for example by registering the numbers with the Telephone Helplines Association; and calls on the Government urgently to ensure that its benefit claim lines, and in particular its crisis loans claim line, are made free to call from a mobile telephone.


1577INCREASED ACCESS TO WATERWAYS IN ENGLAND AND WALES2:6:09
Mr John Grogan
David Taylor
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
John Hemming
Jim Dobbin
* 39
 Mr David Clelland
   That this House applauds the British Canoe Union for staging an excellent 2009 European Canoe Slalom Championships in Nottingham, 28 to 31 May 2009, and celebrates the notable success of Team GB in taking four medals in total, two gold, one silver and one bronze; welcomes the BBC's live coverage on a busy sporting weekend; notes that over 2.5 million paddlers in Britain only have access to 1,400 miles of inland water in England and Wales, which is less than four per cent. of the total 41,000 miles of waterways over three metres wide; further notes that while the Countryside and Rights of Way Act 2002 only incorporates land, the Scottish Land Reform Act 2003 and its supporting Scottish Outdoor Access Code includes waterways, ensuring that paddlers have the same rights as walkers and access to all of Scotland's waterways; and calls on the Government to set a realistic target for increased access to waterways in England and Wales by the Olympic year of 2012.

As an Amendment to Mr John Grogan's proposed Motion (Increased Access to Waterways in England and Wales):

Mr Dai Havard
* 1
Line 11, leave out `and Wales'.
9:6:09(a1)


1578CROSS-INDUSTRY CONSTRUCTION APPRENTICESHIP TASK FORCE2:6:09
Mr David Anderson
Bob Spink
Jim Dobbin
Mark Durkan
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Lynne Jones
* 76
 Albert Owen
   That this House supports the work of the Cross-Industry Construction Apprenticeship Task Force (CCATF); further supports its aim to reinvigorate the culture and ethos of training in the construction industry; accepts the intrinsic value of apprenticeships to young people and to the construction industry; notes the imminent skills shortage affecting the construction industry; recognises that there are currently over 3,000 displaced apprentices in the United Kingdom; further recognises the work of the CCATF in bringing industry together to effect a solution to the current crisis; and calls on the Government to help create an environment conducive to the success of apprenticeships in the construction industry.


1581NATIONAL OBESITY FORUM AND THE MEDICAL MANAGEMENT OF WEIGHT LOSS2:6:09
Mr Kevin Barron
Mr Malcolm Moss
Dr John Pugh
John Cummings
Mr Denis Murphy
Sandra Gidley
* 52
 Mike WoodMr George GallowayMr Andrew Pelling
   That this House notes that the levels of obesity in the United Kingdom continue to increase with serious implications for the quality of life of millions of people and for the National Health Service; welcomes the publication on 2 June 2009 by the National Obesity Forum of Medical Management During Effect Weight Loss as a useful tool which provides outline guidance for healthcare practitioners caring for patients during effective weight loss following surgical interventions and non-surgical methods such as drugs, part-formula low calorie diets and very low-calorie diets; believes that this publication will be a valuable resource for general practitioners to enable them to give the best possible advice to patients seeking and achieving significant weight loss based on sound science and best medical evidence; and congratulates the authors, Dr David Haslam, Dr Colin Waine and Dr Anthony Leeds on their work.


1583CENTENARY CELEBRATIONS AT THE NATIONAL MUSEUM OF SCIENCE AND INDUSTRY3:6:09
John McDonnell
Mr Marsha Singh
Lynne Jones
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Kelvin Hopkins
Jeremy Corbyn
* 47
 Mike WoodMrs Joan HumbleJulie Morgan
 Mr Roger WilliamsMr David AndersonMartin Horwood
   That this House expresses its concern over pay awards for staff at the National Museum of Science and Industry (NMSI), which includes the Science Museum in London, the National Railway Museum in York and the National Media Museum in Bradford, during a period of great success for the institution and especially when NMSI is celebrating its centenary; notes that management has imposed a pay offer for the third year running, despite its rejection by trade unions; further notes that staff pay scales have been frozen at the top for three years and at the bottom for five years, resulting in many staff receiving derisory non-consolidated awards in the last two years; acknowledges that many employees who meet targets have received a less than one per cent. pay rise in total for each of the last two years; is concerned that staff below the maximum have received half of their 2009-10 pay award on a non-consolidated basis, which is in stark contrast to substantial bonuses paid to some NMSI senior executives in 2007-08; and calls on the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport to urgently intervene to resolve this dispute, with the help of the Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service if necessary, to bring an end to minimal pay increases based on a biased performance appraisal system and also to address the continuing damage being done to staff morale, so it does not cause harm to the NMSI role as guardian and interpreter of the nation's industrial and scientific heritage.


1585DAY OF THE AFRICAN CHILD (No. 2)3:6:09
Bob Spink
Jeremy Corbyn
Andrew George
Mr Martin Caton
John Cummings
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
* 36
 John Mason
   That this House commemorates 16 June 2009 as the Day of the African Child; notes with concern that across the globe, 9.2 million children die before the age of five each year; supports the Save the Children global child survival campaign which aims to ensure that the global community achieves Millennium Development Goal 4; and calls on the G8 leaders assembling in Italy to declare that no low-income country in Africa or elsewhere with a credible plan to reduce maternal, newborn and child mortality should fail to achieve these objectives for a lack of donor resources.


1586CONVENT OF THE SISTERS OF MERCY3:6:09
Mr Jim McGovern
Mrs Ann Cryer
Nigel Griffiths
Mr Ian McCartney
Mr Phil Willis
Jim Dowd
* 20
 Mr Paul Murphy
   That this House notes that the Convent of the Sisters of Mercy was founded in Dundee in 1859; further notes that the Sisters were responsible for educating many in the city, not least females and the poor; further notes that their contribution to education in the city continued through many primary schools and especially in Lawside Academy; and congratulates the community at Lawside Convent on their 150th anniversary and wishes them continued success in the future.


1587CHICKEN FARMING AND MAXIMUM PERMITTED STOCKING DENSITY3:6:09
Mr Adrian Sanders
Kelvin Hopkins
Bob Russell
Bob Spink
Robert Key
John Hemming
* 49
 John Mason
   That this House notes with concern the proposed regulation to increase the maximum permitted stocking density for chickens from the recommended 15 to 17 to 17 to 19 chickens per square metre, with a further extension to 19 to 21 chickens if certain criteria are met; further notes that The Scientific Committee on Animal Health and Animal Welfare record that when stocking rates exceed 30 kg per square metre welfare problems are likely to occur regardless of indoor climate control capacity; further believes that higher stocking densities result in an increase in pathologies, reduce behavioural activities and severely affect walking ability; and calls on the Government to exclude the derogation in the EU Directive that allows member states to permit extreme stocking densities above 17 to 19 chickens per square metre from UK legislation and not to abandon its previous recommended stocking density of 15 to 17 chickens per square metre, thereby permitting chicken welfare standards to be reduced.


1589BREATHE EASY WEEK 20093:6:09
Kelvin Hopkins
Bob Spink
Sir Peter Soulsby
Paul Rowen
Glenda Jackson
Chris McCafferty
* 60
 Willie Rennie
   That this House supports the British Lung Foundation's Love Your Lungs campaign for Breathe Easy Week 2009; praises the work of the Breathe Easy patient support network in providing help and information for people living with a lung condition and their carers; notes that less than a quarter of the estimated 3.7 million people in the UK with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) have been diagnosed with the disease; calls on the Government to assess the benefits of incorporating spirometry testing into the new screening programme in order to ensure more people with a lung condition get an early diagnosis; recognises the importance of pulmonary rehabilitation for people with COPD, but observes that in many areas of the UK there is insufficient access to these courses and that they are not adequately funded; believes that more needs to be done to ensure that pulmonary rehabilitation is available to everyone who could benefit from it; eagerly awaits the publication of the clinical strategy for COPD; and urges the full implementation of the strategy in order to ensure an improved quality of life for all people with the disease.


1590ASBESTOS IN DOMESTIC DWELLINGS3:6:09
Mr Michael Clapham
Colin Burgon
Jim Sheridan
Mr Peter Kilfoyle
Mr David Anderson
Mr Eric Illsley
* 80
 Mr Anthony Wright
   That this House welcomes the survey, As Safe as Houses, commissioned by UCATT and researched and written by Dr. Linda Waldman and Heather Williams; notes that the study has uncovered deficiencies in the management of asbestos in domestic dwellings; proposes the situation be improved and tenants and maintenance workers protected by extending the duty to manage asbestos to the internal part of the properties and all identified asbestos to be recorded in a register; recommends that all power tools carry a warning to remind users of the potential danger of asbestos and that apprenticeship training courses for construction workers contain modules on asbestos risks and protection procedures; and calls of the Health and Safety Executive to review its campaign to raise awareness of asbestos amongst maintenance workers to include some of the report's recommendations.


1591SCOUT MOVEMENT AND RECRUITMENT OF ADULT VOLUNTEERS3:6:09
Bob Russell
Mr David Amess
Stephen Pound
Bob Spink
John Hemming
Dr Brian Iddon
* 52
 Sandra GidleyMr Malcolm MossWillie Rennie
   That this House warmly welcomes the latest membership figures from the Scout Association which show the growing popularity of Scouting; notes the record number of girls involved in Scouting, with girls now matching boys in numbers joining the Movement; notes the rising number of adult volunteers; also notes the waiting list of 30,000 young people wanting to join the Scouts; recognises that without more adult volunteers this waiting list is likely to grow; welcomes the Government's recognition of the many benefits associated with volunteering in gaining skills and experience; calls on the Government to better signpost volunteering for job seekers as a means to enhance their career prospects; and urges the Government to explicitly promote the benefits of volunteering for youth organisations for people of all ages so that they can continue to grow to meet the needs of young people.


1592CHIEF SCOUT BEAR GRYLLS3:6:09
Bob Russell
Mr David Amess
Stephen Pound
Bob Spink
John Hemming
Dr Brian Iddon
* 38
 Mr Malcolm MossWillie Rennie
   That this House congratulates Bear Grylls on his appointment as the next Chief Scout and acknowledges that under the leadership of the current Chief Scout, Peter Duncan, over the last five years the Scout Association's youth and adult membership has grown by more than 36,000.


1593UN DECADE OF ACTION FOR GLOBAL ROAD SAFETY3:6:09
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
Dr Brian Iddon
Glenda Jackson
Jeremy Corbyn
Lynne Jones
* 43
 Mr Malcolm MossAlun MichaelDavid Cairns
   That this House welcomes the proposal of the Commission for Global Road Safety, chaired by Lord Robertson of Port Ellen, for a United Nations Decade of Action for Global Road Safety with a global target to reduce the forecast 2020 level of road deaths by 50 per cent., potentially saving five million lives and avoiding 50 million serious injuries; strongly urges the Government to support the proposed decade of action during the forthcoming debate in the 64th Session of the UN General Assembly and to play a leading role in the first UN global Ministerial Meeting on Road Safety to be held in Moscow on 19-20 November 2009; recognises that road injury prevention has been a neglected issue of sustainable development and notes with concern that road crashes kill more than 1.3 million people every year mainly in low and middle income countries; calls on the Department for International Development actively to support the work of the World Bank's global Road Safety Facility and, in particular, to encourage all multilateral and bilateral donors to include in all road construction and rehabilitation projects they finance, a budget allocation dedicated to safety rating, assessment and infrastructure improvement; and encourages all UN Member States to take concerted action to make roads safe by promoting seat belt and helmet use, discouraging drink driving and inappropriate speed, encouraging further investment in safer motor vehicles and roads, and prioritising the protection of vulnerable road users.


1594GAY PRIDE PROTESTS IN MOSCOW3:6:09
Ms Diane Abbott
John Hemming
Glenda Jackson
Chris McCafferty
Jeremy Corbyn
Lynne Jones
* 31
 John Mason
   That this House is concerned at reports that a gay pride rally in Moscow was violently ended by police officers; notes that the protest had been banned by city authorities on the grounds of preventing `moral degradation'; recognises the right to protest peacefully; further recognises that, whilst homosexuality is no longer illegal in Russia, there are no anti-discrimination or harassment laws to protect homosexual men or women; and calls on the Government to use its membership of the Council of Europe to press for an improvement to gay rights in Russia.


1596HUMAN TRAFFICKING4:6:09
Ms Diane Abbott
Peter Bottomley
Lynne Jones
Mr Martin Caton
Bob Spink
Mr Robert N. Wareing
* 51
 Sandra Gidley
   That this House welcomes the entry into force of the Council of Europe Convention on Human Trafficking; notes that the Convention obliges signatories to `protect victims of trafficking and safeguard their rights'; notes that at present the Government only provides specialised accommodation for 54 victims of trafficking and then that they must be female, over 18 years old, and victims of trafficking for sexual exploitation or domestic work; is concerned that victims of all types of human trafficking need protection and support; is further concerned that the Government continues to remove vulnerable people who have been victims of trafficking from the country; and calls on the Government to widen its range of specialised support for victims of trafficking and to give special consideration to the immigration claims of victims of trafficking.


1597BUS SERVICES4:6:09
Greg Mulholland
Lynne Jones
Mr Martin Caton
Graham Stringer
Mr David Clelland
Mr Mike Hancock
* 24
 Jo Swinson
   That this House welcomes the research carried out by Metro, the transport body, and notes with regret its findings which show the number of fare-paying bus passengers in West Yorkshire could drop by more than five per cent. in general and as much as 10 per cent. on certain routes due to fare increases, reductions in frequency and major services cuts; recognises the importance of affordable and frequent bus travel in providing essential and ecologically sound transport for all sectors of society; laments that in too many cases, as in West Yorkshire, bus operators hold local monopolies leaving passengers with few alternative options; condemns the decision of bus operator First to increase fares and cut services despite a reported profit increase of 9.8 per cent. in the last year; and urges the Government to put pressure on transport operators, obliging them to take account of passengers' needs.


1598UNITED STATES NUCLEAR NON-PROLIFERATION POLICY AND THE UNITED KINGDOM4:6:09
Jeremy Corbyn
Peter Bottomley
Lynne Jones
Mr Martin Caton
Bob Spink
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
* 42
 Harry CohenDr Doug Naysmith
   That this House warmly welcomes the statement on 5 May 2009 on behalf of the US administration by Rose Gottemoeller, Assistant Secretary at the US State Department's Bureau of Verification, Compliance, and Implementation and Head of the US Delegation to the Preparatory Committee of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) review conference held at the UN Headquarters in May 2009; additionally welcomes President Obama's personal statement in support of progressive non-proliferation measures conveyed to the Preparatory Committee, particularly his statement that `we must define ourselves not by our differences, but by our readiness to pursue dialogue and hard work to ensure the NPT continues to make an enduring contribution to international peace and security'; notes that President Obama has stressed that the US prioritises the agreement on a new treaty that verifiably ends production of fissile materials intended for use in nuclear weapons, called a Fissile Material Cut-off Treaty; believes that existing so-called civil stockpiles of plutonium, including the 108,000 kilogrammes at Sellafield, must be covered by such a treaty; further welcomes the US administration's call that nuclear weapons states outside the NPT be brought inside the Treaty with, in Ms Gottemoeller's words, `universal adherence to the NPT itself - including by India, Israel, Pakistan and North Korea - a fundamental objective of the United States'; and calls on the Government to work in partnership with the US administration to achieve a secure world without nuclear weapons.


1599SKILLS IN THE RETAIL SECTOR4:6:09
Nick Harvey
Mr David Crausby
Mr Colin Breed
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mrs Joan Humble
Mrs Betty Williams
* 52
 Sandra GidleyFrank DobsonMr Edward Davey
 Dr Kim HowellsMr Dai HavardLynne Featherstone
 Willie Rennie
   That this House notes that the retail sector, as the largest private sector employer in the UK, employing 1 in 10 of the workforce, has created more new jobs in the last five years than any other sector; recognises that a skilled workforce is essential in maintaining the ongoing success of the retail sector, and that during a recession it is essential that retailers are supported in maintaining their investment in the skills of their workforce; and acknowledges the work of Skillsmart Retail, the Sector Skills Council for Retail, in working with retailers to invest in skills through its new National Skills Academy for Retail, the biggest network of retail skills shops in the UK.


1601CROWD CONTROL TECHNIQUES8:6:09
Ms Diane Abbott
Peter Bottomley
Mr Martin Caton
Mark Lazarowicz
Lynne Jones
Mr Colin Breed
* 27
 Harry Cohen
   That this House is concerned at the increased use of the kettle technique by police when managing large protests; notes that the kettle technique involves penning people into a confined area surrounded by riot police; further notes the use of the kettle technique during the recent protests around the G20 Summit; recognises that many innocent protesters are trapped within these pens for hours at a time; believes that preventing people from leaving the kettle, denying people access to food, water and toilet facilities, and using force to keep people in the kettle is wrong; is further concerned that the right to protest peacefully is being curtailed by the use of the kettle technique; and calls on the Government to take steps to protect the right of people to peacefully protest, whatever the outcome of current inquiries into the protests around the G20 Summit.


1603POLITICAL PRISONERS IN LAOS8:6:09
Tom Levitt
Mr Oliver Letwin
Lorely Burt
Peter Bottomley
Bob Russell
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 46
 Mr Elliot MorleyMr David Laws
   That this House expresses profound concern about the human rights situation in Laos; notes that political prisoners continue to be held in detention in harsh conditions; condemns the continuing imprisonment after more than nine years of peaceful protestors Thongpaseuth Keuakoun, Seng-Aloun Phengphanh and Bouavanh Chanhmanivong; calls for a review of the charges against ethnic Hmong Thao Moua and Pa Fue Khang, imprisoned after a politically-motivated trial in June 2003 for their involvement with European journalists in researching a news story about the plight of the Hmong hiding in the jungles of Laos; further condemns the refusal of the Lao government to allow independent observers, including UN agencies, to monitor the situation of Lao Hmong refugees and asylum seekers returned to Laos from Thailand during the past three years; and further calls on the Government to draw these violations of human rights to the urgent attention of the UN.


1604COVENTRY RAPE AND SEXUAL ABUSE CENTRE8:6:09
Mr Jim Cunningham
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Lynne Jones
Robert Key
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 48
 Ms Diane AbbottShona McIsaacHugh Bayley
 Mr Don TouhigDavid HowarthMr Andy Slaughter
 Lynne Featherstone
   That this House commends the work of Coventry Rape and Sexual Abuse Centre, The Rape Crisis Network and the 38 groups in England and Wales that it acts as an umbrella organisation for, which support victims of rape, sexual abuse, sexual violence and incest; acknowledges the selfless dedication of the workforce of such organisations, who are often volunteers; further acknowledges the challenge these groups face in attaining sustainable funding for their work; and calls on all areas and levels of Government to work together to ensure the Rape Crisis Network and the organisations it supports have the financial backing needed.


1605ARGYLL ARCADE8:6:09
Mr Mohammad Sarwar
Michael Connarty
Lynne Jones
Emily Thornberry
Mr Jim Hood
Mr David Hamilton
* 23
 John Mason
   That this House condemns the recent attempts by a single individual to claim sole and exclusive rights to the name Argyle Arcade and to profit at the expense of other traders in that shopping mall in Glasgow; recognises that the Argyle Arcade, built in the Victorian era, is Scotland's oldest indoor shopping mall and has supplied, in particular, items of fine jewellery, to several generations of Glaswegians; and further recognises that the owners and traders therein have provided a popular service for over one hundred years often by longstanding, family run firms.


1607WORLD TRADE WEEK UK8:6:09
Lorely Burt
Bob Russell
Peter Bottomley
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Lynne Jones
Mr Colin Breed
* 33
 Sandra GidleyMr Alistair CarmichaelJo Swinson
   That this House celebrates this year's World Trade Week UK which is taking place between 9 and 12 June; notes that trade and competition are the cornerstones of UK economic prosperity and of particular importance during an economic downturn, which it is feared may result in driving exports down by roughly nine per cent. in volume terms in 2009, representing the biggest contraction since the Second World War; and encourages the Government to do all that it can to further support trade and investment in the United Kingdom, and in particular to assist small and medium-sized businesses in attracting inward investment and exporting their goods and services globally.


1608COVANTA ENERGY8:6:09
John McDonnell
Bob Russell
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Lynne Jones
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 20
 Patrick Hall
   That this House is concerned that Covanta Energy, a US-based waste incineration company, is proposing to build incinerators in Bedfordshire, Buckinghamshire, Cheshire, Lancashire, the North of Ireland and Wales; notes that regulators in the US have frequently cited Covanta for illegal air pollution, that the US National Labor Relations Board has issued a complaint against illegal work rules at all of Covanta's US locations, and that Covanta has failed to sign a collective agreement with the Utility Workers Union of America in Rochester, Massachusetts, despite workers there having voted for union represention in May 2008; and therefore urges the Government to prioritise the health and welfare of both the public and workers by denying any Covanta application in the UK, unless it demonstrates full compliance with environmental and labour standards in all countries in which it conducts business.


1609INCOME SUPPORT8:6:09
John McDonnell
Peter Bottomley
Mr Martin Caton
Lynne Jones
Mrs Ann Cryer
Mr Dai Davies
* 35
 Mr Stephen HepburnJohn Mason
   That this House condemns the proposed abolition of income support which is a crucial lifeline against destitution and poverty for parents, carers, those they care for and other vulnerable people; further condemns the requirement contained in the Welfare Reform Bill that claimants with children over seven years old must find a job or work for their benefits for £1.73 an hour if they are unsuccessful in finding work after two years; notes that unemployment has risen to over two million and that many parents cannot access affordable childcare in their area; deplores this erosion of the principles of the welfare state and the minimum wage, and regrets the hardship that many families will now face; and calls on the Government to maintain income support in recognition of society's collective responsibility for childrearing and the important work of carers and parents for society.


1610BAKERS' ASTHMA8:6:09
John McDonnell
Mr David Crausby
Mrs Linda Riordan
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr David Anderson
Kelvin Hopkins
* 56
 Willie Rennie
   That this House notes with concern that bakers are about 80 times more likely to develop occupational asthma than the average worker due to exposure to flour and other bakery dusts; believes that every worker has the right to work in a healthy and safe workplace and is extremely alarmed that thousands of bakers could be at risk of developing an incapacitating respiratory condition; urges employers to work with health and safety trades union representatives and the Bakers, Food and Allied Workers Union to implement appropriate control measures to protect bakers from developing asthma; and further urges the Government to consider reducing the maximum exposure limit to flour and to ensure that the Health and Safety Executive has sufficient resources to take the necessary action to prevent work-related illnesses such as bakers' asthma.


1613HAMPERED BY HORMONES CAMPAIGN8:6:09
Dr Howard Stoate
Bob Russell
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Graham Stringer
* 66
 Mr Edward DaveyJim DowdHugh Bayley
 Dr Brian IddonGreg MulhollandDavid T. C. Davies
   That this House congratulates The Prostate Cancer Charity on launching the Hampered by hormones campaign which aims to address the needs of men with prostate cancer receiving hormone therapy; notes that the side effects of hormone therapy can have a significant impact on men's lives; expresses concern that research undertaken by the charity shows that over half of men are receiving too little information and support to help them manage the side effects of hormone therapy and are not receiving the standard of care and support they are entitled to; calls on the Government to ensure the full implementation of guidance from the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence relating to the care of men with prostate cancer; and further calls on the Government and the National Cancer Survivorship Initiative to review the charity's research findings and campaign recommendations and take action to improve the care of men living on hormone therapy.


1614FUEL POVERTY (No. 2) BILL8:6:09
Dr Alan Whitehead
Mr Paul Truswell
Ms Karen Buck
Mr Martin Caton
Colin Challen
Mr David Drew
* 108
 Dr Desmond TurnerDr Gavin StrangAlbert Owen
 Mrs Siân C. JamesJohn Mason
   That this House remains concerned about the problem of fuel poverty; notes that the Fuel Poverty Bill introduced by the hon. Member for Somerton and Frome did not get a Second Reading on 20 March 2009; further notes that the Government's objections were the absolutist nature of the Bill and its possible inconsistency with the Government's own home refurbishment plan as set out in the Heat and Energy Savings Strategy; believes, however, that these two objections have been overcome in the Fuel Poverty (No. 2) Bill introduced by a group of Labour hon. Members; calls upon the Government to support the Fuel Poverty (No. 2) Bill, which will help them to deliver not only on their manifesto pledges to end fuel poverty but also the provisions of their Heat and Energy Saving Strategy; and therefore hopes that the Bill will become law in the current Session of Parliament.


1615ARRHYTHMIA AWARENESS WEEK9:6:09
Mr John Maples
Mr Lee Scott
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Bob Russell
* 78
 Dr Desmond TurnerSandra GidleyMs Diane Abbott
 Harry CohenMr Paul KeetchMike Wood
 Lembit ÖpikNorman LambMr Alistair Carmichael
 John HemmingJenny WillottMrs Linda Riordan
 Willie Rennie
   That this House congratulates Arrhythmia Alliance, the Heart Rhythm Charity, a coalition of healthcare professionals, patients and carers to promote better understanding, diagnosis, treatment and quality of life of individuals with cardiac arrhythmias, or heart rhythm disorders, for organising Arrhythmia Awareness Week from 8 to 14 June 2009; welcomes the Know Your Pulse initiative which aims to encourage people to have their pulse checked; notes that more than one per cent. of the population is affected by atrial flutter (AF), the most common type of heart rhythm disturbance; recognises that people with AF have a dramatically reduced quality of life and face long-term serious complications including a high risk of having a stroke; further notes that 100,000 sudden cardiac deaths occur each year due to cardiac arrhythmias, and that 120,000 unexplained incidences of loss of consciousness occur due to cardiac arrhythmia; believes that the early identification of heart rhythm disorders is crucial in reducing the number of premature deaths from heartbeat disorders; and calls on the Government to make heart rhythm disorders a priority by ensuring pulse checks are taken during a routine visit to a GP surgery, to promote timely diagnosis and treatment of heart rhythm disorders.


1616DEBT AND LOW INCOME HOUSEHOLDS IN SCOTLAND9:6:09
Mark Lazarowicz
Peter Bottomley
Mr Ian McCartney
Mr John Leech
Mr Gregory Campbell
David Simpson
* 23
 Michael ConnartyJim SheridanMrs Linda Riordan
 John Mason
   That this House notes the publication of Drowning in Debt: Scottish CAB Clients and Debt, by Citizens Advice Scotland; is concerned that the average debt levels for Citizens Advice Bureaux (CAB) debt clients seeking advice from their local CAB is £20,193, a 50 per cent. rise since 2003; further notes that the report highlights the bleak reality for low income households in debt, including the finding that debt has had a negative impact on health for nine out of 10 debt clients; is further concerned at the increasingly ruthless behaviour adopted by creditors in seeking debt repayment, which at times has been unlawful; applauds Citizens Advice Bureaux in Scotland for the free, confidential and impartial frontline advice they have provided to the people of Scotland for the last 70 years; recognises their successes in pressing for improvements in public policy; and urges the Government to assist indebted households like those mentioned in the report by pursuing the report's recommendations to curb unreasonable creditor behaviour, increase access to affordable credit and ensure that advice services are appropriately resourced.


1617SUPPORT FOR HILL FARMERS9:6:09
Tim Farron
Bob Spink
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Peter Bottomley
Jim Dobbin
Ann Winterton
* 36
 Sandra GidleyMr Malcolm MossJo Swinson
 Mrs Linda Riordan
   That this House opposes the decision of the House of Lords European Union Committee to back European Commission proposals to reform the definition of less favoured areas, which would mean that from 2013 the socio-economic criteria for support would be removed; believes that this would put many upland farmers in a position where they could not receive payments and would therefore endure hardship leading in many cases to people leaving the industry; acknowledges that hill farmers are the guardians of our historic upland landscapes and are the key to the preservation of biodiversity, the management of waterways, the production of food and the delivery of a huge range of environmental benefits; and calls on the Secretary of State for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs to oppose the removal of the socio-economic criteria and to campaign for fairer support for the UK's hill farmers.


1618DAIRY FARMERS OF BRITAIN9:6:09
Tim Farron
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Peter Bottomley
Jim Dobbin
Lynne Jones
Ann Winterton
* 73
 Sandra GidleyMr John GroganMr Eric Martlew
 Mr Martyn JonesNick AingerMr Jim Hood
 Mr Michael MooreAlbert OwenJo Swinson
 Mrs Linda RiordanDavid T. C. Davies
   That this House is appalled by the collapse of Dairy Farmers of Britain which went into receivership owing £50 million to its 1,800 members; is deeply concerned that the impact on the UK dairy industry and on individual dairy farmers and their families will be devastating; deplores the banks' deliberate timing of the calling in of the loan to Dairy Farmers of Britain, causing the calling in of the receivers to maximise the benefit to secured creditors at the expense of those member farmers' May milk cheques; calls on the Government to underwrite the payments that Dairy Farmers of Britain were due to pay to dairy farmers for milk supplied in May or to force Dairy Farmers of Britain's bankers to pay the May milk cheques; also calls on the Secretary of State for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and the Prime Minister to intervene to ensure that buyers do not exploit stricken dairy farmers by paying sub-market prices; and endorses the Farmers Guardian petition which urges the dairy industry's biggest customers to both buy British and to ensure that dairy farmers receive a fair return for their produce.


1619PUBLICATION OF SALARIES AND REMUNERATION PACKAGES PAID FROM PUBLIC FUNDS9:6:09
Mr Roger Godsiff
Jim Dobbin
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Ronnie Campbell
Paul Flynn
Mark Durkan
* 22
 Mrs Linda RiordanGreg MulhollandJohn Mason
   That this House recognises the understandable public interest which has been generated by the publication of salaries and expenses of hon. Members; believes that all salaries and remuneration packages paid to individuals, either directly or indirectly, from public funds exceeding three times the current national average wage of £25,123, during the tax year 2008-09, should be placed in the public domain and made available for public scrutiny; and further believes that this practice should be implemented and the figures up-rated as a standard requirement for each future tax year.


1620BEATSON PEBBLE APPEAL9:6:09
Jo Swinson
Peter Bottomley
Lynne Jones
Mr John Leech
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Martin Caton
* 18
 Mrs Linda RiordanJohn Mason
   That this House supports the Beatson Pebble Appeal, a £10 million campaign to raise funds to build the Beatson Translational Research Centre which will foster collaboration between scientists and clinical researchers to improve existing cancer therapies and develop new treatments; notes that more than one in three people in the UK will be diagnosed with some form of cancer in their lifetime and that cancer causes one in four deaths in the UK, but that cancer research has been instrumental in reducing the overall cancer death rate by 10 per cent. over the last decade; further notes that translational research bridges that chasm between scientific discovery and successful patient treatment and that this facility will greatly enhance the capability of the Glasgow Centre for Cancer Research; and praises the efforts of the Pebble Appeal to raise the additional funds required to build this exceptional facility.


1623FORENSIC SCIENCE SERVICE9:6:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Colin Burgon
Jim Dobbin
Peter Bottomley
Lynne Jones
* 54
 Mr Mark OatenMs Diane AbbottDr Doug Naysmith
 Mrs Joan HumbleGeraldine SmithMr George Howarth
 Mrs Louise EllmanSir Alan BeithLembit Öpik
 Michael ConnartyMrs Linda RiordanDavid T. C. Davies
   That this House notes with concern the announcement made by the Forensic Science Service of a restructuring of the business which will lead to redundancies with an estimated 30 to 40 per cent. of the workforce due to lose their jobs; recognises the first class service provided by the Forensic Science Service which is the market leader in the supply of forensic services to police forces in England and Wales and which has a global reputation for excellence in the developement and deployment of new and advanced techniques; further notes that the Forensic Science Service provides world class training services which all help to provide a comprehensive service, from crime scene to court room, and analyses more than 120,000 cases each year; believes that large job losses will damage this service and result in a loss of valuable skills; and calls on the Government to enter discussions immediately with the Forensic Science Service in order to avoid unnecessary job losses and maintain the skill base which ensure the Forensic Science Service is a world leader.


1625GUN AND KNIFE CRIME AND SERIOUS FEATHER'S THINK TWICE VIDEO9:6:09
Tony Lloyd
Jim Dobbin
Lynne Jones
Mr Ian McCartney
Peter Bottomley
Mr Ronnie Campbell
* 34
 Mrs Linda Riordan
   That this House recognises that young people are most likely to be the victims of gun and knife attacks; believes that whilst everyone must be part of the solution, young people are key to changing attitudes and saving lives; welcomes the release of Marvin `Crown Jewelz' Gilbert's video Think Twice which is designed to bring attention to the dangers of gun and knife attacks; applauds the work of the Manchester-based production company Serious Feather which commissioned and released the video without charge; notes the work of young people in education at Trafford College and Salford and Bolton universities which made all this possible; commends the efforts of Brett Gregory, Ann-Marie Lawrence, Nic Jackson and Alistair Topping; and hopes that the video will be widely viewed and promoted by the media.


1626MANCHESTER ACADEMY AND EASY MONEY GUIDE FOR YOUNG PEOPLE9:6:09
Tony Lloyd
Jim Dobbin
Lynne Jones
Mr Ian McCartney
Peter Bottomley
Paul Flynn
* 22
 Mrs Linda Riordan
   That this House notes that during a worldwide recession young people acquiring sound financial knowledge and information is a strong foundation for recovery and future strength; applauds young enterprise programmes in schools as a creative and engaging form of academic development for young people; applauds the hard work of Manchester Academy and its students in producing the Easy Money guide for young people; welcomes a readable and highly lucid publication, providing a clear and easily understood financial guide for Britain's youth; congratulates the ingenuity and talent of the founding members of Golden Moment Ltd, Wayne Ramwell, Mohtasham Qureshi, Kevin Yap, Kaif Hussain and Muhammed Saleem, who co-authored the book; believes that simple and comprehensible money advice is important for all young people; and commends the work of Golden Moment Ltd as a shining example of social entrepreneurship serving the wider community interest.


1627REFORM OF THE SPEAKERSHIP AND SELECT COMMITTEES10:6:09
Mr Edward Leigh
Alun Michael
Mark Fisher
Mr Iain Duncan Smith
Dr John Pugh
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 97
 Sandra GidleyMr Malcolm MossHugh Bayley
 Mr Michael MeacherMr Gordon PrenticeMr Alistair Carmichael
 David HowarthMrs Linda RiordanMr Douglas Carswell
 John Mason
   That this House believes that the Government should not control all the time on the floor of the House; considers that Parliament should be reinstated as an independent forum by empowering the Speaker, select committees and backbenchers; further believes that the Speaker, through a business committee of the whole House, should determine a significant part of debate on the floor of the House, whilst leaving adequate time for the Government to get its business through, to enable select committees and hon. Members to make substantive motions as well as Government and opposition parties; further believes that the Speaker should effectively become the non-partisan manager of the House, liaising with Government and opposition business managers; further considers that select committees, as well as scrutinising Government departments, should be upgraded to an advice and consent role on senior public appointments; further believes that Government should have to respond in detail to all select committee recommendations; further considers that select committee chairs should be selected by secret ballot of the whole House within the context of party balance; and further believes that select committees should be entitled to receive the kind of support from the National Audit Office and the Scrutiny Unit currently given to the Public Accounts Committee.


1629VETERANS AND POST-TRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER10:6:09
Mr John Leech
Peter Bottomley
Bob Russell
Bob Spink
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Andrew George
* 47
 Sandra GidleyMrs Iris RobinsonDavid Howarth
 Jo SwinsonMrs Linda RiordanWillie Rennie
   That this House recognises the psychological toll that conflict operations can have on members of the armed forces; notes that according to Combat Stress: the Ex-Services Mental Welfare Society approximately 60 per cent. of British veterans suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder; is concerned that in 2008 referrals relating to the condition were up eight per cent. on the previous year and up 66 per cent. on 2005 levels; applauds the work of organisations like Combat Stress who since 1919 have provided support to almost 100,000 veterans of every British armed forces campaign; and calls on the Government actively to address the issue of war trauma and look at further ways of assisting armed services veterans to make an integrated return to civilian society.


1630ARRIVA AND SHREWSBURY RAILWAY STATION10:6:09
Daniel Kawczynski
Lynne Jones
Mrs Ann Cryer
Jeremy Corbyn
Norman Baker
Mr John Leech
* 7
 Mrs Linda Riordan
   That this House welcomes the assurance from the Commercial Director of Arriva Trains, Mr Mike Bagshaw, that he will visit Shrewsbury station; and notes that he accepts that the aesthetic condition of the buildings and environs are unacceptable and further accepts Arriva Trains' responsibility to clean up and modernise the train station to a standard appropriate to Shrewsbury station.


1631OCCUPATIONAL PENSIONS10:6:09
Bob Spink
Mark Durkan
Andrew George
Jim Dobbin
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr David Drew
* 10
 John Mason
   That this House acknowledges the frustration felt by more than 125,000 people who lost their occupational pensions between 1997 and 2005; notes with dismay that the compensation they receive through the Financial Assistance Scheme declines in real value every year and is far less than the promised 90 per cent. of accruement; and believes that the Government should fulfil its obligation to correct this injustice by increasing the Financial Assistance Scheme Cap and indexing pre-1997 pension compensation by inflation.


1633SUPPORTING YOUNG CARERS OFSTED SURVEY10:6:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Jim Dobbin
Mr Nigel Evans
Bob Spink
Mark Durkan
* 52
 Jim DowdMr Bill OlnerHugh Bayley
 Tony LloydMr David ClellandMrs Linda Riordan
   That this House notes with concern the findings of Ofsted's Supporting Young Carers survey; expresses concern that despite the recent reforms to children's services, many children and young people who care for their disabled parents are often unidentified, unsupported and without a voice; further notes with concern the low level of awareness by local authorities and their partners of the number of young carers in their area and that they do not consider their needs when providing services for disabled parents; further notes with concern that young carers surveyed were unaware of their right to request an assessment; believes that this situation is unacceptable and lets down these young people; and calls on the Government to ensure that the recommendations set out by Ofsted are implemented without delay and for the Government to develop a national strategy for young carers in order better to meet their needs.


1634POLICE COMMUNITY SUPPORT OFFICERS10:6:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Jim Dobbin
Bob Spink
John Mann
Mr Mike Hancock
* 42
 Tom LevittMr Eddie McGradyMrs Linda Riordan
   That this House welcomes the valuable role and contribution made by police community support officers (PCSO) in supporting police officers by providing a visible presence and in helping to improve the quality of life in communities; believes that the role of police officers is distinct and different and that PCSOs should support, not substitute, or infringe on the work of police officers; and urges the Government to launch a publicity drive to raise public awareness of PCSOs and the positive impact that they make in helping keep our towns, cities and communities safe.


1635PROTECTION OF THE TITLE OF DOCTOR10:6:09
John Mann
Mr David Drew
Lynne Jones
Kelvin Hopkins
Mrs Ann Cryer
Jeremy Corbyn
* 10
 Mrs Linda Riordan
   That this House notes the title of doctor is not a protected title; further notes that practitioners of complementary medicine have an important role in health care, but believes that the title doctor implies a background in scientific orthodox medicine; further believes that the use of the term doctor by practitioners of complementary medicine is misleading and confusing; further believes that the array of other qualifications a trained orthodox doctor may hold can also be confusing; and calls on the Government either to protect the title of doctor for British Medical Association registered and suitably qualified practitioners, or to introduce a simple and popularly recognisable scheme that will distinguish between different traditions and levels of scientific evidence behind medicine.


1636WESTMINSTER PARLIAMENTARY PASSES FOR MEMBERS OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND THEIR STAFF10:6:09
John Mann
Mr Andrew Dismore
Andrew Gwynne
Dr Desmond Turner
Jon Cruddas
Mr John Grogan
* 29
 John HemmingMrs Linda RiordanJohn Mason
   That this House notes that the number of parliamentary passes available for the staff of hon. Members and Peers is necessarily limited; further notes that Members of the European Parliament (MEPs) are allocated passes to the parliamentary estate, but that hon. Members are not allocated passes to the European Parliament; and believes that it is unnecessary for MEPs or their staff to be allocated House of Commons passes and that new MEPs should not therefore be issued with such passes.


1638ACCESS TO THE HOUSES OF PARLIAMENT FOR MEMBERS OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT10:6:09
John McDonnell
Kelvin Hopkins
David Taylor
Alan Simpson
Mr Neil Gerrard
Mike Wood
* 31
 John Mason
   That this House notes with concern that Members of the European Parliament (MEPs) are automatically given security passes to the Houses of Parliament; believes there is no reason why MEPs need such access to the Houses of Parliament; notes that members of the Scottish Parliament, the Welsh Assembly and the London Assembly are not given passes to the Houses of Parliament; further notes that Members of the UK Parliament are not given security passes to the European Parliament on a reciprocal basis; and therefore calls for an end to the practice of giving security passes to the Houses of Parliament to MEPs.


1639TRADING ARM OF THE NATIONAL MUSEUM OF SCIENCE AND INDUSTRY10:6:09
John McDonnell
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr David Drew
Jeremy Corbyn
Kelvin Hopkins
Alan Simpson
* 45
 Frank DobsonPaul FlynnJulie Morgan
 Mr Roger WilliamsMr David AndersonMartin Horwood
 Mr Andrew Pelling
   That this House deplores the attempts by the board and senior managers of the National Museum of Science and Industry (NMSI) to undermine the status of its staff as public servants through the misuse of its trading arm; notes that the clear intention of the legislation that enabled NMSI to create a trading company, the National Heritage Act 1983, was that the company would carry out commercial activities in support of museum activities, but not that it should be used as a tool to dismantle the terms and conditions of museum staff; calls on the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport to intervene immediately to bring an end to this practice; and asks that the Secretary of State re-assert the principle that the responsibility for collecting, caring for, and making available to the public the national heritage in scientific and industrial artefacts ought to reside in staff directly employed by and accountable to the state.


1640DISABLED CHILDREN AND HEALTH10:6:09
Mrs Joan Humble
Mrs Betty Williams
Mr Tom Clarke
Annette Brooke
Tom Levitt
Jane Kennedy
* 96
 Dr Phyllis StarkeyDr Desmond TurnerMr Simon Burns
 Mr Michael MatesSandra GidleyMr Mark Oaten
 Gwyn ProsserMr Michael FallonMr Peter Ainsworth
 Mr Humfrey MalinsMr Andrew LoveMs Diane Abbott
 Mike GapesMr Edward DaveyHarry Cohen
 Mr John HoramMr Don FosterRoger Berry
 Mr Robert WalterRobert KeyJoan Walley
 Mr Bill OlnerMr Richard ShepherdClare Short
 Mr David WinnickHugh BayleyMr George Howarth
 Mr Edward O'HaraMr Eric MartlewSir Alan Beith
 Mr Fraser KempDr Richard TaylorJohn Hemming
 David HowarthMrs Linda RiordanMr Angus MacNeil
   That this House welcomes the new report, Disabled Children and Health, produced by the Every Disabled Child Matters campaign, with the support of the Children's Trust, Tadworth; recognises the commitment made to children's health through the Healthy lives, brighter futures strategy; notes that this strategy confirms that primary care trusts in England have £340 million in their 2008-09 budgets for services for disabled children, including short breaks, community equipment, wheelchairs and palliative care, for which £30 million is earmarked specifically for children's palliative care; further notes with concern the evidence in Disabled Children and Health that disabled children have unequal access to health services and that there is confusion amongst primary care trusts regarding what is expected of them in relation to health services for disabled children and how to identify this specific funding locally; acknowledges the impact of missing out on health services on the child and families' ability to lead an ordinary life; and calls on the Department of Health, primary care trusts, local authorities and the health, social care and education inspectorates to respond positively to the recommendations in the Every Disabled Child Matters report in order to provide disabled children with health services that meet their needs.


1641ROYAL MAIL AND THE POSTAL SERVICES BILL10:6:09
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Jim Dobbin
Mr Bob Laxton
Colin Burgon
Mrs Joan Humble
* 69
 Mr Michael MeacherMr Joe BentonDr Gavin Strang
 Michael ConnartyMark LazarowiczMr Angus MacNeil
 John Mason
   That this House calls on the Government to withdraw the Postal Services Bill and the proposals to part-privatise Royal Mail; notes that since the publication of the Hooper Review, the environment in which Royal Mail operates has significantly changed and that subsequent analysis and reports examining the impact of the Government's proposals raises doubts over the benefits of part-privatisation; further notes that 75 per cent. of people oppose the part-privatisation of Royal Mail, with 60 per cent. of people saying it needs to be reformed but remain in the public sector; and calls on the Government to listen and respond to these wide-ranging concerns and re-examine their proposals to ensure that Royal Mail is modernised, not privatised, and remains a wholly publically-owned organisation.


1642FALKLAND ISLANDS LIBERATION DAY10:6:09
Andrew Rosindell
Geraldine Smith
Mr Henry Bellingham
Jim Dobbin
Lady Hermon
Mr Gerald Howarth
* 28
 Mrs Iris Robinson
   That this House notes that this year marks the 27th anniversary of the Falklands Islands conflict; recalls the magnificent sacrifices made by Her Majesty's armed forces in heroically liberating the Islands and securing the unconditional surrender of the Argentine forces who illegally invaded the Islands on 2 April 1982; remains resolutely dedicated to strengthening the historic ties between Britain and the Falkland Islands; reaffirms the continued support of the United Kingdom in maintaining the Islands as a self-governing British Overseas Territory; and looks forward to many more years of the Union Flag flying proudly above Stanley and throughout the Islands.


164312th ANNUAL NATIONAL CHILDCARE WEEK10:6:09
Mrs Joan Humble
Annette Brooke
Jane Kennedy
Tom Levitt
Mrs Louise Ellman
Jim Dobbin
* 54
 Mrs Iris RobinsonJenny WillottJulia Goldsworthy
 Mrs Linda Riordan
   That this House welcomes the 12th Annual National Childcare Week, organised by the Daycare Trust with the support of Children's Mutual; notes that the theme of the week is Foundations for the Future; and agrees that high quality and affordable childcare can build firm foundations for the future by giving children a good start in life, enabling their parents to work or train, and in the long term help to tackle social exclusion, create jobs and raise educational standards.


1644TROOPING THE COLOUR10:6:09
Andrew Rosindell
Geraldine Smith
Mr Henry Bellingham
Jim Dobbin
Mr Gerald Howarth
Ann Winterton
* 23
 Mrs Iris Robinson
   That this House looks forward to the 2009 Trooping the Colour ceremony on Saturday 13 June to mark the Official Birthday of Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II; notes with pride that the flags of all the nations of the Commonwealth are always displayed in and around Horse Guards Parade for this great occasion; and calls on the Government to ensure that the flags of all Her Majesty's Territories are also flown in time for the ceremony, including Her Majesty's Crown Dependencies of the Isle of Man. Jersey, Guernsey, Alderney and Sark, together with Her Majesty's Overseas Territories of Anguilla, Bermuda, British Antarctic Territory, British Indian Ocean Territory, British Virgin Islands, Cayman Islands, Falkland Islands, Gibraltar, Montserrat, Pitcairn, Henderson, Ducie and Ocno Islands, St. Helena, Ascension Island, Tristan da Cunha, South Georgia and the South Sandwich Islands and the Turks and Caicos Islands.


1645VAUXHALL MOTORS11:6:09
Andrew Miller
Kelvin Hopkins
Patrick Hall
Lynne Jones
Mr Martin Caton
Jim Dobbin
* 43
 Mr Bill OlnerMr David WinnickMr Dennis Skinner
 Mr Kevin BarronMr David CrausbyDr Brian Iddon
 Mr Ian